• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official*** India in Australia 2011/12

Teja.

Global Moderator
I know most people will disagree but Ishant Sharma getting injured is either a blessing in disguise or will have negligible impact this way or the other on the series, IMO.

I don't think one that there was any chance Sharma would have had an effective series' in Australia though he might have had a promising, aesthetically appealing one.

While I'm all for giving chances to players and everything but when one is consistently lolbad (averaging 50+) while facing decent opposition over the last two years, one must get some lessons out of it. His exploits essentially consist of him beating up on NZ in India in one test and WI in India over three tests. He also averaged 35 vs Oz in the one test he played against them last year

Apart from that he averages over fifty as a bowler in every test series he has played in since the beginning of 2010.

Ishant Sharma - Averages from the beginning of 2010

SA in India - 78.66(2 tests)
India in SL - 61.7(3 tests)
Oz in India - 35(1 test)
NZ in India - 8.2(1 test)
India in SA - 48.1(1 test)
India in WI - 16.8(3 test)
India in England - 58.1(4 tests)
WI in India - 67.4(3 tests)

Based on the above, How is Sharma likely to perform when playing an Australian line-up at home? Reckon it's obvious.

It's pretty shocking how staggeringly bad his bowling is in most series' which represent the tiniest bit of a challenge itbt. A bowling average of 48+ in 5/8 series' played consisting of 13/18 tests(72%) in that time is not int'l standard, IMO and the odd WI rout on bowling friendly wickets should not change that.
 

Athlai

Not Terrible
Heh deriding Ishant for "beating up" on NZ in one Test is pretty funny considering how no other Indian bowler really bothered us in the other two Tests.

If not for Sharma India could have had a humiliating drawn series against NZ when they were still ranked the supposed best in the world.
 

Teja.

Global Moderator
Heh deriding Ishant for "beating up" on NZ in one Test is pretty funny considering how no other Indian bowler really bothered us in the other two Tests.

If not for Sharma India could have had a humiliating drawn series against NZ when they were still ranked the supposed best in the world.
Yeah, It was a decent performance, Sree got the top two still, IIRC and the ball was moving in NZ first Innings.

Still reckon the central point of the post is valid. The majority of the time, He averages 50+ with the ball which freakishly seems to coincide with him playing decent oppo a lot.
 

Xuhaib

International Coach
Ishant is an interesting one. He's still young if he gets it right in the next couple of years then India could still have a gun bowler that could play for another decade. On the contrary if a bowler shows little sign of any improvement over a period of 40 tests then you have to wonder weather does he have any upside potential or not? its a case quite similar to Umer Akmal for Pakistan.
 

sreeku7

School Boy/Girl Captain
I know most people will disagree but Ishant Sharma getting injured is either a blessing in disguise or will have negligible impact this way or the other on the series, IMO.

I don't think one that there was any chance Sharma would have had an effective series' in Australia though he might have had a promising, aesthetically appealing one.

While I'm all for giving chances to players and everything but when one is consistently lolbad (averaging 50+) while facing decent opposition over the last two years, one must get some lessons out of it. His exploits essentially consist of him beating up on NZ in India in one test and WI in India over three tests. He also averaged 35 vs Oz in the one test he played against them last year

Apart from that he averages over fifty as a bowler in every test series he has played in since the beginning of 2010.

Ishant Sharma - Averages from the beginning of 2010

SA in India - 78.66(2 tests)
India in SL - 61.7(3 tests)
Oz in India - 35(1 test)
NZ in India - 8.2(1 test)
India in SA - 48.1(1 test)
India in WI - 16.8(3 test)
India in England - 58.1(4 tests)
WI in India - 67.4(3 tests)

Based on the above, How is Sharma likely to perform when playing an Australian line-up at home? Reckon it's obvious.

It's pretty shocking how staggeringly bad his bowling is in most series' which represent the tiniest bit of a challenge itbt. A bowling average of 48+ in 5/8 series' played consisting of 13/18 tests(72%) in that time is not int'l standard, IMO and the odd WI rout on bowling friendly wickets should not change that.
May be he:will bowl better when he is injured
 

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Zaheer Yadav Praveen Ashwin could very well be our full strength attack in the near future

Ishant and Ojha will be backups while Vinay/Irfan/Mithun will fight for the last slot
 

sreeku7

School Boy/Girl Captain
Zaheer Yadav Praveen Ashwin could very well be our full strength attack in the near future

Ishant and Ojha will be backups while Vinay/Irfan/Mithun will fight for the last slot
Need at least 5 last slots to fit in Mithun or Vinay :D
 

Cruxdude

International Debutant
While the bowling was disappointing, they just landed in Australia the previous day at 3 am and had the Bradman Oration to attend the same evening. The general aura of secrecy about players injuries is maddening to say the least. One can not be sure about Ishant's status till Boxing day comes.
 

Burgey

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Just heard on the radio Pattinson and adiddle have injuries heading into Boxing Day.

Excellent.
 

Top