• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* Ashes Series Thread

Redox

Cricket Spectator
PM 11 84 for 4!!! :P:P:P

Kirtly is almost unplayble, 3 wickets so far to him.Seems to me that the team is finally comming back into form! England gonna win this one for sure!
 

Top_Cat

Request Your Custom Title Now!
5/124 now.

Excuse me Redox, could you please put that gun away you just jumped over...............
 

Kimbo

International Debutant
Yea, I think the PM's XI is gonna take this one... geez England, what is up with you?
 

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
Untill now people have been saying that the English team have been losing to a strong Aussie team, but their performance against a virtually unknown players is a real disgust!
It was also an understrength England side - especially in the top to middle order - expect 2 or 3 to come in there for the series...
 

Tim

Cricketer Of The Year
Still...players like Trescothick, Knight & Flintoff should be embarrassed at the way they played.
 

chris.hinton

International Captain
ANOTHER LOSS


This is rubbish we should have won one game by Now, And it not the Injures the fact is that we are not good Enough GRAVENEY HAS GOT TO GO! he is Worse the Illingworth he is taking English cricket to the dark ages.




[Edited on 10/12/2002 by chris.hinton]
 

Anil

Hall of Fame Member
Originally posted by marc71178
Untill now people have been saying that the English team have been losing to a strong Aussie team, but their performance against a virtually unknown players is a real disgust!
It was also an understrength England side - especially in the top to middle order - expect 2 or 3 to come in there for the series...
Oh come on....aren't you tired of making these lame excuses? It was a pathetic performance by a completely demoralised team. All the talk of unscarred(mentally, I mean) youngsters making a difference to the one day side has not borne out by facts atleast.
 

Rik

Cricketer Of The Year
Lame excuses? No, we are trying to find the positives while everyone else seems to be trying to slag off a team who's not performing at the moment but have not done much wrong for about 2-3 years and are now called the worst side in the world...you want the worst side? Look at Bangladesh, 87 all out with a rookie taking 6-3...lay off it will you?
 

Anil

Hall of Fame Member
Originally posted by Rik
Lame excuses? No, we are trying to find the positives while everyone else seems to be trying to slag off a team who's not performing at the moment but have not done much wrong for about 2-3 years and are now called the worst side in the world...you want the worst side? Look at Bangladesh, 87 all out with a rookie taking 6-3...lay off it will you?
No, I am not trying to slag off England nor am I saying that they are the worst side. I know they aren't. Most other teams would have fared badly in the same situation. However, their performance(test and limited overs) in this tour has been pathetic and that is an indisputable fact and no recalling of past performances can erase that fact.

There seems to be a fine line between finding positives and making excuses as far as this series is concerned. For example, what positives did you find from the fact that England lost to an Aus XI that had very few if any national players? That they were inexperienced..? Aren't these so called fresh & mentally unscarred youngsters the ones who are supposedly going to change England's fortunes in the VB series?

Look, I can understand that you want your team to do well, but I would also suggest that you accept the reality while looking for your "positives".

[Edited on 12/10/2002 by anilramavarma]
 

Rik

Cricketer Of The Year
Don't worry I wasn't saying you were. I'm just tired of the constant slagging off of England when they aren't doing it against Australia, that's enough to demorilies any team. A least we will get to see more of Gareth Batty who I've been impressed with so far. He showed some fight with the bat.
 

Legglancer

State Regular
Yes the England team has been performing
well in the last couple of years... but only
in Test Cricket. In ODI's basically they have
totally sucked the last few years. EX: last
year they lost to SL 3-0, then were totally
outplayed and lost all matchers with pakistan
and australia at home.

Subsequently england beat the ZIM's and reached
the final's of a home series with india and
SL, hence the renewed optimisum.

Although I think they are a better team than
18 months ago, England have yet to prove that
they are a Top-Draw ODI team.
 

Rik

Cricketer Of The Year
I'd say that's pretty fair. England dissapoint but they have the talent there.
 

Choora

State Regular
Originally posted by Rik
I'd say that's pretty fair. England dissapoint but they have the talent there.
Talent where???? Certainly not on the ground.I'm not trying to mock the English team, but the fact is that they have been a total rubbish team.The PM eleven was not a strong team, yet English team crumbled so easily.
 

Rik

Cricketer Of The Year
Originally posted by Choora
Originally posted by Rik
I'd say that's pretty fair. England dissapoint but they have the talent there.
Talent where???? Certainly not on the ground.I'm not trying to mock the English team, but the fact is that they have been a total rubbish team.The PM eleven was not a strong team, yet English team crumbled so easily.
Obviously you have never seen Flintoff bat, or the fact that he won a game for England by taking 3 Wickets including 1 and a superb run out in the last over. Obviously you completely missed Collingwood's 71*, Hussain's Century in the Natwest Final, Trescothick's century in that game and when he was in India when he scored a blinding century before being given out to a ball which pitched a long way outside leg. Of course you must have missed Irani's batting and bowling when he single handedly destroyed India in the Natwest Series, or Blackwell's innings against India in the ICC Champion's Trophy. How about Nick Knight's Century and 70 odd against India in the ODI's in India? In order to come up with that statement then obviously you must have missed these performances and many many more.
 

Tim

Cricketer Of The Year
I hate to say this but Collingwoods 3 half centuries have come against fairly weak bowling attacks. 2 against Zimbabwe, 1 against India.
 

Neil Pickup

Request Your Custom Title Now!
It's an irrelevant warmup game.

There's no point reading into these too much, just like India being outplayed by CD for two days before a Sanjay special and the rain intervened doesn't mean that India (and Dravid - 0 and 1) are useless.

Pathetic overreactions (Chris!!) don't help anyone, we're just in a divot at the minute and in six months time we'll be fine again. Don't rush to make change on change or, well, Pakistan.
 

Top_Cat

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Yeah exactly, Choora. Whilst England haven't done so well on this tour thusfar, it's not purely because of a lack of talent. You don't play for your country (particularly the country where the game originated) without being any good.

England have not played well; this isn't in dispute. But to say it's purely because of a lack of talent is wide of the mark somewhat.
 

Rik

Cricketer Of The Year
Originally posted by Tim
I hate to say this but Collingwoods 3 half centuries have come against fairly weak bowling attacks. 2 against Zimbabwe, 1 against India.
Yup but he's got to improve. Anyway to say England has no talent is a stupid remark. India are looking at Bangar for an all-rounder and England have found Flintoff and Irani, not bad eh?
 

age_master

Hall of Fame Member
yeah enland have abit of talent, Trescothick and Vaughn, they are not the best batsmen in the world but they are pretty good i must say, Kirtley looked good in the Aus A game as well
 

Top