Ok, I'll try and rate the players from what I've seen on Cricinfo, maybe someone who's seen the highlights or the match on TV could do one too?
Trescothick - A fine 85 and if he had not been run out by Shah, England would have stood a much greater chance of winning.
Knight - 42 runs, but the form he's in he should have carried on after getting in. Partnership with Trescothick still going well.
Hussain - Still thinks he should bat at 3. On this evidence he should think again.
Shah - Started off really slowly but picked up later in his innings before getting out. When he came in the run rate was still within reach but he put pressure on himself and the team and eventually got himself out after leaving himself with too much to do.
Collingwood - Got a wicket but was very expensive, his 3 overs going for 20. Only got 2 runs, still not sure where he fits into this team.
Stewart - Sawn off by Shah before he could get going.
Blackwell - Bowling was a bit expensive and got himself out trying to get the run rate down. Like Collingwood I am not sure where his best position is in this team.
Irani - Totally out of form with the ball. To be fair he is not a number 8 batsman but in this form he looks more like a number 11. Hasn't taken a Wicket in 2 games now, England appear to be carrying him.
Caddick - Bowled well for once with 2-29 off his 10 overs, and showed some spirit when the game was lost by slogging De Silva into the stand. He needs to do this more often though, and until he does he should not be an automatic pick.
Anderson - Again did well with the ball with another 2 Wickets, but was rather expensive. The ability is there to see though. I was not impressed with his batting, 1 off 11 balls is just not good enough, especially in the last overs of a ODI. Also he played an insane reverse sweep after facing 5 balls for no runs...someone tell him it's more likely to get him out than score any runs!
Harmison - Another 9 wides and 2 no balls to add to the collection. If he can't bowl it straight then he shouldn't be in the team, let alone the WC squad! Showed more fight with the bat than most, and with a bit of practise could be taught to slog a quick 20 odd which could be the difference between winning and loosing.