• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** Australia in India Thread

JustTool

State 12th Man
Jono said:
To be fair, Yuvraj did walk. Shepherd would of probably raised the finger, but he didn't wait to find out.

Great day of cricket, in favour to India but it would of been much more if Yuvraj just kept his head. He was let off by Clarke, why play at that ball? Oh well, I'm one happy camper :)
This walking stuff is pure horseshit. So, now suddenly the Aussies decide it is hip to walk and we expect everyone to follow. What if they change their mind and like Steve Waugh decide that no-more-walking. Should the whole world stop following.
Withour more technology, the only way things even out in umpiring errors is that they make mistakes both ways - if you take the ability of them to incrrectly call you NOT-OUt when you are out then the mistakes will only be in one-direction i.e. OUT when you are NOT-OUT. And things will never even out.
Best way to end all this drama, or at least alleviate the need for all this drama, is top bring in MORE TECHNOLOGY. :@
 

Mr Casson

Cricketer Of The Year
I'm confused as to what exactly people have against Gilchrist's keeping. Sure he makes mistakes (like everyone does), but he takes some unbelievable catches such as the one that got Yuvraj yesterday.

He's never looked that bad to me. Even apart from catching, just general tidiness behind the stumps like keeping to tough balls from spinners. In the first test I remember one of Warne's deliveries going screaming down leg side and Gilchrist saved it using his legs - which was ugly as hell as far as connoiseurs of fine keeping go, but well done all the same.
 

NikhilN

International Regular
JustTool said:
Amazing that No One, I mean NO ONE, believes that dropping Chopra in favor of Yuvraj was the right move. And EVERYONE (on this BB) agrees that Yuvraj's technique has flaws that are horribly exposed in Tests. What is Ganguly thinking ? Or, is he ? By the way, as I said in one of my posts yesterday he should have brought Kumble on earlier - Kumble was underbowled and still delivered. DROP ZAHEER and YUVRAJ. AND PATEL. :@
I believe that was right to drop Chopra
 

Sehwag309

Banned
For those who missed it

Apologize for the Quality, Video Card Issue. Couldnt fit Kaspa Wicket as there was too much confusion to show

Hayden: 136/1


____________________________________________________

Langer: 136/2



____________________________________________________

Martyn: 189/3



____________________________________________________

Lehmann: 191/4​



____________________________________________________

Clarke: 204/5



____________________________________________________

Gilchrist: 210/6



____________________________________________________

Warne: 216/7



____________________________________________________

Gillespie: 224/8



____________________________________________________

Kaspa: 228/9. Mcgrath: 235/10​

 

NikhilN

International Regular
Sehwag309 said:
Apologize for the Quality, Video Card Issue. Couldnt fit Kaspa Wicket as there was too much confusion to show

Hayden: 136/1


____________________________________________________

Langer: 136/2



____________________________________________________

Martyn: 189/3



____________________________________________________

Lehmann: 191/4​



____________________________________________________

Clarke: 204/5



____________________________________________________

Gilchrist: 210/6



____________________________________________________

Warne: 216/7



____________________________________________________

Gillespie: 224/8



____________________________________________________

Kaspa: 228/9. Mcgrath: 235/10​

Hey mate can you please make the Gilly out avatar size?
 

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
NikhilN said:
Hey mate can you please make the Gilly out avatar size?
Yes, thank you for quoting the entire post when it wasn't necessary and causing a massive slow down of the thread.
 

JustTool

State 12th Man
NikhilN said:
I believe that was right to drop Chopra
Even after Yuvraj scored less than double digits even after he got one life ? I suppose you are in favor of Zaheer being retained as you clearly seem to be a fan of Agarkar (who led India to one of the FEW vistories iN Australia :) 8-) :blink:
 

JustTool

State 12th Man
Best summary of WALKING events and what cricket is all about....Excerpts:

Australia walk into Kumble's waiting arms
By Simon Briggs in Madras
(Filed: 15/10/2004)



Test cricket's endless capacity for surprise was reaffirmed yesterday in Madras. Not only did Australia lurch from a seemingly impregnable position to their worst collapse in India, but three of their batsman actually opted to walk rather than wait for the umpire's decision.



The image of the day was not supplied by Anil Kumble, India's saviour with seven wickets in 63 balls, but by umpire David Shepherd, who looked utterly bemused when Michael Kasprowicz received a not-out verdict, but then turned and walked off anyway. "Did he hear me say 'not out'?" an incredulous Shepherd was seen to ask non-striker Simon Katich.

The three walkers - Kasprowicz, Jason Gillespie and stand-in captain Adam Gilchrist - were all dismissed in the same way, caught at bat-pad off the dynamic Kumble. But Gilchrist emphasised last night that there was no team policy on walking. "A lot was made of the umpiring in the last Test and maybe people are thinking about that and understanding what a difficult job it is for the umpires," he said. "It's got to be a positive for the game." Whether captain Ricky Ponting, who has been ruled out of the next Test with a fractured thumb, agrees is another matter.

Yesterday's events were a long way from the traditional image of the Australian cricketer as someone who only walks when he runs out of petrol. But the tourists' sportsmanship was reciprocated in the final over, when Indian opener Yuvraj Singh was caught behind off a fine inside-edge and declined to wait for the decision.

Australia may be hoping that such gestures may win back admirers after Bangalore, where the price of a couple of flukey wickets turned out to be a hailstorm of public censure. But their generosity came at a heavy price. Plunging from 136 for no wicket to 235 all out, Gilchrist's team evoked the recurring nightmare of Calcutta 2001
 

JustTool

State 12th Man
More from Simon Briggs - he is very good, hits the right issues, makes the right observations...

Kumble had hardly been used until this point. Indian captain Sourav Ganguly is perhaps not his strongest supporter, if you judge by his omission from a number of Tests and one-day finals over the last couple of years. But Kumble loves the splice-jarring bounce in the Chepauk Stadium pitch, as 29 wickets in five previous Tests should suggest. He made his point brilliantly after tea.

Can you believe Ganguly would rather support Yuvraj, Zaheer and Parthiv than back Kumble...in a manner of speaking
 

FRAZ

International Captain
Sehwag309 said:
Good Work there ...Appreciated .
Any ways , The points that I made about the 2nd game before it started were spot on as far as the first day of the 2nd test is concerned .
Wicket Keeping and Kumble factor and Fast Bowling factor ....
Stay Kool
 

mavric41

State Vice-Captain
I don't think the Indians' approach this morning is a wise one. Shouldn't they be trying to score when the ball is new and easier to score runs from rather when it will reverse swing and spin. They have kept their wickets though.
 

mavric41

State Vice-Captain
tooextracool said:
err no, akram was more of a slogger. pathan has shown so far that he has the ability to do both.

Early on he was, but when he teamed with Imran Khan for a big partnership in Sydney (they both scored centuries) he came of age. Pathan reminds me of him then.
 

FRAZ

International Captain
mavric41 said:
Early on he was, but when he teamed with Imran Khan for a big partnership in Sydney (they both scored centuries) he came of age. Pathan reminds me of him then.
No comments about the post of tooextra that you quoted from .....
 

SJS

Hall of Fame Member
NikhilN said:
I believe that was right to drop Chopra
Maybe. But Yuvraj was the worst choice to put in his place. Any of the following would have been better.

Parthiv
Dravid
Ganguly
Jadhav
Sriram

There is absolutely no justification for Yuvraj except that Ganguly is mulishly obstinate. Jo keh diya so keh diya. (What I have said I have said/will do) is what he appears to be doing.

Here is a captain praised for standing by his players but look carefully at his career as captain and you will see that he is does stand by players but he is very selective and choosy (not always on merit) as to whom he will back to the hilt.
 

viktor

State Vice-Captain
DONT EVER buy the cricinfo audio package!! if I ever meet the guy Sunil somebody, I swear i'm gonna kill him!!!!hes going on and on about Irfan being the answer to India's alrounder problem. even said he should open in the next innings!!!!!
 

Top