• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** India v Pakistan

biased indian

International Coach
Anil said:
bucknor is just someone who was a very good umpire...but now hanging on to the "elite" panel of umpires only by past reputation...that's why i have respect for venkat, he knew his standards were falling and he got out...bucknor looks like he is waiting for the icc to wake up and fire him or something...
and indian board have a retierment age for its umpires i dont know any other board have it, thats one of the reasons y venkat called it quits when he was at his best. its high time Icc do some thing about it
 

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
Sanz said:
Neither do you. Although it is beside the point that I have never claimed to represent all of India. So next time you want to suck up to someone or look good in front of everyone here, try harder.
I don't know why you had a go at me when I wasn't trying to denigrate you... but umm okay...

I was referring to the fact that whomever he refers to, whether it be me, you or whomever, they don't represent the whole cricketing nation's fans, as Swervy implicated by stating that umpires cheating is always brought up in Indian topics. I never claimed you said Bucknor was cheating.
 

bhajji24

Banned
bucknor is a *****

infiniti said:
Hi everyone,
It's my first post on this forum. I have been a silent observer for the last few weeks. But today's utterly dismal and appalling decision by Steve Bucknor has pained me to no ends and I just need a way to vent off my anger. I was so pumped up, I really would have smashed Afridi for creating a scene there in order to distract Dravid, I am just hoping Pathan gets him on a duck.

The ball was atleast 2-3 inches away when it went past the bat, there was no sound, no appeals except from the bowler. I think if Razzaq would not have persisted, he would have turned it down and I believe he had judged Tendulkar not out in the beginning. Neither anyone from the slip cordon, nor the wicket-keeper cared even for a half hearted appeal. Cmon Mr. Bucknor, you could have done better than that.

It has been a thing with Bucknor for some time that he trusts the loudness and the persistence of the appeal more than his own senses. No doubt, he was a very good umpire in the past, but over the years his eyes have constantly betrayed him. Now it's up to him, to retire now and save himself from the disgrace that will follow, or watch himself fade into oblivion. I see him picking the latter option.

Just wondering, has Bucknor or for that matter any other umpire owed up their wrong decisions after the game is over.
well well well the black ******* is at it again steve ****ner is such a ***** we all knew his outrageous & *******ly actions in the past against india including pointing fingers at parthiv or giving a joke of a lbw against tendulkar in brisbane recently but surely this takes the cake it was evident he knew it was not out as everybody else did & yet the black ***** couldnt bear to see india winning so raised his finger;hard to believe tendulkar took it so well if i was the batsman i would smash his head woth my head honestly the *******......
 

Gangster

U19 12th Man
Swervy said:
and yet it is something we hear almost ever series India play in

Maybe you should ask your precious MCC to make a new rule: Indians aren't allowed to talk. Oh wait, they had that rule in effect for about 400 years!
 

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
bhajji24 said:
well well well the black ******* is at it again steve ****ner is such a ***** we all knew his outrageous & *******ly actions in the past against india including pointing fingers at parthiv or giving a joke of a lbw against tendulkar in brisbane recently but surely this takes the cake it was evident he knew it was not out as everybody else did & yet the black ***** couldnt bear to see india winning so raised his finger;hard to believe tendulkar took it so well if i was the batsman i would smash his head woth my head honestly the *******......
Wow, I think its YOUR post that takes the cake. Utterly inappropriate, no matter how badly Bucknor umpired. Racial slurs? Damn.
 

Swervy

International Captain
Gangster said:
Maybe you should ask your precious MCC to make a new rule: Indians aren't allowed to talk. Oh wait, they had that rule in effect for about 400 years!

hahaha..MY precious MCC..and whats that meant to mean
 

Vroomfondel

U19 12th Man
can someone please conjecture as how and why Bucknor instead of shrugging his shoulders, didn't just take the light meter out and check? I think Tendulkar asked him twice or thrice...

Never mind the bad decision, it basically cancels out the one in Mohali (and strengthens the argument for technology-adoption instead of clinging on to traditions of incompetence).

But why, when asked by Tendulkar didn't Bucknor (or Hair for that matter) pull out the light meters -- especially when Sami and Razzak were bowling bouncers. And the same umpires decide to call it a day 10 minutes after Sachin departs.

Why aren't there rules for this -- why isn't the umpire required to check the light at the request of a batsman, it's a question of safety as much as fair play.
 

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
Vroomfondel said:
can someone please conjecture as how and why Bucknor instead of shrugging his shoulders, didn't just take the light meter out and check? I think Tendulkar asked him twice or thrice...

Never mind the bad decision, it basically cancels out the one in Mohali (and strengthens the argument for technology-adoption instead of clinging on to traditions of incompetence).

But why, when asked by Tendulkar didn't Bucknor (or Hair for that matter) pull out the light meters -- especially when Sami and Razzak were bowling bouncers. And the same umpires decide to call it a day 10 minutes after Sachin departs.

Why aren't there rules for this -- why isn't the umpire required to check the light at the request of a batsman, it's a question of safety as much as fair play.
Exactly my friend! Exactly.

Its not the bad decision, that is a part of the game. But this decision could have been prevented had Bucknor not acted like such a 'Grade A' jackass.
 

Vroomfondel

U19 12th Man
Ok, enough of this crap.

On a happier note. I was just watching bits of the match and the roar at Eden gardens seems to be back.

The pull shot that dravid hit for four off razzak (right at the end of play) elicited a roar from the crowd that sent shivers up my spine. Hopefully people will come in droves on saturday...
 

Gangster

U19 12th Man
Is it so far-fetched to believe that an umpire simply does not like a team? The Tendulkar incident is just the latest in a ever-increasing body of evidence to suggest that Bucknor is either an amazingly incompetent umpire (although his most egregious decisions seem to come solely against India) or, more logically, he dislikes the Indian team. Perhaps Ganguly has rubbed him the wrong way, perhaps Dalmiya put him up in a sub-standard hotel room, or perhaps Dravid slept with his daughter. We can guess for days, but from all appearances, it is clear Bucknor dislikes the Indian team enough to allow his decisions to be influenced. On another note, Darrell Hair sucks too.
 

biased indian

International Coach
bhajji24 said:
well well well the black ******* is at it again steve ****ner is such a ***** we all knew his outrageous & *******ly actions in the past against india including pointing fingers at parthiv or giving a joke of a lbw against tendulkar in brisbane recently but surely this takes the cake it was evident he knew it was not out as everybody else did & yet the black ***** couldnt bear to see india winning so raised his finger;hard to believe tendulkar took it so well if i was the batsman i would smash his head woth my head honestly the *******......
be polite man
 

biased indian

International Coach
Vroomfondel said:
can someone please conjecture as how and why Bucknor instead of shrugging his shoulders, didn't just take the light meter out and check? I think Tendulkar asked him twice or thrice...
i think the problem was that they didnt had any light meter with them.
other wise once they had offered the light to the indian batsmen they should have noted down the meter reading .because if same situation come up again tommorrow they will have to keep the batsmen batting upto the stage simillar to today.but instead of that what i saw on tv was both the umpires where taking down the time what is the garuntee that tommorrow tahe same time will have the exact light as today .i am sure they didnt take any meter reading because just after taking down the time they started walking back to the pavilion
 

Neil Pickup

Request Your Custom Title Now!
bhajji24 said:
well well well the black ******* is at it again steve ****ner is such a ***** we all knew his outrageous & *******ly actions in the past against india including pointing fingers at parthiv or giving a joke of a lbw against tendulkar in brisbane recently but surely this takes the cake it was evident he knew it was not out as everybody else did & yet the black ***** couldnt bear to see india winning so raised his finger;hard to believe tendulkar took it so well if i was the batsman i would smash his head woth my head honestly the *******......
Completely inappropriate and absolutely unacceptable.

Don't expect to be part of this community much longer.
 

Neil Pickup

Request Your Custom Title Now!
It's bizarre that they weren't going off for light as it failed, when Bucknor and Dar took England off in South Africa when the batting side didn't want to - there is a major issue of consistency that needs addressing here as there's an equally big credibility risk involved.
 

biased indian

International Coach
Neil Pickup said:
It's bizarre that they weren't going off for light as it failed, when Bucknor and Dar took England off in South Africa when the batting side didn't want to - there is a major issue of consistency that needs addressing here as there's an equally big credibility risk involved.
the best that can be done is that they should set a reading which is on the lighter side so that once it goes down that if any of the team compalin they should go off.

But the situations like the one that occured during pak vs eng should be taken into consideration as well
 

aussie

Hall of Fame Member
aussie

that decision from bucknor was poor, i couldn't believe it when i saw him gave tendulkar out, its not the first time time he gave a quite dubious decision againts tendulkar remember in one of test in australia in 2003, i cant remember exactly which test but it was similar to this one. Bucknor has been an excellent umpire throughout his career but lately he hasn't been lokkin that hot
 

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
Vroomfondel said:
can someone please conjecture as how and why Bucknor instead of shrugging his shoulders, didn't just take the light meter out and check? I think Tendulkar asked him twice or thrice....
Can someone tell me where it says the batsman is the judge of the light?
 

PAKMAN

State 12th Man
its all part of the game umpires are onlu human if tendulker wasnt given out in the last match having a big inside edge he was given out this time :D
 

aussie

Hall of Fame Member
aussie

well thats true tendulkar did get a big inside edge of kaneria n was given not out in mohali so its one all :D
 

Top