• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

McGrath. Marshall. Hadlee.

Rank them


  • Total voters
    28

kyear2

International Coach
It was obvious to anyone watching him in the 2000s. The flat pitch era thing is a bit overdone.
Didn't say I didn't notice it, always wonder why no one brings it up.

I wasn't ever going to 🤣

But note that not every where had that bounce and dint have the movement the earlier era had.
 

Johan

International Debutant
honestly I can also see a case for Hadlee over McGrath but McGrath was better on flatties and performed better in the home of the strongest batting he could bowl against (India) so I'd give it to him, Hadlee needed a huge tour of windies honestly.
 

Fanboy375

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
honestly I can also see a case for Hadlee over McGrath but McGrath was better on flatties and performed better in the home of the strongest batting he could bowl against (India) so I'd give it to him, Hadlee needed a huge tour of windies honestly.
Mcgrath didn't face Aus who had the strongest batting lineup but Hadlee faced Aus,Ind,Pak and WI who had better batting power than his own team
 

subshakerz

Hall of Fame Member
honestly I can also see a case for Hadlee over McGrath but McGrath was better on flatties and performed better in the home of the strongest batting he could bowl against (India) so I'd give it to him, Hadlee needed a huge tour of windies honestly.
Yeah Hadlee had a moderate away series against WI, a huge tour would have really solidified his case.

As it is, his career is mainly Eng, Aus and NZ.
 

Fanboy375

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
Between 2002-2007, there were only two standout fast bowlers.

McGrath: 44 Tests. 190 wickets. Avg of 21.15. SR of 52.8

Shoaib : 30 Tests. 132 wickets. Avg of 21.94. SR of 39.3
Waqar also had amazing early career.19 ave in first 4 years but after that he couldn't keep up.But also Mcgrath being different is that unlike Waqar and Shoaib he isn't a fast bowler with extreme pace.That is why he is so consistent like Wasim unlike Shoaib and Waqar
 

kyear2

International Coach
Obviously.


McGrath doesn't need to much movement.
Why would I bring it up?

Would you? It's really similar to Sachin.

A lot of his legacy is based on playing in the 90's. But even then his pitches at home were flat, way flatter than the ones every where else.

Have you ever brought it up, ever?
 

kyear2

International Coach
honestly I can also see a case for Hadlee over McGrath but McGrath was better on flatties and performed better in the home of the strongest batting he could bowl against (India) so I'd give it to him, Hadlee needed a huge tour of windies honestly.
It's about moments and tours and when and against whom.

Those are the things that create legacies.

Think Marshall and McGrath had more big moments in big series, especially abroad.
 

subshakerz

Hall of Fame Member
Why would I bring it up?

Would you? It's really similar to Sachin.

A lot of his legacy is based on playing in the 90's. But even then his pitches at home were flat, way flatter than the ones every where else.

Have you ever brought it up, ever?
I did mention that the flat pitch thing was overdone by the likes of you and that it was nowhere near as flat as Pakistani pancakes Wasim bowled on.
 

subshakerz

Hall of Fame Member
It's about moments and tours and when and against whom.

Those are the things that create legacies.

Think Marshall and McGrath had more big moments in big series, especially abroad.
Hadlee had those but because he was NZ, didn't get highlight except for Aus 85 tour.
 

kyear2

International Coach
I did mention that the flat pitch thing was overdone by the likes of you and that it was nowhere near as flat as Pakistani pancakes Wasim bowled on.
I was making reference to Sachin and his pitches at home during the '90's.
 

Top