Burgey
Request Your Custom Title Now!
I think the nature of the sport dictates that must be the case. You play 7 opponents on your way to a Grand Slam title. In that regard it's different to say, golf, where the entire 130 odd field is playing against each other.I don't see it that way.
Nadal went out in the fourth round, but Federer still had to fight his way to the title. A Grand Slam title is a Grand Slam title regardless of whether you beat Robin Soderling or Rafael Nadal.
The next time Federer and Nadal meet in a Grand Slam final, they'll be a question mark over Federer regardless of surface, but for now he took his opportunity.
When Becker won his 1st Wimbledon, his opponent in the final, Kevin Curran, took out both Lendl and McEnroe. Historically speaking, it doesn't detract from his effort in winning the tourney. Same with one of Agassi's US Opens where Sampras, Rafter et al were rissoled early.