Can you beat for the cricket guru title?

[JASON]

Q11 Is scoring a triple century one of the common things?


Edit :Sorry didn't see Bryce's question !!

 

[SJS]

are they the Grace brothers ?

WARNING : THat IS attempting a complete answer. As per the rules, if you are wrong, you would not be able to participate for this question. The other alterantive is to attempt to get closer (zero in) on the answer rather than 'shoot blindly'.

Just an example : You could ask if they were brothers ? There could be other ways of asking

Want me to answer still ??

 

[bryce]

ok sorry i hadn't read the rules but am now aware of them, thanks for letting me off lol, disregard my last post, new query: is one of them WG Grace?
and another query: are they brothers ?

 

[SJS]

Three famous cricketers who have four things in common that no other cricketers have (all four that is) . Who are these and what did they have in common that is so uncommon ??

1. Are they physical traits?....NO
2. Are they cricketing achivements?....YES
3. Are the 3 cricketers from the same country ? ( again may be imprecise, if 2 are from 1 country and the third from another country)….YES
4. Is the country in the Subcontinent ?....NO
5. Is any of the 3 players, currently playing ?.....NO
6. Is one of the 4 common things a batting record ?....YES
7. Are the three cricketers from Australia ?....NO
8. If they are not Aussies, then Are the three English?....YES
9. Is Denis Compton one of them ?.....NO
10. Is Being a Captain one of the 4 common things ?....NO

FIRST HINT : All of them started their careers before the second world war

Q11 are they brothers ?....NO

 

[JASON]

Q12 I repeat my question from above - Is scoring a triple century one of the 4 common things ?

 

[SJS]

Three famous cricketers who have four things in common that no other cricketers have (all four that is) . Who are these and what did they have in common that is so uncommon ??

1. Are they physical traits?....NO
2. Are they cricketing achivements?....YES
3. Are the 3 cricketers from the same country ? ( again may be imprecise, if 2 are from 1 country and the third from another country)….YES
4. Is the country in the Subcontinent ?....NO
5. Is any of the 3 players, currently playing ?.....NO
6. Is one of the 4 common things a batting record ?....YES
7. Are the three cricketers from Australia ?....NO
8. If they are not Aussies, then Are the three English?....YES
9. Is Denis Compton one of them ?.....NO
10. Is Being a Captain one of the 4 common things ?....NO

FIRST HINT : All of them started their careers before the second world war
11. are they brothers ?....NO

12. Is scoring a triple century one of the 4 common things ?...NO

 

[JASON]

Q13 Is scoring a century on debut one of the common things?

 

[bryce]

did they all play test matches ?

 

[SJS]

]Three famous cricketers who have four things in common that no other cricketers have (all four that is) . Who are these and what did they have in common that is so uncommon ??

1. Are they physical traits?....NO
2. Are they cricketing achivements?....YES
3. Are the 3 cricketers from the same country ? ( again may be imprecise, if 2 are from 1 country and the third from another country)….YES
4. Is the country in the Subcontinent ?....NO
5. Is any of the 3 players, currently playing ?.....NO
6. Is one of the 4 common things a batting record ?....YES
7. Are the three cricketers from Australia ?....NO
8. If they are not Aussies, then Are the three English?....YES
9. Is Denis Compton one of them ?.....NO
10. Is Being a Captain one of the 4 common things ?....NO

FIRST HINT : All of them started their careers before the second world war
11. are they brothers ?....NO
12. Is scoring a triple century one of the 4 common things ?...NO

Q13 Is scoring a century on debut one of the common things?...YES
Q14 did they all play test matches ?....YES

 

[bryce]

is it a century on test debut ?

 

[JASON]

Q 15 Is playing for a University one of the common things ?

Edited this will be Q16, Bryce will be Q15.

Since Bryce's question is rejected this will remain Q15, while awaiting bryce to rephrase question.

 

[SJS]

is that test match or first class debut you mean sjs ?

I answered the question asked. AND the question you are asking can not be answered with a yes/no answer
You may have to rephrase the question and it will count as a query

 

[SJS]

]Three famous cricketers who have four things in common that no other cricketers have (all four that is) . Who are these and what did they have in common that is so uncommon ??

1. Are they physical traits?....NO
2. Are they cricketing achivements?....YES
3. Are the 3 cricketers from the same country ? ( again may be imprecise, if 2 are from 1 country and the third from another country)….YES
4. Is the country in the Subcontinent ?....NO
5. Is any of the 3 players, currently playing ?.....NO
6. Is one of the 4 common things a batting record ?....YES
7. Are the three cricketers from Australia ?....NO
8. If they are not Aussies, then Are the three English?....YES
9. Is Denis Compton one of them ?.....NO
10. Is Being a Captain one of the 4 common things ?....NO

FIRST HINT : All of them started their careers before the second world war
11. are they brothers ?....NO
12. Is scoring a triple century one of the 4 common things ?...NO

Q13 Is scoring a century on debut one of the common things?...YES
Q14 did they all play test matches ?....YES
Q 15 Is playing for a University one of the common things ?... NOT RELEVANT

Q 15 Is playing for a University one of the common things ?.....NOT RELEVANT

PS. Not relevant, in this case means, it may be so or may not be so but this doesnt affect the answer OR this was not a part of the original query.

 

[bryce]

well you said there are 4 common things, so playing for a university either is one of the common things or isn't one....

 

[bryce]

lol jason and i can see where your getting your questions from

 

[SJS]

Three famous cricketers who have four things in common that no other cricketers have (all four that is) . Who are these and what did they have in common that is so uncommon ??

1. Are they physical traits?....NO
2. Are they cricketing achivements?....YES
3. Are the 3 cricketers from the same country ? ( again may be imprecise, if 2 are from 1 country and the third from another country)….YES
4. Is the country in the Subcontinent ?....NO
5. Is any of the 3 players, currently playing ?.....NO
6. Is one of the 4 common things a batting record ?....YES
7. Are the three cricketers from Australia ?....NO
8. If they are not Aussies, then Are the three English?....YES
9. Is Denis Compton one of them ?.....NO
10. Is Being a Captain one of the 4 common things ?....NO

FIRST HINT : All of them started their careers before the second world war
11. are they brothers ?....NO
12. Is scoring a triple century one of the 4 common things ?...NO

Q13 Is scoring a century on debut one of the common things?...YES
Q14 did they all play test matches ?....YES
Q 15 Is playing for a University one of the common things ?.....NOT RELEVANT

SECOND HINT : What they shared with each other, they did not share with their team mates when they started their test careers !

 

[SJS]

well you said there are 4 common things, so playing for a university either is one of the common things or isn't one....

I dont know. Maybe thet did maybe they didnt. They could have had other things in commonn besides the four I started with , you know, maybe they loved the same type of music, but its not relevant for me

The four things they had in common , which I had in mind when I started this, did not include going to the same college or university.

 

[bryce]

100 on Test Debut for England who started their Careers before the 2nd World War

WG Grace
KS Ranjitsinhji
PF Warner
RE Foster
G Gunn
Nawab of Pataudi snr
BH Valentine
PA Gibb

 

[marc71178]

He didn't say that they were all necessarily the same country.

The prescence of Ranji and Nawab on there suggests some sort of royalty connection...

 

[bryce]

is on of the common things to do with being born outside of england ?