• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** Australia in India Thread

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
Pathan proved he's more than just a pinch hitter when he stuck around with Dravid and Patel in both innings. I'm not overreacting and saying he's going to be a great allrounder, all I'm saying is that he's got talent, and maybe, just maybe he may be able to be more than just a tailender who can swing. The commentators have agreed, most here have seen it and I'm sure that the Indian team knows that as well.
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Jono said:
Pathan proved he's more than just a pinch hitter when he stuck around with Dravid and Patel in both innings. I'm not overreacting and saying he's going to be a great allrounder, all I'm saying is that he's got talent, and maybe, just maybe he may be able to be more than just a tailender who can swing. The commentators have agreed, most here have seen it and I'm sure that the Indian team knows that as well.
Not an all-rounder....yet...but a very good chance. In fact, their best chance. By playing him at number 7, or higher up in ODI's (except against Australia), they can't lose much. They have to take this chance and make the best of it. He's a lot better than Agarkar, Parthiv and Balaji, though Dinesh Karthik, with an average of 42 in FC matches, is a lot closer to the top 6.
 

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
Did anyone else see Sehwag and Langer having a joke around when they were walking off the field at stumps? It was great to see, Langer had Sehwag's bat in his hands and because it was so heavy, he went and felt Sehwag's biceps. Lol, just great to see that though both teams are intense on the field (ie Bhaji and McGrath) the spirit of the game is still alive. :)
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
Jono said:
Did anyone else see Sehwag and Langer having a joke around when they were walking off the field at stumps? It was great to see, Langer had Sehwag's bat in his hands and because it was so heavy, he went and felt Sehwag's biceps. Lol, just great to see that though both teams are intense on the field (ie Bhaji and McGrath) the spirit of the game is still alive. :)
Hmmm...Sehwag using a heavy bat? I though his bat was lighter than Sachin's. AT least that's what I read in the papers.
 

mavric41

State Vice-Captain
masterblaster said:
Credit to Yuvraj too, he walked, even though I had the feeling that Shepherd was going to give him out anyway.

It'll be interesting to see Irfan and Sehwag bat together, I'm hoping for another solid contribution by Irfan to back up his Bangalore innings. The man has a lot of potential with the bat in hand.
He reminds me of a yound Wasim Akram the way he bats.
 

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
Yeah but Sachin's bat is like an anchor. I think everyone in cricket uses as lighter bat than the great Sachin.

Either way Sehwag's reaction to Langer feeling his bicep was quite humorous :)
 

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
I'm hoping for another solid contribution by Irfan to back up his Bangalore innings. The man has a lot of potential with the bat in hand.
He should get not one, not two but as many as 7 scores over 40, and he can, if the captain should have any confidence in him. The captain has a very crucial role to play here. The number 7 position in Tests and ODI's is a lottery (although Dinesh Karthik must get it if he is picked) and he can benefit a great deal by staying at that position for a long time, and so can the team.

The Times of India had suggested some work for Sunil Gavaskar, as batting consultant, to do with every player in the Indian team. For Irfan, he should get him to keep the momentum going. Irfan's basics as a batsman are good, and he runs well between wickets, so he should get more runs in singles. The big shot options will come and he should take them when they come. Being tall and well-built, he should be able to get his fours and stand-clearing sixes in clean shots, not fake shots like Sehwag, which just clear the ropes. His defense is not too bad, either. IF he can earn praise from someone like Geoffrey Boycott, a hard man for technique, he is definitely very good, but as Boycs said, he must WANT to do well.
 
Last edited:

Arjun

Cricketer Of The Year
For the Indian team, for the next session:
SEHWAG: Occupy the crease. Rotate the strike. Take every big shot available, but stay at the crease for a big score.

PATHAN: Rotate the strike and hit the ball only when possible, and when needed, but give the strike to the batsman at the other end.

DRAVID: Occupy the crease for a really, really long time and also score some runs.
 

Mister Wright

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Arjun said:
END OF DAY ONE:

It was a good bowling performance by the Indians, but they were lucky on two counts-exactly the two walks, even more than the dodgy decision that got Clarke. The Australians are in such good form and have rolled over nearly every other team they have played, so they can afford it. The same cannot be said for most other teams, who will depend on an umpire to bail them out. Good point about Ganguly- with his team having won so few tournaments, and his batting also suspect, his fielding being almost nonexistent, he needs an umpire to save him. His grounded catch was supposed to make up for all his dropped catches, misfields and loose throws, but was just in the same bracket. By the way, does anyone remember Alec Stewart's trick in Trent Bridge, 2002? He contested the umpire's decision and used TV replays to stay not out! So did Wasim Jaffer in Barbados, 2002.

That said, Kumble bowled really, really well and deserved his 7 wickets. There was so much talk about Harbhajan being the main bowler, him getting 43 wickets in 4 matches against the Aussies, but Kumble is always a better bet. He has been very fit, and has used intelligence more than cracking pitches and that has helped him- and the team- a lot. However, he needs to be a regular fixture in ODI's, and must get more support with the fields.

The Indian batting performance was a disappoitment. Yuvraj got out yet again with two left feet against a spinner, which defeats the purpose of opening with him. The start was still bad- 28 runs in 13 overs. It could damage a promising career, one that could help the team a lot. Sehwag did little wrong, and should keep up the good work in the next session. But with 8 runs in 34 balls, for an attacking batsman, what has Akash Chopra done wrong? Pathan gets an opportunity to bat higher up, and must prove that he can bat- a lot better than some of the tailenders he follows so often. However, he was a strange choice for a night watchman- he's the opposite- a pinch-hitter.
I disagree, I think it will do Pathan a world of good batting up the order. And from what I have seen is far from just a pinch-hitter, rather a fine uper-order player.
 

SJS

Hall of Fame Member
Mister Wright said:
I disagree, I think it will do Pathan a world of good batting up the order. And from what I have seen is far from just a pinch-hitter, rather a fine uper-order player.
Spot on. Hope he gets another fifty tomorrow and opens the eyes of the selectors to look beyond the immediate small group they seem to currently choose from.

His performance since coming from nowhere just about a year ago should embolden them a bit.....I hope.
 

Mister Wright

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
SJS said:
Spot on. Hope he gets another fifty tomorrow and opens the eyes of the selectors to look beyond the immediate small group they seem to currently choose from.

His performance since coming from nowhere just about a year ago should embolden them a bit.....I hope.

Yeah, from what I've seen it wouldn't be unrealistic to see him batting as high as 7 or 6 and becoming a genuine all-rounder, however it is a little early to be talking that way.
 

Jono

Virat Kohli (c)
Very well said Mister Wright. At the age of 19, the guy has a world of opportunity in front of him. I wish him the best, because he will be so valuable to Indian cricket.

It will be interesting to see how he goes tomorrow, hopefully he does well. :) I also think Sehwag is going to be a huge key, if he can stay at the crease and play intelligently, India could get a good total.
 

Dar

School Boy/Girl Captain
Well done Anil Kumble, you've made my day.

I can't believe they dropped Chopra and opened with Yuvraj but apart from that a great day for India. It is CRUCIAL they bat well tomorrow, this test is so important in terms of the series.
 

Neil Pickup

Request Your Custom Title Now!
It's certainly going to be interesting to see how this one pans out.

Why's walking suddenly become the fashion? I can't imagine what Steve Waugh must be thinking...
 

Linda

International Vice-Captain
About this walking trend.. I can deal with it, and admire it, however I would love to know what Gilchrist would do if he were in a more sticky situation. Like the article on baggygreen suggests, what would he do if his wicket meant the loss of the match, or even the series?

It would be interesting to see how far these players ethics stretched.
 

Dar

School Boy/Girl Captain
Im not too sure about the walking thing, i know its honourable and everything but on another day you may be dealt a shocker of a decision and theres nothing you can do about it. Plus like others have mentioned, how far will the ethics be stretched
 

tooextracool

International Coach
Mr Casson said:
I think the point is that his worry should be exacerbated by a real young-gun with a case for inclusion.
which means that he should be worried about his place in the side, and after all the times that i argued against that, before which someone decided to change the point completely.
 

tooextracool

International Coach
Mister Wright said:
My original point was that you had no point. But you kept on about it which isn't unusual.
your original point was that he should be worried....any sane person would assume that he should be worried about his place in the side. of course you decided to twist it around by saying that he should be worried if he continued to play like that, which is the same for any player anywhere in the world.
 

tooextracool

International Coach
masterblaster said:
Still can't really understand why Ajit Agarkar cannot find a way into the playing XI. Agarkar's record against the Aussies is outstanding compared with Zaheer who just continues to have dismal games against them.

The Australian's really do respect Agarkar's bowling as he's had a lot of success against them, and that should clearly send a signal out to Ganguly to play Agarkar.
i really cant understand why zaheer khan is still playing, his bowling has been complete rubbish for most of his career, bar the occasional good spells.
at least agarkar would solve the 'langer' problem:p
 

Top