Tharmi'll hate this but simply, too many Manly players in the Aussie side. When there were less Manly players we beat NZ easily, and don't forget when we did they had Matai, also a Manly player.
They lose Mattai, so one less Manly toss pot. We gain Watmyth - one extra Manly toss pot.
It upset the natural order of things, costing us a win.
Kite - did ok for a non-rep prop.
Watmyth - not a rep player
G Stewart - good club player, that's it.
Williams - meh, a fast winger - they're a dime a dozen.
On a serious note, wtf was Stuart doing replacing a 125 metre per game prop in Steve Price with a wide-running back rower in Watmyth? That's a disaster waiting to happen. Petro and Kite go off the ground, and we're light on for size. Played right into NZ's hands.
They were superb actually. Deserved to win. Happy for Cayless after so much big game nothingness for him in the past.
And whoever chose Lockyer as MOTM obviously hit their head when they fell out of the ute with Changa before the game, in yet another example of Rugby League pre-game entertainment going so very, very well.