• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** Pakistan and England in the UAE 2015/16

Compton

Compton

International Debutant
The decision made sense. I wouldn't go as far to say I absolutely agree with it, but it does make sense.
 
P

Pothas

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Cabinet96 said:
Not really. It wasn't even an annoying "umpires call sucks" one because it was literally scrapping the bails.
Click to expand...
Do we even know if what he thought about the height though? He clearly just gave it out because he thought he hit it.

I dunno it makes no difference to the result but it just feels so annoying in a pitch where it is so ridiculously hard to get wickets.
 
Compton

Compton

International Debutant
Midwinter said:
"Turns out Oxenfrod thought there was an inside edge, with Stokes diving to take the catch, but since he didn't give it out lbw, then umpire's call is not out. Got that? Good"

Doesn't an appeal cover all forms of dismissal.

Can some one pleas explain why if the ball was caught off the bat, an appeal is made that it can then be not out ?

Have the rules changed that you have to appeal for each form of dismissal seperately ?
Click to expand...
The appeal can cover all forms all it likes, but the umpire didn't give him out c Stokes lbw b Anderson.

He can only be out one method, and the umpire gave him out caught. The umpire did not think it was out lbw. So umpire's call on the ball tracker was not out lbw.
 
M

Midwinter

State Captain
Compton said:
The appeal can cover all forms all it likes, but the umpire didn't give him out c Stokes lbw b Anderson.

He can only be out one method, and the umpire gave him out caught. The umpire did not think it was out lbw. So umpire's call on the ball tracker was not out lbw.
Click to expand...
Thanks for that , missed the bit about it not being a catch
 
Compton

Compton

International Debutant
Rashid has bowled well today. Shame he still needs another wicket to keep that bowling average under 3 figures...
 
Cabinet96

Cabinet96

Hall of Fame Member
Pothas said:
Do we even know if what he thought about the height though? He clearly just gave it out because he thought he hit it.
Click to expand...
True actually. The on field umpire was the one who gave it not out in the end though, so if he'd originally thought it was smashing into the stumps he would've presumably just given it out. It would've been nice to listen to the umpire chat like we did in the summer though.
 
Compton

Compton

International Debutant
Cabinet96 said:
True actually. The on field umpire was the one who gave it not out in the end though, so if he'd originally thought it was smashing into the stumps he would've presumably just given it out. It would've been nice to listen to the umpire chat like we did in the summer though.
Click to expand...
According to Bumble he told the third umpire immediately that it was out caught, not leg before.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top