I've just had an extensive chat with Garven over this, and I thought I'd summarise my thoughts here -
- There is nothing to suggest that Pinchy's response to Liam's post with "I'll Stay" was binding - or the equivalent of being officially contracted (ie; his position in the squad being finalised in the Squad Announcements thread)
- According to Garven, Liam then decided
after Pinchy had responded that it would be binding
- Therefore, the pretenses under which Pinchy said he'd stay were false, because there was no indication UPON SIGNING that it'd be binding
I think that whilst it's inconvenient and undesireable for Blue that Pinchy should change his mind after saying that he'd stay (and I sympathise in this regard), there are no grounds for him to be barred from moving.
Don't mean to annoy anyone, and I didn't really care much about this, but Garven has compelled me to offer my thoughts. Could be misinformed though, so apologies if I've missed something.
Edit - might also add that Garven doesn't actually intend to sign Pinchy, so feel free to come Red bud
.