very true, although out of that group i would think Ganguly, Tendulkar, Agarkar, Zaheer & Harbhajan should go to the WC.Sanz said:If India go with players like Ganguly, Tendulkar, Laxman, Raina, Santh, Agarkar, Kumble, Zaheer, Harbhajan then I am sure we will end up in the bottom half. There is no way we will be able to compete with Pak, SA, Australia, England and NZ.
Thats probably on the money. I think that Patel & Harris will be fighting it out for the remaining spot, or perhaps Harris & Franklin.NEW ZEALAND 15-MAN SQUAD:
Fleming, McCullum, Vincent, Astle, How, Fulton, Marshall, Styris, Oram, Vettori, Patel, Bond, Adams, Franklyn, Mills.
didn't realis Harris was still playing cricket, thought he was finished well if so he could well and go but that will depend on domestic performances i would think. But i have seen a fair deal of your side of late and i reckon thats probably the best 15 that you could take...Tim said:Thats probably on the money. I think that Patel & Harris will be fighting it out for the remaining spot, or perhaps Harris & Franklin.
Jesse Ryder was being suggested as a surprise selection not so long ago, but I think his former NZ U19 team-mate Ross Taylor is starting to push his credentials..and he could be a bolter ahead of Astle. But it's unlikely I think.
I know..and that's I predict that India wont be in the final four.aussie said:very true, although out of that group i would think Ganguly, Tendulkar, Agarkar, Zaheer & Harbhajan should go to the WC.
wouldn't Wavel hinds, Samuels, Powell or Ryan Hinds be better options than Ganga?. Also for WI sake you should hope Collins if fit haven't seen kelly so cant comment, but Butler didn't look too great in SRI what about Darren Powell. With the spinner it depends on how Lewis goes in the coming year he & banks will battle it out.Mr Mxyzptlk said:Stepping out on a limb, my Windies side:
Ramnaresh Sarwan (C)
Denesh Ramdin (wk) (vc)
Brian Lara
Shiv Chanderpaul
Chris Gayle
Daren Ganga
Dwayne Smith
Runako Morton
Dwayne Bravo
Ian Bradshaw
Corey Collymore
Richard Kelly
Fidel Edwards
Omari Banks
Deighton Butler - or Reyad Emrit
Collins will be injured and miss the tournament.
Would have Marlon Samuels or Devon Smith in place of Ganga. otherwise looks fine.Mr Mxyzptlk said:Stepping out on a limb, my Windies side:
Ramnaresh Sarwan (C)
Denesh Ramdin (wk) (vc)
Brian Lara
Shiv Chanderpaul
Chris Gayle
Daren Ganga
Dwayne Smith
Runako Morton
Dwayne Bravo
Ian Bradshaw
Corey Collymore
Richard Kelly
Fidel Edwards
Omari Banks
Deighton Butler - or Reyad Emrit
Collins will be injured and miss the tournament.
I considered that. Powell, no. Wavell Hinds, close, but I somehow don't envision him in the World Cup squad. I just have a hunch that Ganga will be in the squad, though I'd love to see Ryan Hinds there. Hey, Hinds may even get the spinner's role.aussie said:wouldn't Wavel hinds, Samuels, Powell or Ryan Hinds be better options than Ganga?. Also for WI sake you should hope Collins if fit haven't seen kelly so cant comment, but Butler didn't look too great in SRI what about Darren Powell. With the spinner it depends on how Lewis goes in the coming year he & banks will battle it out.
The West Indies selectors don't seem to be very fond of Devon Smith in ODIs. Ganga is as good of an OD batsman as Marlon Samuels IMO. Ganga scored 88 runs from his first 10 ODI innings. Since then, 8 of his last 18 ODI innings have been half-centuries.ramkumar_gr said:Would have Marlon Samuels or Devon Smith in place of Ganga. otherwise looks fine.
nah Smith seems made for OD cricket WI would be wrong not to pick him, he can give you some overs of lively medim-pace & is superb in the field.Mr Mxyzptlk said:EDIT: Re: Marlon Samuels, I almost put him in ahead of Banks as the spinner in the squad. I think he may be in the squad next year, but I'm not sure who for. I'd love to see him there ahead of Smith, but that's not likely.