Pap Finn Keighl
International Debutant
Pant > Dhoni > Sanga
Well Flower was easily the worst keeper of this lot so… the phrase wicket keeper batsman does have wicket keeper in the prominent first positionI don't think his wicket keeping was good enough to exceed Flower's batting. My guy couldn't perform against Bangladesh at home.
That's a very interesting take and totally changes many things here, as I rate Flower a clearly superior bat.Well I never saw Flower keep much, but on CW his wicket keeping is rated quite lowly. However I heard Kimber once say that he was a better keeper than Gilchrist iirc. Guess I'll have to do some research
Yeah, just 40+, but was a class keeper and honestly, no other keeper averages such will explicitly batting at 3.As only a pure wicket keeper better, is Sanga 2nd? Because his batting went down massively while keeping + he only kept in a minority part of his career. As good a batsman as he was, it doesn't feel right keeping him in second
Most definitely. Rizwan was getting benched for Sarfaraz Ahmed just a few months ago, for all the roads he gets at home, his home output is quite below par.Serious question, but is Pant better than Rizwan?? He is very poor against the moving ball.
Saha>Kirmani is a take most won't agree with, but I feel strongly about.Watling tied with Flower! Just shows how grossly overrated Watling is on CW
And really, nobody advocating for kirmani or engineer? TG Evans could be a shout too.
Yes. Isn’t Pant one of the only players nevermind keepers to have scored a bunch of centuries in like 5 away series or something weird like that?Serious question, but is Pant better than Rizwan?? He is very poor against the moving ball.
His greatest output is being the MVP in two series victories in Australia. Wonder how many cricketers, let alone keepers, can claim that.Yes. Isn’t Pant one of the only players nevermind keepers to have scored a bunch of centuries in like 5 away series or something weird like that?
He’s still a baby in test terms too, he has insane output.
He’s an unorthodox bat - his output is there.
No he was terribleWell Flower is obviously the best batsman of them, was he an acceptable wicket keeper?
I have read a few times on here that he wasn't good. He's definitely the best batsman out of those three but probably would have been a specialist batsman for a better side.No he was terrible
rad haddin is obviously the answer here
Could you provide any article or maybe any footage? That would be helpful for us who haven't watched him keep.No he was terrible
rad haddin is obviously the answer here