• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** New Zealand in Australia 2015

Moss

International Captain
Did pretty well in UAIstan though. Both Trent and Tim had a fair bit success in the sub continent too
Yeah, bit of an exaggeration to say the attack is swing-or-bust, but Plan B clearly missing on this tour.

Personally I think McCullum, and the team to a lesser extent, bought into the hype that all out attack a la Steve Waugh era Aus is the only way to go, forgetting that the patience game was something that actually served them well in places like the Windies and the UAE.
 

jonbrooks

International Debutant
Yep, 'umpires call' allows the same event (ball clipping) to be treated differently depending on the umpires imperfect reaction. I think most here agree it should be revised.
I don't think it should be revised. If it is marginal then it should be umpire's call. That's what they're there for. Overall the 50/50s will even out over time. DRS is there for the howlers e.g. inside edge on to pad given out lbw etc.
 

Spark

Global Moderator
Yeah, bit of an exaggeration to say the attack is swing-or-bust, but Plan B clearly missing on this tour.

Personally I think McCullum, and the team to a lesser extent, bought into the hype that all out attack a la Steve Waugh era Aus is the only way to go, forgetting that the patience game was something that actually served them well in places like the Windies and the UAE.
All out attack doesn't really suit this attack either tbh, with line-and-length swing bowlers. They really should be looking to emulate Anderson/Broad who are much more fond of the squeeze, rather than trying to blast batsmen out with magic balls and hyper-attacking fields.
 

jcas0167

International Regular
Possibly, but the alternative is the Umps just become mere ornaments who stand their to hold the bowlers cap and sweater (considering no-balls can be checked on wickets.) If that's what you want, then you should make it clear and say so.
Provided you get more consistent and accurate decisions that's not really a concern for me at this level.
 

SteveNZ

Cricketer Of The Year
Possibly, but the alternative is the Umps just become mere ornaments who stand their to hold the bowlers cap and sweater (considering no-balls can be checked on wickets.) If that's what you want, then you should make it clear and say so.
Look, I'd have no technology (for LBWs) and accept it as part of the game, rather than deal with the vagaries of a computer system (I understand that's not in keeping with the professional environment...but it seems like we debate said computer system as an alternative to competency of umpires.). And I'd also have one unsuccessful review.
 
Last edited:

Dan

Hall of Fame Member
Completely agree on the context of the game, but I still think it needs amending to at least not losing your review. The nonsense Burns one, no doubt we needed to lose.
Don't. ****ing. Review. Marginal. Decisions.

Simple.
 

Skyliner

State Captain
I feel a little sorry for Boult and Southee. So good in the right conditions. Masterly in fact. Yet these conditions do not suit bowlers of their type. What do ya do?
 

Cabinet96

Hall of Fame Member
I feel a little sorry for Boult and Southee. So good in the right conditions. Masterly in fact. Yet these conditions do not suit bowlers of their type. What do ya do?
In Boult's case, in particular, not bowling like a drain tends to help.
 

jonbrooks

International Debutant
I feel a little sorry for Boult and Southee. So good in the right conditions. Masterly in fact. Yet these conditions do not suit bowlers of their type. What do ya do?
What you do is have a plan B i.e. bowl to a field, bowl in the correct channels, don't give the batsmen easy runs etc. They have not been doing this. Both Southee and Boult have been guilty of bowling all over the place. I haven't been watching (too painful) but have they put the pitch map up for Southee and Boult's bowling? I seriously doubt you'd find a good concentration of balls in any one given area.
 

SteveNZ

Cricketer Of The Year
Don't. ****ing. Review. Marginal. Decisions.

Simple.
You'd do the same if you were an international captain my man. Hence why I said make it one review, so they don't.

Is Boult off the field with injury? Shame to see him come to Australia, quite clearly still worrisome about his injury and not prepared to bend his back. 12 months too late, this series. Hopefully finds it later in the summer.
 

Top