Tom Halsey
International Coach
Hmm, if you mean the United forum at ********* the general consensus was that Charlton deserved his place at number one.roseboy64 said:Anybody here know anything about Duncan Edarwds? If Eddie was around I bet he would know. Anyway, I'm aksing because on the Man Utd forum there was a thread about Manchester United Opus and it's ranking of players. Most were quite peeved that he wasn't number one over Charlton and Best. From what I've heard he was probably one of the best to ever play the game and if he'd lived long enough maybe even the best ever. From what I've read he was the complete footballer and the only one to make Sir Bobby feel inferior. A man who played in the era of Pele and alongside George Best.
However, it was generally agreed that it would have been better to split the ranking up into seperate eras - but then it would spark no debate and wouldn't serve its purpose.
There was also quite a stink that Billy Meredith wasn't included, but since no-one alive saw him play, I personally fail to see how he could have been included.
EDIT: Ah, filter.
Last edited: