What 3 players would u want exchanged from ur team?

[Sudeep]

Yuvi is better with the bat and in the field.

That being said despite Yuvraj having played only four Tests, and Flintoff having improved eons in the last year?

 

[Sudeep]

In tests Yuvi can bowl a few tight overs and maybe even break partnerships. He's pretty handy.

Interesting comment, considering Yuvraj has picked up a grand total of ONE wicket.

 

[chicane]

Interesting comment, considering Yuvraj has picked up a grand total of ONE wicket.

I said MAYBE. Hope you can read it now.

 

[chicane]

That being said despite Yuvraj having played only four Tests, and Flintoff having improved eons in the last year?

So what? Yuvraj is far more talented with the bat. If he fails in tests like you're hoping for, we'll see then.

 

[Sudeep]

I said MAYBE. Hope you can read it now.

Yes, that's the point I'm arguing.

On what basis are you saying MAYBE?

 

[Sudeep]

So what? Yuvraj is far more talented with the bat. If he fails in tests like you're hoping for, we'll see then.

And far more unreliable because of his style.

 

[chicane]

Yes, that's the point I'm arguing.

On what basis are you saying MAYBE?

What the hell's there to argue about? Why can't he break partnerships?

 

[Sudeep]

What the hell's there to argue about? Why can't he break partnerships?

LOL.

I see a different point there.

Why can he?

 

[chicane]

And far more unreliable because of his style.

LOL and Flintoff's power play has been ultra relaible till recently has it? Don't write Yuvraj off so blatantly without having any clue about his enormous talent, and there's a very good chance he'll suceed.

 

[Sudeep]

LOL and Flintoff's power play has been ultra relaible till recently has it? Don't write Yuvraj off so blatantly without having any clue about his enormous talent, and there's a very good chance he'll suceed.

Is it just me or Flintoff really seems really good at defence too?

 

[chicane]

LOL.

I see a different point there.

Why can he?

He's shown his wicket taking ability in ODIs whenever given the opportunity. What the hell do you expect given he's been sparingly used over 4 tests?

 

[Sudeep]

He's shown his wicket taking ability in ODIs whenever given the opportunity. What the hell do you expect given he's been sparingly used over 4 tests?

ODIs and Tests - two completely different formats.

 

[chicane]

Is it just me or Flintoff really seems really good at defence too?

Recently? Yeah he's been outstanding. So what's your point man? Yuvraj has a sound technique as well.

 

[Sudeep]

Recently? Yeah he's been outstanding. So what's your point man? Yuvraj has a sound technique as well.

Not as sound as Flintoff, IMO.

 

[chicane]

ODIs and Tests - two completely different formats.

Oh it makes such a difference to a part time SLA doesn't it? Care to explain what? There will be slight difference but what you needed to understand from that was he is pretty tidy and he could occasionaly break partnerships.

 

[chicane]

Not as sound as Flintoff, IMO.

In your opinion, which obviously speaks of how blind you've been while watching(if at all) Yuvi bat.

 

[Sudeep]

Oh it makes such a difference to a part time SLA doesn't it? Care to explain what? There will be slight difference but what you needed to understand from that was he is pretty tidy and he could occasionaly break partnerships.

Occasionally.

Not regularly as Flintoff.

And that's the arguement for picking Flintoff for Yuvraj.

 

[Sudeep]

In your opinion, which obviously speaks of how blind you've been while watching(if at all) Yuvi bat.

Yes, we'll see how sound he is, when he opens against the likes of McGrath, Gillespie and Lee.

 

[chicane]

Occasionally.

Not regularly as Flintoff.

And that's the arguement for picking Flintoff for Yuvraj.

So can you please point out where I said Yuvraj is better than Flintoff at that? I only said he's a more talented batsman and one of the best fielders in the world, at the same time is handy with the ball.

 

[Sudeep]

So can you please point out where I said Yuvraj is better than Flintoff at that? I only said he's a more talented batsman and one of the best fielders in the world, at the same time is handy with the ball.

IMO,

Bowling: Flintoff >>> Yuvraj
Batting: Flintoff = Yuvraj
Fielding: Yuvraj > Flintoff

Which tilts it towards Flintoff.