• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* IPL 2021

Who wins it?


  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .

karan_fromthestands

State Captain
It is difficult for him to get in. As openers, there is Kohli, Rohit, Rahul and Dhawan above him in the pecking order and deservedly so. He is at best 5th in the list.
Shaw was easily ahead of all these guys, he had a very lean period and others have grabbed their opportunities!

I would still pick Shaw over Gill in tests, but it would be unfair at this point of time. So Shaw will definitely have to wait a little before he gets a crack at it. But I am happy that this is happening to Shaw, I mean he has faced adversity at the right time, he'll be better equipped to deal with these scenarios in the future.
 
Last edited:

Noumenon

U19 Vice-Captain
What has pecking order and queue got to do in sports where form *and* ability combined with role requirement should be enough for one to stake a claim.
 

Noumenon

U19 Vice-Captain
India fielded a prank bowling attack in T20s they played in Aus a few months back. Lack of penetration was clear to see even with Bumrah available.

I think this IPL season has done a lot to improve the field. Siraj has made a serious case as a white ball bowler and Avesh has been stellar. Axar and R Chahar have enhanced their reputation. Even Sundar looks accomplished bowling in this format. Enough spin options there to junk Kuldeep and Chahal altogether I think.

Bumrah, Siraj, Avesh, Bhuvi, R Chahar, Axar, and Jadeja. Ideally this ought to be the bowling pool for WT20.
 

JOJOXI

International Captain
Jadeja's improved batting in Limited Overs could be massive for India. If you could bat him and H Pandya at 6 and 7 interchangeably with H Pandya as a 6th bowler the batting is strengthened especially if you've got an Axar or Sundar at number 8 to accompany them. You could then go with Bhuvi, Siraj/Thakur and Bumrah as your 3 seamers. On seam friendly pitches perhaps Siraj instead of Thakur and on dryer pitches perhaps Thakur with his cutters - he looked decent v England. R Chahar worth having somewhere around the side too although personally think the deep batting helps then Rohit and Rahul have no reason to rein themselves in too much.

Rohit
Rahul/Dhawan (Rahul if you trust him to bat at a good SR for India)
Kohli
Suryakumar
Pant (wk)
Jadeja
H Pandya
Sundar
Bhuvneshwar
Siraj/Thakur
Bumrah
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
They seem to like opening with Virat. If that is the case,

Rohit
Virat
SKY
Pant
Hardik
Jaddu
Sundar
Shardul
Bhuvi
Chahar
Bumrah

wont mind this side tbh. More bowlers the better...
 

Noumenon

U19 Vice-Captain
Sundar is two levels below both R Chahar and Axar as a spinner and practically useless as a batsman down the order. Do not want.

Shardul shouldn't even be in conversations. Bhuvi and D chahar cannot play together. That'd be India going back to a prank attack.
 

Noumenon

U19 Vice-Captain
Rohit and Virat have become millstone around India's WT20 ambitions. KLR was meant to deliver us from that style but he's now emulating them.
 

JOJOXI

International Captain
They seem to like opening with Virat. If that is the case,

Rohit
Virat
SKY
Pant
Hardik
Jaddu
Sundar
Shardul
Bhuvi
Chahar
Bumrah

wont mind this side tbh. More bowlers the better...
Feels like 1 batsman too few - Jadeja and Hardik both good but not sure I'd trust them as a number 5 and 6 without a close to specialist batsman behind them. Think such a lineup encourages more conservatism from Rohit and Virat as SKY and Pant especially the sort of players who could get out playing a poor shot first ball - not a criticism I think their positivity in middle overs is a good thing but it carries risk - potentially too much risk if you've only got 4 specialist batsman then Hardik and Jadeja - if you are in the semi-final and 20/2 after 3 overs India are in a big hole with such a relatively shallow batting lineup. I know Sundar can bat but I'd prefer a Rahul or more stable batsman in the top 5 if you are going to have Sundar at 7.


Sundar is two levels below both R Chahar and Axar as a spinner and practically useless as a batsman down the order. Do not want.

Shardul shouldn't even be in conversations. Bhuvi and D chahar cannot play together. That'd be India going back to a prank attack.
Sundar went at under 6 in the IPL last year, despite not being used at the best times this season he still is going at 7.37 an over. Axar and Sundar have very similar IPL records last year - Axar with one more wicket but also 0.5 rpo more expensive. Axar has a slightly better international T20 record but I'm not sure that's enough to suggest Axar is 2 levels above Sundar. Especially when Sundar is a powerplay bowling specialist and the seamers you've all named are good options for the death. Deepak Chahar has a good T20 record in India and has started this season decently - good with the new ball if you have Bumrah, Bhuvi and Siraj or Thakur they can all bowl at the death so you don't even really need D Chahar for that - get wickets with the new ball and he's fine. D Chahar wouldn't be in my first choice XI but if say a Bhuvi got injured you could use him as a new ball specialist - Siraj/Thakur and Bumrah could bowl 2 each in the final 4 overs and D Chahar maybe the 16th, you've also got Jadeja and H Pandya who could easily bowl 5 overs between them as well.

Might be controversial but I wouldn't write Chahal off quite yet either - it seems like 5 games have seen him gone from starter to public enemy number 1 almost. He has been a regular wicket taking threat for India for a few years and had 21 wickets in the IPL less than a year ago in IPL 2020. India could name as many as 22 players in their squad and given R Chahar is relatively untested internationally and its not like he didn't go for runs himself v England in the T20Is I'd want another wristspinner in the squad if I was India or at the very least Ashwin.


My 22 for WT20 would be the following I think

Kohli, Rohit, Dhawan, Rahul, Kishan, Suryakumar, Iyer, Pant, K Pandya H Pandya, Jadeja, Sundar, Thakur, D Chahar, B Kumar, Bumrah, Natarajan, Chahal, R Chahar, Ashwin ** Siraj **, Samson **

** = The ICC have expanded squad restrictions of 15 players and 8 backroom staff to 30 overall so squads could have up to 22 players - however, in the case they bring across a couple extra staff members as well as players I'd get rid of Samson, Siraj and Ashwin in that order
 

Noumenon

U19 Vice-Captain
If Shaw's form holds for the rest of the IPL, it'd take some breathtaking brazenness to keep him out of the XI for WT20.
 

Noumenon

U19 Vice-Captain
Punjab Kings do not have such an abundance of talent that they can keep Sarfaraz Khan out of the playing XI. He should have been playing at 4 since game 1.
 

karan_fromthestands

State Captain
What has pecking order and queue got to do in sports where form *and* ability combined with role requirement should be enough for one to stake a claim.
You can't just keep chopping and changing your team, it sends out a wrong signal and creates insecurity. There will always be new names coming up every now and then and every domestic season will have a few standout players, but changes shouldn't happen unless they are necessary.

Players should only be selected if they are good enough and should get a decent chance to showcase their skills once they are in the team. Unfortunately, the current coach, captain and selectors are known for making too many changes, hope this stops. With regards to Prithvi, age is on his side and I am sure he'll get his chances.
 

karan_fromthestands

State Captain
India fielded a prank bowling attack in T20s they played in Aus a few months back. Lack of penetration was clear to see even with Bumrah available.

I think this IPL season has done a lot to improve the field. Siraj has made a serious case as a white ball bowler and Avesh has been stellar. Axar and R Chahar have enhanced their reputation. Even Sundar looks accomplished bowling in this format. Enough spin options there to junk Kuldeep and Chahal altogether I think.

Bumrah, Siraj, Avesh, Bhuvi, R Chahar, Axar, and Jadeja. Ideally this ought to be the bowling pool for WT20.
Chahal should definitely be dumped, I don't care if Kuldeep is not considered for white ball cricket but he has some serious potential in the longest format. All the names you mentioned are quality and can surely get their chances in the shorter formats.
 

karan_fromthestands

State Captain
Punjab Kings do not have such an abundance of talent that they can keep Sarfaraz Khan out of the playing XI. He should have been playing at 4 since game 1.
Murugan Ashwin over Bishnoi was baffling, and Sarfaraz's omission is even worse. Also, Arshdeep is out? Coz the captain is selfish AF with the bat and doesn't score at a quick rate?
 

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Rahul.casually hit 91(50) at the start of the season, he can clearly still strike it if he chooses. Either push yourself down the order and let Gayle go crazy in the PP or cut the anchor crap Rahul.
 

MW1304

Cricketer Of The Year
He's dire to watch atm. This is who people want opening the batting for India? Will waste the powerplay every time.
 

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Rahul is apparently striking at under 100 in the PP this IPL after having faced 110+ balls and having played 3 games at armehebad.
 

karan_fromthestands

State Captain
He's dire to watch atm. This is who people want opening the batting for India? Will waste the powerplay every time.
Even when Shaw was going through a rough patch, he was just playing his natural game. At no point did he try to play conservatively to get his own form back. That's the kind of players you need in LOI cricket, wickets are flat AF and any total can be chased, players like Rahul can lose you games without drawing attention to their shitty approach.

Rahul can score at a decent click, but will not care about the team as soon as he starts losing some form.
 

Arachnodouche

International Captain
Waiting game paying off for KL tonight but the odds are always going to be against him in T20s. Doesn't look great when he gets out for a 45 off 40.
 

Top