Steve Smith vs Sachin Tendulkar (after 205 innings)

[Narayana]

bruh

tho tbh the only people I've personally seen who screamed ATG from just viewing experience were Sachin Tendulkar, Brian Lara and AB De Villiers

Kohli during 2018 ?

 

[Johan]

Kohli during 2018 ?

I don't break it down into timeframes tbh

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Roots legacy will depend on 2025 ashes and if he can keep his average above 50.

If he retires averaging 48/49, then most people will rate him below Dravid and all other ATGs.

I expect him to do well in Aus tho. Surely he can’t go 20 games without scoring a hundred.

 

[Johan]

Now Sutcliffe looks like a proper ATG bat

 

[govinda indian fan]

Roots legacy will depend on 2025 ashes and if he can keep his average above 50.

If he retires averaging 48/49, then most people will rate him below Dravid and all other ATGs.

I expect him to do well in Aus tho. Surely he can’t go 20 games without scoring a hundred.

If he doesnt that would be shocking

 

[Narayana]

Now Sutcliffe looks like a proper ATG bat

I like Rahul Dravid batting, he is a stylish player, same with kane Williamson.

 

[Johan]

I like Rahul Dravid batting, he is a stylish player, same with kane Williamson.

seems like you like technical nudgers

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Not saying he's not good, but nothing about him screams out ATG when I watch him.

But yes, he has been the best in the world for a little while.

Finally something you and subs agree on. He doesn’t rate him as an ATG either.

I think he’s similar in quality to Dravid (slightly worse).

 

[Johan]

Finally something you and subs agree on. He doesn’t rate him as an ATG either.

I think he’s similar in quality to Dravid (slightly worse).

Subs and you should rate him as the GOAT after Smith

sports evolution etc

 

[DrWolverine]

bruh

tho tbh the only people I've personally seen who screamed ATG from just viewing experience were Sachin Tendulkar, Brian Lara and AB De Villiers

ABD.
So much talent.
He underperformed in test cricket

 

[DrWolverine]

Ashes 2025
It will play a huge role in legacies of Root & Smith

 

[Narayana]

ABD.
So much talent.
He underperformed in test cricket

Yes he retired before his downfall as well.

 

[capt_Luffy]

ABD.
So much talent.
He underperformed in test cricket

Yeah. I think if ODIs and especially T20s never existed, he would be a strong contender for Top 10 Ever. Was Great overall, but focused more on the LOs

 

[Johan]

The Three greatest batters of all time per PC/Subs theory

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Smiths legacy won’t be affected much by a home ashes. Bloke has like 8 hundreds in England lol.

Let’s see what his final average is though. It will be tough to keep it above 55.

 

[Thala_0710]

View attachment 45061
The Three greatest batters of all time per PC/Subs theory

The game has since evolved and now Kamindu, Brook and Jaiswal are the GOATs

 

[Johan]

The game has since evolved and now Kamindu, Brook and Jaiswal are the GOATs

Yeah nothing can go wrong as long as we ignore that Root outplays Brook frequently too

 

[Narayana]

Smiths legacy won’t be affected much by a home ashes. Bloke has like 8 hundreds in England lol.

Let’s see what his final average is though. It will be tough to keep it above 55.

His ashes average was 60+ before 23 ashes so the best ashes batsman after Bradman tag will be affected.

 

[Thala_0710]

Yeah nothing can go wrong as long as we ignore that Root outplays Brook frequently too

Jaiswal outperforms Kohli much much more though. Hence, the logic stands

 

[Johan]

Jaiswal outperforms Kohli much much more though. Hence, the logic stands

makes sense to me, everyone before 2010 were playing in a less competitive and amateur era, I don't know how people even rate such farmers tbh