• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** Australia in India Thread

Spetsnatz

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
masterblaster said:
Of all places, they put the test at Nagpur!

The Mohali ground in Chandigardh is one of the best test match cricketing grounds in India, with plenty of help for the faster bowlers and batsmen, with some spin on day's 4 and 5.

But no, Nagpur it is. No matches in Eden Garden, the home of Indian Cricket either. Shame really.
Eden Gardens is getting a test against South Africa I believe.

But you have to wonder why Mohali isn't going to host anything when both Nagpur and Kanpur get tests against Aus and Rsa respectively.

Perhaps Pakistan will play there in the new year.
 

Deja moo

International Captain
age_master said:
the previous record was 8/155 by basically the same team (stronger even) not really the zone for favouritism

That doesnt count for much if you consider the 347 of the tied test , which was basically just one run short of a win .

IMO, India were 65-35 favourites to win this one .
 

Spetsnatz

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
Re: Tendulkar, I'm just wondering whether its in India's best interests
to play him -- he's had no match practice for 2 months now and he would have to replace an in form Mohammad Kaif in the middle order.

Wouldn't it make more sense to play him in the BP X1 against against RSA and ease him back into the national team ?

I'm not sure India so desperately need him atm (they still showed they could rack up a decent total against the Aussies in Chennai and that too without major contributions from Dravid or Laxman) ; yes he's a great batsman - but to accomodate him you would have to drop Kaif.
 

masterblaster

International Captain
Spetsnatz said:
Re: Tendulkar, I'm just wondering whether its in India's best interests
to play him -- he's had no match practice for 2 months now and he would have to replace an in form Mohammad Kaif in the middle order.

Wouldn't it make more sense to play him in the BP X1 against against RSA and ease him back into the national team ?

I'm not sure India so desperately need him atm (they still showed they could rack up a decent total against the Aussies in Chennai and that too without major contributions from Dravid or Laxman) ; yes he's a great batsman - but to accomodate him you would have to drop Kaif.
It's a rash move, but I would drop Yuvraj Singh and open with Mohammad Kaif. The man showed he had the technique to tackle the Australian bowling and was really looking superior to Yuvraj Singh in batting stakes. My main man to open would be Akash Chopra, but he's been forgotten.

My ideal team for Nagpur:

Sehwag
Kaif (even though I'd like to see Chopra there but anyways...)
Dravid
Tendulkar (If Fit) / Yuvraj
Laxman
Ganguly (c)
Patel (even though I'd like to see Dinesh Karthik in this spot)
Irfan Pathan
Agarkar
Harbhajan
Kumble
 

Deja moo

International Captain
Nehra has reported fit for the third test.

IMO, Nehra would be a better bet for the dustbowl that is Nagpur rather than AA .
 

SJS

Hall of Fame Member
masterblaster said:
It's a rash move, but I would drop Yuvraj Singh and open with Mohammad Kaif. The man showed he had the technique to tackle the Australian bowling and was really looking superior to Yuvraj Singh in batting stakes. My main man to open would be Akash Chopra, but he's been forgotten.

My ideal team for Nagpur:

Sehwag
Kaif (even though I'd like to see Chopra there but anyways...)
Dravid
Tendulkar (If Fit) / Yuvraj
Laxman
Ganguly (c)
Patel (even though I'd like to see Dinesh Karthik in this spot)
Irfan Pathan
Agarkar
Harbhajan
Kumble
If Patel is playing then why shouldnt he be prefered over Kaif as an opener ?
 

SJS

Hall of Fame Member
Deja moo said:
Nehra has reported fit for the third test.

IMO, Nehra would be a better bet for the dustbowl that is Nagpur rather than AA .
I concur. Actualy he is a better bowler on all tacks. He is a bit emoty above the shoulders but Agarkar is no great brains either. Maybe a tad bit smarter than Nehra but Nehra is a far better bowler and more consistent.
 

masterblaster

International Captain
SJS said:
I concur. Actualy he is a better bowler on all tacks. He is a bit emoty above the shoulders but Agarkar is no great brains either. Maybe a tad bit smarter than Nehra but Nehra is a far better bowler and more consistent.
Just difference in opinion I guess, but against Australia, I'd always go for Agarkar over Nehra or Zaheer.
 

Deja moo

International Captain
SJS said:
I concur. Actualy he is a better bowler on all tacks. He is a bit emoty above the shoulders but Agarkar is no great brains either. Maybe a tad bit smarter than Nehra but Nehra is a far better bowler and more consistent.

Exactly.

Ideally Brett Lee too should be brought into the Aussie side. Nagpur is a pitch where only way the pacers could hope to dismiss the batsmen is either if the batsmen mess up themselves, or by bowling yorkers .

Whether the Aussies would be bold enough to drop McGrath for Lee is another matter .
 

masterblaster

International Captain
SJS said:
If Patel is playing then why shouldnt he be prefered over Kaif as an opener ?
There'd be far too much pressure on the young man to open and to wicketkeep, plus it'd probably affect his keeping negatively even more, so I wouldn't do it.

He's a gutsy batsman, we need a strong tail and thanks to Patel and Irfan, our tail has been wagging, which has hardly ever happened before.
 

Top