• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

ING Cup

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
No, number 6 is a specialist batsman slot.

He was selected as a batsman who can provide back-up.

The only people who bring in the words all-rounder are the media and the general public.
 
Well that body of people outnumbers a few selectors. Using that logic, I am not a selector, so what you are saying does not apply to me. You aren't either. We are members of the general public, who are the ones calling him an allrounder. Therefore what's the problem here?
 

marc71178

Eyes not spreadsheets
The point is, he clearly is not, has never been selected as, and has never once even hinted that he is an all-rounder.

He is a batsman who can fill in, and his selection is on those grounds.
 

age_master

Hall of Fame Member
Mark Waugh has been named captain of the NSW side for the ING cup match vs Victoria. the matchj will be evened up a little by the test match which involves S Waugh, Katich, Macgill and Bracken. McGrath is also missing due to ijnjury, the NSW side still looks the goods to win with Bevan and Lee returning from injury.

Mark Waugh (c)
Phil Jaques
Dominic Thornely
Michael Clarke
Michael Bevan
Brad Haddin
Shawn Bradstreet
Brett Lee
Stuart Clark
Matthew Nicholson
Aaron O'Brien
Liam Zammit


Zammit i imagine will be 12th man. hopefully Mark Waugh will open with thornley, he seems to bat better there.
 
Well now that's a real kick in the nuts for Slater. What was originally said was that with the return of Michael Clarke from India it was difficult for Slater to keep his place. Now with a whole bunch of players heading up to Brisbane he still can't get a game. Suits me fine though, I've never been a fan of his...
 

Mister Wright

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Slater doesn't deserve a spot in the One Day squad for NSW he hasn't been performing for a number of seasons, especially this season. If he wants to hold on to his Pura Cup spot he should just concerntrate on that, he is only averaging about 17 and there and his first-class career average is about to drop under 40.
 
There's two games coming up this weekend. Western Australia vs Tassie on Friday night, and NSW vs Victoria on Sunday. It's a pretty straightforward bet for mine; WA and NSW. Don't put that down to bias as I come from Perth and live in the ACT :D

I think the WA batting will murder the Tassie bowling attack. The Tassie attack is lead by Damien Wright and Adam Griffith, but even them I have little regard for, although I do like the look of Brett Geeves. I think the WA has the batting and the bowling to dispose of Tassie easily. With Goodwin, Hussey, North, Rogers, plus the allrounders it should be fairly easy to score.

The WA bowling is looking a little worse this year than it has in the past, but they do have the goods. Thistle, Clark, Worthington (who is more a genuine allrounder), Casson, Wilson. I'm not sure how many of those are available however.

It will be interesting to see how the 11th test playing nation (NSW) deal with Victoria in the absence of their Australian representatives. NSW have relied heavily on players like Katich and Steve Waugh to score heavily in the ING cup this year, but they're off to Brisbane. One would think that the batting will be spearheaded by Clarke and Mark Waugh, and the bowling bolstered by the return of Brett Lee.
This game is being played at the MCG, so it's hard to say who will have the advantage going into the game as the MCG wicket is a real chameleon. It changes as often as the weather.
The Victorian team have looked good this season and they haven't lost any players to the Australian side so I assume they will be playing at full strength. The biggest worry for the NSW bowling is that they dispose of Hodge quickly and cheaply.
On the whole, both teams look pretty even with NSW understrength, but I think they've got what it takes to stave off the Victorians (two words: Michael Clarke).
 
Last edited:
I don't think so. If there's any pattern to the names that were announced in the squad then we could see any of Jaques/Thornely/Waugh opening, with the person who doesn't open being relegated to 3. That would leave Clarke 4, Bevan 5 and Haddin 6.
 

Mr. P

International Vice-Captain
Well I suppose a positive for Tassie so far is that Shane Watson seems to be playing well. Full credit to WA however.:)
 
We should get the full report from Linda :lol:.
Shane Watson's batting has improved a hell of a lot. He has a very good technique these days, as long as his bowling turns up okay he has a free pass back into the one day side at Harvey's expense (or Symonds if he doesn't play another career saving innings).
I must say that what I've seen of Watson on TV this season is that he doesn't play like a lot of allrounders with barely any technique. That could be part of why he's actually had success at international level, he's got a good head on his shoulders.
 
Great knock by Watson, steadied the ship when they needed it most. If the lower order for Tasmania can fire, they could be in for a defendable total. However at the moment, WA should still be thinking about a bonus point.
 
FANTASTIC innings by North! I've said that this kid is good, and he carried WA tonight. 75* off 96 balls to get WA to 7/197. Brilliant.
 

Linda

International Vice-Captain
I was very impressed with my man Kade Harvey (3 wickets for a medium pacer, come on) and newbie John Taylor. No body expected him to do much (there were quite a few 'Taylor who?'s).

The Tassie bowlers weren't that great (not taking any credit from North, Ged), with the exception of Griffith.

Hey, Im just glad we got another bonus point.:duh:
 
The Tassie bowlers were good enough to take 7 wickets inside 40 overs. They were good enough to knock over Hussey and Goodwin, WA's two form batsmen, for 2 runs combined.
In fact, they were good enough for a lot of things. :P
It was their batsmen that didn't put up a big enough total. 20-30 runs more might have done it.
 

Top