Tahsin said:
South Africa -:
Hashim Amla
Abraham de Villiers
Dale Steyn
Andrew Puttick
Imraan Khan
Thandi Tshabalala
Con de Lange
Pierre Joubert
Thami Tsolekile
Jon Kent
Just commenting on the Natal boyz, 'cos I'm a Dolphin all the way...
I'm a huge Amla fan, and I think he's got what it takes in the long run, but his technique's being exposed pretty badly. He's only got one full first class season behind him, and he's 20, so there's still time. I'm not sure whether they should persist with him in the test side, but then again the 1st class game has basically been on pause for the last couple months anyway. Needs some work on the fundamentals, but the class is there, everyone's seen it for years, even before his 1st class debut he was highly regarded.
Imraan Khan, hmm, if his spin was progressing then maybe, but he's almost given it up in favour of his batting. Which doesn't mean to say he won't make it, he's shown some class with the club in hand. He did look a good prospect with the ball a season or 2 back, I hope they work on his bowling, Natal need all the bowling they can get.
Jon Kent, had some stellar times a few years back and really looked classy in the U19 World Cup he played in, but his performances since haven't really been good enough to think about including him.
On Thami, he's a good enough keeper, probably better than AB in terms of potential, but as a batsman he just does not come anywhere close to being in the vicinity of cutting it. Maybe if our top order was smashing attacks to all corners we could think about carrying a specialist keeper, but certainly not now, when we're struggling to find a balanced lineup.
He seems to have fallen off the earth this season, but I think there's potential in Monde Zondeki and Mfuneko Ngam, despite his brittle bone structure is battling his way back to something resembling form.