But you don't pick the Test team based on how good a player can play, it should be picked on who's playing well now. Based on that, MacGill can't be selected for the Boxing Day Test match at this stage, and he shouldn't get a look in again until whoever replaces him underperforms.I don't agree with that MacGilla's talent is very well known to all of us he just is having a rough time of it atm (and he probably has a dodgey knee too) so he needs all the support he can get atm from his team-mates because ideally the Aussies would want him to there till the Ashes 09 so that gives the next-gen spinners time to be groomed.
But there aren't many better options atm the younger spinners aren't ready yet and Hogg is the only likely option but still i think MacGill should play in the remaining 4 test matches this summer.But you don't pick the Test team based on how good a player can play, it should be picked on who's playing well now. Based on that, MacGill can't be selected for the Boxing Day Test match at this stage, and he shouldn't get a look in again until whoever replaces him underperforms.
Right now we've got another option who, even if not quite as good as MacGill, is certainly bowling far better at the moment, and therefore deserves to be picked. Hogg's form at the moment is infinitely superior to MacGill's, and MacGill's knees are such an issue he shouldn't be picked for the Test team anywayBut there aren't many better options atm the younger spinners aren't ready yet and Hogg is the only likely option but still i think MacGill should play in the remaining 4 test matches this summer.
AWTA. Hogg deadset cert for Boxing Day unless MacGill performs a couple of miracles at domestic level. Indians will carve MacGill up but have shown trouble in picking Hogg and his variations.Right now we've got another option who, even if not quite as good as MacGill, is certainly bowling far better at the moment, and therefore deserves to be picked. Hogg's form at the moment is infinitely superior to MacGill's, and MacGill's knees are such an issue he shouldn't be picked for the Test team anyway
Wait, what? Seriously, even though I disagreed with you, I could understand your reasoning at 1/150 and 3/250.. but Malinga and Murali are at the crease on the 5th day of a test and they still need over 100 to win. They have no hope. If Sri Lanka win this game, I'll eat cat food and put the footage of it on YouTube for you all to see. It's not going to happen.What odds are Lanka at now? I reckon they can do it still.
How do you know Hogg cannot be the better option compared to MacGill? If you have that much faith in MacGill despite his poor form or whatever it is (it has not been just this test series), it is fair enough that you continue with him. I wouldn't. If Hogg fails, I would select another pace bowler despite the problems with playing 4 fast bowlers. It isn't a preferable option but any thing is preferable to MacGill playing if he keeps bowling the way he is.But there aren't many better options atm the younger spinners aren't ready yet and Hogg is the only likely option but still i think MacGill should play in the remaining 4 test matches this summer.
He's obviously taking the piss.Wait, what? Seriously, even though I disagreed with you, I could understand your reasoning at 1/150 and 3/250.. but Malinga and Murali are at the crease on the 5th day of a test and they still need over 100 to win. They have no hope. If Sri Lanka win this game, I'll eat cat food and put the footage of it on YouTube for you all to see. It's not going to happen.
What odds are Lanka at now? I reckon they can do it still.