Prince EWS
Global Moderator
Equally though, five bowlers is essentially useless is the fifth guy you picked adds nothing that the others don't - as he just ends up bowling overs that better bowlers could be bowling.4 batsman scored 100s and England manged to decalre before using their bowlers. Compunded by the fact that Monty took 6 wickets and England bowled a Lara-less Windies out for 437.
Batting's not the problem Perm.
And I think you must realise that the selectors aren't selecting a "hindsight first test" team - they're selecting a team totally removed from the first test. You won't have all your batsmen score hundreds every time, nor will you have your best bowler toddle off injured. In fact, both are exceedingly rare. Playing 5 batsmen with an out-of-form #7 batting #6 would be suicidal IMO. They'll probably do it anyway though, knowing the selectors.