superkingdave
Hall of Fame Member
he touched the ball but he didn't win it - the result of the challenge was the ball being in Rosicky's path and him being brought down. Him being brought down occured after both players contact with the ball, the contact with the ball ended with it being in Rosicky's path - in effect Rosicky won the challenge(luckily or not) but he was not able to take advantage of that because he was brought down.Tom Halsey said:Yes but Chimbonda got the ball in a fair challenge. Your whole argument is fairly nonsensical to me - it doesn't matter whether he brought him down or not, he got the ball.
That's my opinion anyway, we're probably going round in circles. I also think Rosicky went down a bit easy