The reason Australia don't produce many quality fingerspinners is because no decks in Australia help fingerspin, except The SCG.jamesryfler said:Barring Hayden and Ponting (to some extent), the rest of the batsmen aren't great players of spin particularly finger spin.
The Pura Cup doesn't feature a single decent finger spinner -- I **personally** think Hauritz has quite a while to go before he can play internationally.
Most of the spinners Australia produce and have produced are wristies -- either left armers or the orthodox type e.g Warne, Hogg, Casson, Bright, White, MacGill etc.
So its not really a surprise that historically, the Aussies have struggled against quality finger spinners on pitches offering some help to them.
Richard, i think made a comment that finger spinners weren't of
much use outside of the subcontinent and possibly the Caribbean.
I don't really agree with this -- it really depends on whether the finger spinner chooses to deceive batsmen thru the air rather than off the pitch. If the former, I see no reason why a finger spinner can't be successful on various types of wickets e.g Erapalli Prasanna did quite well on New Zealand's seaming wickets in 1967-68 and 1975-76. BS Bedi was quite outstanding
on the Australian tour of 1977-78 and not just at Sydney.
Murali I belive took quite a few wickets on Sri Lanka's 2001 RSA tour, another place not renowned for turning wickets.
I haven't seen Murali for a while but BS Bedi was certainly a spinner who beat a lot of batsemn with his flight.
Richard said:The reason Australia don't produce many quality fingerspinners is because no decks in Australia help fingerspin, except The SCG.
CricketMAX in New Zealand...Ford_GTHO351 said:Imagine though if Twenty20 cricket did make an international debut as the third form of Cricket along with Tests & ODI's. Wouldn't be great to watch, seeing the likes of Gilchrist batting with even more agression Imagine the feelings of the bowler having to bowl to Gilchrist in Twenty20 cricket!
What are you basing this assumption on? Just some kind of instinctive certainty in your mind(like "I say so, hence it must be true...") or is there some logic to this?Richard said:I don't really think it's possible to beat batsmen in the air at 50-53mph, the only way to beat them is off the pitch at that pace. Bish and Prasanna might have had the odd good tour to somewhere unhelpful, but that was more likely down (like Harbhajan's to New Zealand recently) to poor batting rather than good bowling.