Viv Richards & Allan Donald vs Brian Lara & Curtly Ambrose

[Fuller Pilch]

I would have Weekes, Walcott, Miandad, Dravid, Barrington, Root, Harvey, De Villiers all in the same tier tbh

Plus Kane & Younis Khan

 

[Fuller Pilch]

are you Pakistani?

What's wrong with Miandad? He was brilliant

 

[Johan]

Why? Don't think he rates Miandad unreasonably high.

it's pretty unreasonably high lol, like I don't think Miandad is really compareable to Root or Dravid at all

 

[Fuller Pilch]

it's pretty unreasonably high lol, like I don't think Miandad is really compareable to Root or Dravid at all

Better imo

 

[Johan]

What's wrong with Miandad? He was brilliant

outside of New Zealand, his away record is super lacking, Root lvl in Australia, Mid in England, mid in West Indies, no ton in India

 

[Johan]

Better imo

I hope you overcome your stockholm syndrome

 

[Fuller Pilch]

outside of New Zealand, his away record is super lacking, Root lvl in Australia, Mid in England, mid in West Indies, no ton in India

Yeah but he did well against Hadlee who was better than any bowlers Root and Dravid faced.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Wasn't talking about plain list, which doesn't signify the gap between individual players.

I found the gaps ass tbh

 

[Johan]

Yeah but he did well against Hadlee who was better than any bowlers Root and Dravid faced.

not sure where Bumrah will end up, but I'd prefer consistency away from home rather than domination in a single facet, even Warner obliterated Steyn, doesn't make his away record better.

 

[Johan]

I found the gaps ass tbh

Compton or Barrington

 

[sayon basak]

I found the gaps ass tbh

If you get rid of the sub tiers and put all the names in a list, I bet it'd pretty similar to yours.

And I didn't claim the gaps to be perfect, they were random. I just proposed a method. I'm okay with the method being ass tho.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Barrington

 

[Johan]

Barrington

Rank

Barrington
May
Weekes
Worrel
Walcott
Compton
Harvey
De Villiers

 

[capt_Luffy]

Rank

Barrington
May
Weekes
Worrel
Walcott
Compton
Harvey
De Villiers

Barrington
Weekes
Compton
De Villiers
Walcott
Harvey
May
Worrell

 

[sayon basak]

Rank

Barrington
May
Weekes
Worrel
Walcott
Compton
Harvey
De Villiers

Barrington
Weekes
Compton
Walcott
De Villiers
Harvey
May
Worrell

 

[Johan]

Barrington
Compton/Weekes
Weekes/Compton
Walcott
De Villiers
Harvey
May
Worrell

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Why? Don't think he rates Miandad unreasonably high.

Yea Im pretty sure most people would agree Miandad is close to Dravid and Barrington

 

[Johan]

Barrington
Weekes
Compton
De Villiers
Walcott
Harvey
May
Worrell

it's kinda crazy how Walcott managed to be outscored by both Hutton and Harvey in his two ATG serieses, unlucky asf

 

[Johan]

Great peak.
Extraordinary away record.
He deserves it in my opinion

lack of crucial ashes knocks ruins his reputation, even Root has more which is insane

 

[Johan]

like I won't put Javed above Lloyd