AFL Draft

[Jono]

Btw, when I wasn't taking part in this, I was going to request if I could choose which team(s) I liked, and why. Not necessarily criticise others, just state which ones tickled my fancy, but since I took part in the end, how about anyone that wants to can?

I've stated a while earlier that I really like the way Hoggy's team was shaping up, but I haven't had a proper look since then.

I may have a glance at them all tomorrow.

 

[Jono]

Never recovered in my mind from when Lockett had a day out on him when he got the record.

Yeah but Silvagni never recovered for me ever since I heard him commentate.

Tragic.

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Wouldn't mind people having a crack at what they think of mine. Personally, I reckon mine's pretty average except for my forward line, but maybe I'm biased

 

[pasag]

I like Clapo's side.

 

[Johnners]

I like Clapo's side.

Cause it's got about 10 ex-Carlton players in it no doubt

 

[Matt79]

Any big name players miss out? Somewhat suprised Scott Wynd and to a lesser extent Joe Misiti, Mal Michael, John Barnes and Max Hudghton aren't there.

Was going to take Hudghton but had a last minute epiphiny about Daryl White and took him instead. Was seriously tossing up between Ottens and Wynd for my second ruck, took Ottens as the more accomplished forward.

 

[Matt79]

Would have taken Tony Shaw if I didn't have to have a <50 gamer. Nearly took him over Didak.

 

[pasag]

Cause it's got about 10 ex-Carlton players in it no doubt

Maybe

Thread of '09, IMO. Very well run.

 

[Johnners]

1.1 vic_orthdox: Wayne Carey (CHF)
1.2 dcye: Gary Ablett Snr (CHF)
1.3 pasag: Chris Judd (Foll)
1.4 howardj: Ben Counsins (R)
1.5 Matteh: Tony Lockett (FF)
1.6 Cameel: Jason Dunstall (FF)
1.7 Clapo: Michael Voss (R)
1.8 Matt79: Nathan Buckley (C)
1.9 Hoggy31: Stephen Silvagni (FB)

2.1 Hoggy31: Adam Goodes (C)
2.2 Matt79: Jonathon Brown (CHF)
2.3 Clapo: Stephen Kernahan (CHF)
2.4 cameel: Glen Jakovich (CHF)
2.5 Howardj: Matthew Lloyd (FF)
2.6 Matteh: James Hird (C)
2.7 pasag: Robert Harvey (R)
2.8 dcye: Matthew Scarlett (CHB)
2.9 vic_orthdox: Chris Grant (CHB)

3.1 vic_orthdox: Mark Ricciuto (R)
3.2 dcye: Jim Stynes (R)
3.3 pasag: Greg Williams (C)
3.4 Howardj: Gary Ablett Jnr (R)
3.5 Matteh: Daniel Kerr (R)
3.6 cameel: Corery McKernan (R)
3.7 Clapo: Justin Leppitsch (CHB)
3.8 Matt79: Simon Black (R)
3.9 Hoggy31: Matthew Richardson (CHF/FF)

4.1 Hoggy31: Jason Akermanis (C)
4.2 Matt79: Dustin Fletcher (FB)
4.3 Clapo: Simon Madden (R)
4.4 cameel: David Schwarz (CHF)
4.5 Matteh: Dean Cox (R)
4.6 Howardj: Alastair Lynch (FF)
4.7 Pasag: Tony Modra (FF)
4.8 dcye: Darren Glass (FB)
4.9 vic_orthdox: John Platten (R)

5.1 vic_orthdox: Darren Jarman (C)
5.2 dcye: Matthew Pavlich (HF)
5.3 Pasag: Paul Kelly (C)
5.4 Howardj: James Clement (B)
5.5 Matteh: Sam Mitchell (R)
5.6 cameel: Danny Frawley (FB)
5.7 Clapo: Ben Rutten (FB)
5.8 Matt79: Brett Kirk (R)
5.9 Hoggy31: Paul Salmon (R)

6.1 Hoggy31: Jimmy Bartel (R)
6.2 Matt79: Andrew McLeod (HB)
6.3 Clapo: Craig Bradley (C)
6.4 cameel: Gavin Wanganeen (B)
6.5 Matteh: Nick Riewoldt (CHF)
6.6 Howardj: Glenn Archer (B)
6.7 Pasag: Jeff White (R)
6.8 dcye: Shane Crawford (C)
6.9 vic_orthdox: John Longmire (FF)

7.1 vic_orthdox: Peter Matera (W)
7.2 dcye: David Neitz (FF)
7.3 Pasag: Peter Dacois (F)
7.4 Howardj: Simon Prestigiacomo (FB)
7.5 Matteh: Chad Cornes (HB)
7.6 cameel: Anthony Koutoufides (C)
7.7 Clapo: Nigel Lappin (HB)
7.8 Matt79: Scott West (C)
7.9 Hoggy31: Brent Harvey (C)

8.1 Hoggy31: Lenny Hayes (R)
8.2 Matt79: John Worsfold (B)
8.3 Clapo: Luke Hodge (HB)
8.4 cameel: Steve Johnson (HF)
8.5 Matteh: Shannon Grant (HF/F)
8.6 Howardj: Dermott Brereton (CHF)
8.7 Pasag: Darren Gasper (FB)
8.8 dcye: Shane Woewodin (C)
8.9 vic_orthdox: Ashley McIntosh (FB)

9.1 vic_orthdox: Andrew McKay (HB
9.2 dcye: Joel Bowden (HB)
9.3 Pasag: Warren Tredrea (HF)
9.4 Howardj: Shaun Hart (R)
9.5 Matteh: John Blakey (HB)
9.6 cameel: Lance Franklin (F)
9.7 Clapo: Brendan Fevola (FF)
9.8 Matt79: Gary Ayres (B)
9.9 Hoggy31: Paul Roos (CHB)


10.1 Hoggy31: Brad Johnson (F)
10.2 Matt79: Gary Hocking (HF)
10.3 Clapo: Wayne Schwass (C)
10.4 cameel: Peter Bell (R)
10.5 Matteh: Michael Martyn (FB)
10.6 Howardj: Tadhg Kennelly (HB)
10.7 Pasag: Mark Mercuri (HF)
10.8 dcye: Guy McKenna (HB)
10.9 vic_orthdox: Shaun Rehn (R)

11.1 vic_orthdox: Simon Goodwin (C)
11.2 dcye: Ben Hart (FB)
11.3 Pasag: Tony Liberatore (R)
11.4 Howardj: Brett Delidio (C)
11.5 Matteh: Gary Lyon (HF)
11.6 cameel: Lance Franklin (HB)
11.7 Clapo: Paul Couch (C)
11.8 Matt79: Sav Rocca (FF)
11.9 Hoggy31: Nigel Smart (B)

12.1 Hoggy31: Nicky Winmar (HB)
12.2 Matt79: Tim Watson (HF)
12.3 Clapo: Nathan Brown (F)
12.4 cameel: Nathan Burke (R)
12.5 Matteh: Fraser Gehrig (F)
12.6 Howardj: Daniel Bradshaw (CHB)
12.7 Pasag: Ang Christou (B)
12.8 dcye: Nathan Bassett (B)
12.9 vic_orthdox: David King (B)

13.1 vic_orthdox: Phil Matera (F)
13.2 dcye: Tod Viney (C)
13.3 Pasag: Chris Langford (FB)
13.4 Jonoj: Tyson Edwards (C)
13.5 Matteh: Aaron Davey (C)
13.6 cameel: Michael Long (C)
13.7 Clapo: Paul Chapman (HF)
13.8 Matt79: Paul Williams (HF)
13.9 Hoggy31: Barry Hall (FF)

14.1 Hoggy31: Michael O'Loughlin (F)
14.2 Matt79: Jeff Farmer (F)
14.3 Clapo: Chris Johnson (B)
14.4 cameel: Joel Corey (HF)
14.5 Matteh: Craig Bolton (B)
14.6 Jono: Darren Milburn (HB)
14.7 Pasag: Leo Barry (B)
14.8 dcye: Kane Cornes (R)
14.9 vic_orthdox: Rohan Smith (B)

15.1 vic_orthdox: Dean Kemp (HF)
15.2 dcye: Brett Ratten (C)
15.3 Pasag: Michael Tuck (HB)
15.4 Jono: Leigh Colbert (CHB)
15.5 Matteh: Scott Pendlebury (C)
15.6 cameel: Nick Dal Santo (C)
15.7 Clapo: Chris Mainwaring (C)
15.8 Matt79: Mark Harvey (HB)
15.9 Hoggy31: Stewart Leowe (F)

16.1 Hoggy31: Aussie Jones (HB
16.2 Matt79: Daryl White (HB)
16.3 Clapo: Terry Daniher (F)
16.4 cameel: Doug Hawkins (C)
16.5 Matteh: Tom Harley (HB)
16.6 Jono: Clark Keating (R)
16.7 Pasag: Mil Hanna (HB)
16.8 dcye: Adam Yze (HF)
16.9 vic_orthdox: Stephen Tingay (HF)

17.1 vic_orthdox: Wayne Campbell (HF)
17.2 dcye: Russell Roberston (F)
17.3 Pasag: Scott Lucas (HF)
17.4 Jonoj: Nick Davis (F)
17.5 Matteh: Ryan O'Keefe
17.6 cameel: Roger Merrett (CHF)
17.7 Clapo: Gavin Brown (HF)
17.8 Matt79: Justin Madden (R)
17.9 Hoggy31: David Wirrpanda (B)

18.1 Hoggy31: Ben Allan (HF)
18.2 Matt79: Brad Ottens (F)
18.3 Clapo: Michael ***ton (B)
18.4 cameel: Marcus Ashcroft (B)
18.5 Matteh:
18.6 Jono: Andrew Embley (HF)
18.7 Pasag: Aaron Hamil (F)
18.8 dcye: Anthony Stevens (HF)
18.9 vic_orthdox: Luke Power (F)

19.1 vic_orthdox: Luke Darcy (R)
19.2 dcye: Peter Everitt (R)
19.3 Pasag: Matthew Primus (HF)
19.4 Jono: Matthew Knights (C)
19.5 Matteh:
19.6 cameel: Leon Davis (F/HF/C)
19.7 Clapo: Cyril Rioli (F/HF)
19.8 Matt79: Robert Dipierdomenico (C)
19.9 Hoggy31: Darren Bewick (HF)

20.1 Hoggy31: Adam Simpson (C/R)
20.2 Matt79: Cameron Ling (C/R)
20.3 Clapo: Brendon Lade (R)
20.4 cameel: Paul Haselby (C/R)
20.5 Matteh:
20.6 Jono: Trent Cotchin (C/R)
20.7 Pasag: Darren Milane (C/HF)
20.8 dcye: Daniel Rich (C/R)
20.9 vic_orthdox: Bowen Lockwood (F/HF)

21.1 vic_orthdox: Mark Bairstow (C)
21.2 dcye: Dean Solomon (HB/HF)
21.3 Pasag: Kurt Tippet (F)
21.4 Jono: Damien Hardwick (HB)
21.5 Matteh:
21.6 cameel: Allan Jakovich (F)
21.7 Clapo: Tony McGuiness (C/F)
21.8 Matt79: Alan Didak (C/HF/F)
21.9 Hoggy31: Nathan Bock (B-F)

22.1 Hoggy31: Adrian McAdam (F)
22.2 Matt79: John Anthony (F)
22.3 Clapo: Corey Enright (B/HB/C)
22.4 cameel: Liam Jurrah (F)
22.5 Matteh:
22.6 Jono: Michael Gardiner (R)
22.7 Pasag: Fraser Brown (C)
22.8 dcye: Brad Green (C/HF)
22.9 vic_orthdox: Michael Brennan (B)

 

[Johnners]

vic_orthdox:

B: Rohan Smith, Ashley McIntosh, David King
HB: Andrew McKay, Chris Grant, Wayne Campbell
C: Peter Matera, Darren Jarman, Simon Goodwin
HF: Stephen Tingay, Wayne Carey, Dean Kemp
F: Philip Matera, John Longmire, Luke Power
R: Shaun Rehn, Mark Riccuito, John Platten
Int: Luke Darcy, Bowen Lockwood, Mark Bairstow, Michael Brennan

dontcloseyoureyes:

B: Nathan Bassett, Matthew Scarlett, Ben Hart
HB: Joel Bowden, Darren Glass, Guy McKenna
C: Todd Viney, Brett Ratten, Shane Woewodin
HF: Gary Ablett Snr, Matthew Pavlich, Anthony Stevens
F: Russell Robertson, David Neitz (c), Adem Yze
R: Jimmy Stynes, Kane Cornes, Shane Crawford
Int: Peter Everitt, Daniel Rich, Dean Solomon, Brad Green

Pasag:

B: Leo Barry, Chris Langford, Ang Christou
HB: Mil Hanna, Darren Gasper, Michael Tuck
C: Paul Kelly, Greg Williams, Robert Harvey
HF: Scott Lucas, Warren Tredrea, Mark Mercuri
F: Peter Dacois, Tony Modra, Aaron Hamil
R: Jeff White, Chris Judd, Tony Liberatore
Int: Matthew Primus, Kurt Tippett, Darren Milane, Fraser Brown

Howardj/Jono:

B: James Clement, Simon Prestigiacomo, Glenn Archer
HB: Darren Milburn, Leigh Colbert, Tadgh Kennelly
C: Shaun Hart, Tyson Edwards, Brett Deledio
HF: Daniel Bradshaw, Dermott Brereton, Andrew Embley
F: Alastair Lynch, Matthew Lloyd, Nick Davis
R: Clark Keating, Gary Ablett Jnr, Ben Cousins
Int: Mattew Knights, Trent Cotchin, Damien Hardwick, Michael Gardiner

Matteh:

B: *, Michael Martyn, Craig Bolton
HB: Tom Harley, Chad Cornes, John Blakey
C: Scott Pendlebury, James Hird, Aaron Davey
HF: Garry Lyon, Nick Riewoldt, Ryan O'Keefe
F: Fraser Gehrig, Tony Lockett, Shannon Grant
R: Dean Cox, Daniel Kerr, Sam Mitchell
Int: *, *, *, *

cameel:

B: Gavin Wanganeen, Danny Frawley, Marcos Ashcroft
HB: Michael Long, Glen Jakovich, Byron Pickett
C: Nick Dal Santo, Anthony Koutoufides, Doug Hawkins
HF: Joel Corey, Roger Merritt, David Schwarz
F: Steve Johnson, Jason Dunstall, Lance Franklin
R: Corey McKernan, Peter Bell, Nathan Burke
Int: Leon Davis, Paul Haselby, Allan Jakovich, Liam Jurrah

Clapo:

B: Michael ***ton, Ben Rutten, Chris Johnson
HB: Luke Hodge, Justin Leppitsch, Nigel Lappin
C: Chris Mainwaring, Paul Couch, Wayne Schwass
HF: Paul Chapman, Stephen Kernahan, Gavin Brown
F: Nathan G. Brown, Brendon Fevola, Terry Daniher
R: Simon Madden, Michael Voss, Craig Bradley
Int: Cyril Rioli, Brendon Lade, Tony McGuiness, Corey Enright

Matt79:

B: John Worsfold, Dustin Fletcher, Gary Ayres
HB: Andrew McLeod, Mark Harvey, Darryl White
C: Scott West, Nathan Buckley, Brett Kirk
HF: Tim Watson, Jonathan Brown, Paul Williams
F: Jeff Farmer, Saverio Rocca, Brad Ottens
R: Justin Madden, Simon Black, Gary Hocking
Int: Robert Dipierdomenico, Cameron Ling, Alan Didak, John Anthony

Hoggy31:

B: David Wirrpanda, Steven Silvagni, Nigel Smart
HB: Nicky Winmar, Paul Roos, Aussie Jones
C: Brent Harvey, Adam Goodes, Jason Akermanis
HF: Brad Johnson, Matthew Richardson, Ben Allan
F: Stewart Loewe, Barry Hall, Michael O'Loughlin
R: Paul Salmon, Lenny Hayes, Jimy Bartel
Int: Darren Bewick, Adam Simpson, Nathan Bock, Adriam McAdam

 

[Johnners]

Someone should finish of Matteh's team imo.

 

[cameeel]

cameeel:

B: Gavin Wanganeen, Danny Frawley, Marcus Ashcroft
HB: Michael Long, Glen Jakovich, Byron Pickett
C: Nick Dal Santo, Anthony Koutoufides, Doug Hawkins
HF: Joel Corey, Roger Merritt, David Schwarz
F: Steve Johnson, Jason Dunstall, Lance Franklin
R: Corey McKernan, Peter Bell, Nathan Burke
Int: Leon Davis, Paul Haselby, Allan Jakovich, Liam Jurrah

Corrected to Danny Frawley, though give James Frawley a few more years and he may not be a bad addition to the side

 

[dontcloseyoureyes]

Not enough Demons in your side IMO.

 

[Johnners]

Corrected to Danny Frawley, though give James Frawley a few more years and he may not be a bad addition to the side

Haha woops, fixed.

 

[Matt79]

Do we want to break it down a bit and talk about who's team we each think has the best backline, midfield team and forward set up?

Agree with Zac, this thread has been great. For a few weeks there, it was the only thing I was bothering looking at on CW.

 

[Matt79]

My team aside, I reckon Jack and Zac's teams have the best midfields, although obviously they're all pretty good with at least a couple of stand out players in each team.

Reckon Williams, Harvey, Judd, Liberatore, Kelly, Millane just shade Jarmen, Roo, Platten, Matera, Goodwin, Power.

 

[Johnners]

By all means. Think Saggers has the midfield battle sewn up though. Judd, Harvey, Williams, Kelly and Libba, sheesh.

Someone (with more knowledge than yours truly ) should still finish Matteh's team

 

[Matt79]

Reckon my team would match him in that regard. Buckley, Black, Hocking, West, Watson, Kirk, Ling, Dipper, McLeod, Paul Williams and even Didak in bursts can all cycle through there.

 

[Hoggy31]

Other players on my short-list:

Peter Riccardi
Brett Allison
Mark Bickley
Martin Pike
Jude Bolton
Darren Jolly
Jason Ball
Daniel Chick
Barry Stoneham
Tony Free
Paul Broderick

Shocked Shaun Burgoyne wasn't taken, gun. Scott Cummings had a few good years too.

My team is the best in all honesty, would take all. Btw Claps, Matthew not Mark (crab) at CHF.

 

[Johnners]

Heh shocking error. Will fix