South Africa team selection

[Stefan9]

Its nice to see our batting lineups depth has atleast improved.

 

[Northerner]

Squad has been announced for Sri Lanka. Muthusamy leapfrogging Piedt now. There will be rain around Durban next week so not sure how Kingsmead will play. Temba also fit so we are probably going to see:
1. de Zorzi
2. Markram
3. Stubbs
4. Temba
5. Bedingham
6. Verreynne
7. Mulder
8. Jansen
9. Coetzee
10. Maharaj
11. Rabada

I suppose if there is spin around we go for Muthusamy instead of Coetzee.

 

[Northerner]

A little bit puzzled why Dane Paterson is in the squad, he is a steady bowler but almost 36 years old, time to move on to the next generation,

 

[Marius]

Not a terrible squad v SL but I don't know why Paterson is there, and Harmer must count himself unlucky.

Who could have been chosen ahead of Paterson though? Swanepoel or Pretorius?

 

[Northerner]

Not a terrible squad v SL but I don't know why Paterson is there, and Harmer must count himself unlucky.

Who could have been chosen ahead of Paterson though? Swanepoel or Pretorius?

Yes Pretorius and possibly Sipamla, it has to bee make or break time in tests for Aiden too, so much talent but too many low scores.

 

[Dendarii]

Do the test matches overlap with domestic first-class matches? Paterson's really only there as an emergency backup, so maybe there's an argument for it being better for other fringe bowlers to be getting game time rather than carrying drinks as they can be brought into the team at short notice if necessary. I'm not convinced that's a good enough argument to keep him around though.

 

[Dendarii]

Not a terrible squad v SL but I don't know why Paterson is there, and Harmer must count himself unlucky.

We've come to the conclusion that CSA's policy appears to be that players need to be playing for a domestic team in order to be eligible for selection. If that is the case and they've made it clear to the players then Harmer has effectively retired from international cricket unless he decides to play for a South African team again. If they haven't made it clear then that's a major blunder on their part.

 

[Stefan9]

Not a terrible squad v SL but I don't know why Paterson is there, and Harmer must count himself unlucky.

Who could have been chosen ahead of Paterson though? Swanepoel or Pretorius?

Harmer isn't eligible as he hasn't played SA domestic cricket for 2 seasons. Can't be unlucky if you don't make yourself eligible for selection.

 

[Stefan9]

A little bit puzzled why Dane Paterson is in the squad, he is a steady bowler but almost 36 years old, time to move on to the next generation,

He is a Shukri guy. Do remember he values character very high.

 

[Stefan9]

Do the test matches overlap with domestic first-class matches? Paterson's really only there as an emergency backup, so maybe there's an argument for it being better for other fringe bowlers to be getting game time rather than carrying drinks as they can be brought into the team at short notice if necessary. I'm not convinced that's a good enough argument to keep him around though.

There is a round from 28th November that overlaps with the first test. Only western province vs knights overlaps with the second test.

 

[Kenneth Viljoen]

I would have made it 17 , would have added Hermann , Baartman and Subrayen to the squad

 

[Kenneth Viljoen]

Squad has been announced for Sri Lanka. Muthusamy leapfrogging Piedt now. There will be rain around Durban next week so not sure how Kingsmead will play. Temba also fit so we are probably going to see:
1. de Zorzi
2. Markram
3. Stubbs
4. Temba
5. Bedingham
6. Verreynne
7. Mulder
8. Jansen
9. Coetzee
10. Maharaj
11. Rabada

I suppose if there is spin around we go for Muthusamy instead of Coetzee.

Mulder Jansen Coetzee Rabada is one hell of a pace attack

 

[StephenZA]

Mulder Jansen Coetzee Rabada is one hell of a pace attack

Creates a decent long batting line up as well.

 

[Dendarii]

I would have made it 17 , would have added Hermann , Baartman and Subrayen to the squad

They tend to have smaller squads when playing at home. There's no real need to have too many extra players as it's not that difficult to bring someone into the squad in the event of injury and it means that those players unlikely to start are free to play for their domestic teams, which is a more productive use of their time.

 

[WpGuy]

Squad has been announced for Sri Lanka. Muthusamy leapfrogging Piedt now. There will be rain around Durban next week so not sure how Kingsmead will play. Temba also fit so we are probably going to see:
1. de Zorzi
2. Markram
3. Stubbs
4. Temba
5. Bedingham
6. Verreynne
7. Mulder
8. Jansen
9. Coetzee
10. Maharaj
11. Rabada

I suppose if there is spin around we go for Muthusamy instead of Coetzee.

Maybe instead of Mulder even than ?

 

[WpGuy]

A little bit puzzled why Dane Paterson is in the squad, he is a steady bowler but almost 36 years old, time to move on to the next generation,

Maybe they see him as a vern philander holding bowler for now and after test championship he goes out ?

 

[WpGuy]

He is a Shukri guy. Do remember he values character very high.

Most coaches do have their favs and shukri was at cobras.

 

[Bahseph]

Maybe instead of Mulder even than ?

Don't think so. I think Mulder is going to be a fixture moving forward. Shukri is a huge fan.

 

[Marius]

Squad has been announced for Sri Lanka. Muthusamy leapfrogging Piedt now. There will be rain around Durban next week so not sure how Kingsmead will play. Temba also fit so we are probably going to see:
1. de Zorzi
2. Markram
3. Stubbs
4. Temba
5. Bedingham
6. Verreynne
7. Mulder
8. Jansen
9. Coetzee
10. Maharaj
11. Rabada

I suppose if there is spin around we go for Muthusamy instead of Coetzee.

That's not a bad side actually, I can live with that.

 

[WpGuy]

That's not a bad side actually, I can live with that.

Rabada not the worst number 11 and 3 extremely fast different bowlers with mulder to swing it and maharaj if needed to stop gap and than take wickets once it turns.