• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Will Geriant Jones become the new Gilchrist?

O

Oli Norwell

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
He's made a good start to his test career, seems to be able to score at a good rate, plus his keeping isn't that bad.

Would be nice for England fans if in five years he'd played 50 tests, and had an average of 60. Can't quite see it happening though?.
 
T

tooextracool

International Coach
hes been very impressive,however he does need to work on a few areas of his batting.....especially his cutting because he seems to throw his bat at anything wide and fails to keep it down. nothing that a bit of experience wont do,as it did for flintoff.
however he does have all the shots in the book and i look forward to see both him and flintoff counter attacking australia at 140/5.
 
luckyeddie

luckyeddie

Cricket Web Staff Member
More than likely not - or should that be 'less than likely so', because such talk is as out of place as the usual 'Irfan Pathan to replace Kofi Annan as Secretary General of the UN' rubbish we had recently.

He's got a couple of things in common with Churchy, of course - a real slugger with the bat and not as impressive as he ought to be behind the sticks.
 
Jamee999

Jamee999

Hall of Fame Member
Could be the new Stewie -IF he improves his keeping-I think that in 2006/07 he could get in for his batting.
 
marc71178

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
Has anyone said that Jones (the unproven one showing a lot of promise) is better than Gilchrist (the proven performer)?

Didn't think so, in fact the initial poster said he didn't think so - it is just speculation, rather than a statement.

And Jones' keeping isn't the best, but he's the better keeper in this game!
 
luckyeddie

luckyeddie

Cricket Web Staff Member
chicane said:
And comparing Irfan Pathan with Harmison is supposed to be OTT! 8-)
Click to expand...
Well, seeing as everyone said 'unlikely', including the person who started the thread, the comparison with the comparison (!?!) of Pathan v Harmison is misplaced.
 
O

Oli Norwell

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
Well have to say on this performance he's looking extremely good, it took Gilchrist a few years to develop into the player he is. Plus he's scoring at well over 4 and over. So who knows, I'm sure he'll get a good run in the side. What with Strauss England really have uncovered 2 gems.
 
chicane

chicane

State Captain
luckyeddie said:
Well, seeing as everyone said 'unlikely', including the person who started the thread, the comparison with the comparison (!?!) of Pathan v Harmison is misplaced.
Click to expand...
In the other thread Pathan was in some ppl's opinion nowhere near Harmo and the comparison was OTT, then what is this? Why speculate this mega mismatch then?
 
Neil Pickup

Neil Pickup

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Difference is that this is nothing more than speculation rather than actually claiming it's so!
 
chicane

chicane

State Captain
Neil Pickup said:
Difference is that this is nothing more than speculation rather than actually claiming it's so!
Click to expand...
Well there was a 'Can Pathan be as good as Wasim' thread, which was merely speculation, and that too was supposed to be OTT..
 
luckyeddie

luckyeddie

Cricket Web Staff Member
chicane said:
In the other thread Pathan was in some ppl's opinion nowhere near Harmo and the comparison was OTT, then what is this? Why speculate this mega mismatch then?
Click to expand...
Only a fool could possibly equate the following two statements as equivalent...

1. Irfan Pathan warrants comparison with Steve Harmison at the moment
2. Geraint Jones does not warrant comparison with Adam Gilchrist at the moment.

I refuse to speculate how many would
a) agree with both
b) disagree with both
c) agree with one - and which one.

How's that for a diplomatic answer?

(Chicane's reply in 5....4....3.... "You swine, calling me a fool...") :D
 
PY

PY

International Coach
'Tis a bit odd that we are all saying that it isn't likely to happen and yet the people who are paid to talk about cricket are making comparisons along those lines already.

They don't always talk crap so you never know......
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top