shiv vs lara vs ponting vs sachin ?

[Matt79]

1. Bat

LOL.

Feel vindicated in my initial scornful response. Not much more annoying than loaded poll questions designed to boost the originaters favourite players, esp. When they then get shirty that no one agrees.

Shiv, as a batsman, isn't in Ponting, let alone Lara or Sachin's class. If you want to compare one guys peak against other players whole careers, then good luck to you.

 

[Johnners]

1. Bat

2. Field (In Ponting and Sachin's case at least)

 

[biased indian]

went for sachin in both case .....

shiv in ODI WTF

 

[Eclipse]

I dare you to list what those players can do better than chanderpaul

Bat better.

In just about every single way.

 

[wfdu_ben91]

He is above them - chanderpaul is superior to lara, ponting and sachin.

He has developped into a remarkable player - all the other three has flaws, chanderpaul has none.

Where is the names of the other 10 batsman from the modern era that are better then Chanderpaul but yet aren't as good as Tendulkar, Ponting & Lara?

 

[Athlai]

Hayden>Ponting>Langer>Hussey>Tendular/Lara>Chanderpaul clearly

 

[Evermind]

Trollish thread. Shiv nowhere near the quality of the other 3.

Sachin in ODIs, Ponting in tests.