wpdavid
Hall of Fame Member
I think that's a fair summation of the current situation from England's pov. Other might quibble your first sentence, but life's too short imo.Trent's someone who's prone to brainfades. Thats about it. Not an indication that he's a bad defender at a right back position.
What he offers to his team more than makes up for any perceived shortcomings in defense
It was a harder call when Walker was at or close to the peak of his powers and was able to do a decent job on the likes of Mbappe and Vinicius Jnr.
Some folks would still take TAA's superior attacking contributions, and others would take the view that Walker's superior defensive skills should be the deciding factor when we're choosing a RB for the national side. We've seen plenty of that on these pages, and no sane person would want to rehash that particular argument. But I would just say that it wasn't madness to prefer peak Walker, even if some people would have chosen TAA instead. And I would readily concede that's not where we're at now, so TAA it is.