Shaun Pollock, Chaminda Vaas , Mkhaya Ntini , Bond ,Shaun Tait, Brett Lee & Asif ?

[FRAZ]

Shaun Pollock, Chaminda Vaas , Mkhaya Ntini , Bond ,Shaun Tait, Brett Lee & Asif ?

I guess it is the modern times version of 'Mcgrath vs Wasim vs Waqar vs Walsh' discussion . Who would you like to bowl for your team ,given there are following types of pitches and conditions available i.e.
1. Grassy (under clouds and slight wind)
2. Indian pitch with a package of 300+ per day runs in a test
3. Typical South African Durban Pitch
4. ODI on NZ pitches
5. ODI in kolkatta
Offcourse different bowlers can be chosen for the above conditions but overall who would you prefer ?

 

[silentstriker]

1. Asif
2. Asif
3. Asif
4. Don't care
5. Don't care

 

[FRAZ]

Shaun Pollock is my pick tbh !

 

[Beleg]

1. Pollock
2. Bond
3. Ntini
4. Bond
5. Bond

Shane Bond or Shaun Pollock.

 

[Jono]

Following massive stereotypes:

1. Grassy (under clouds and slight wind) - Pollock
2. Indian pitch with a package of 300+ per day runs in a test - I'm guessing this means its a flat deck, well on a flat deck I'd rather Mohammad Asif
3. Typical South African Durban Pitch - Makhaya Ntini
4. ODI on NZ pitches - Shane Bond
5. ODI in kolkatta - Shaun Pollock
Offcourse different bowlers can be chosen for the above conditions but overall who would you prefer? - Makhaya Ntini

 

[FRAZ]

Following massive stereotypes:

1. Grassy (under clouds and slight wind) - Pollock
2. Indian pitch with a package of 300+ per day runs in a test - I'm guessing this means its a flat deck, well on a flat deck I'd rather Mohammad Asif
3. Typical South African Durban Pitch - Makhaya Ntini
4. ODI on NZ pitches - Shane Bond
5. ODI in kolkatta - Shaun Pollock
Offcourse different bowlers can be chosen for the above conditions but overall who would you prefer? - Makhaya Ntini

Jono ! nice & cute glasses.

 

[PhoenixFire]

1. Asif
2. Asif
3. Ntini
4. Pollock
5. Asif

 

[Jono]

Jono ! nice & cute glasses.

Yeah they look good on me. I can also teleport through time, and speak Japanese.

 

[adharcric]

1) Asif
2) Asif
3) Ntini
4) Pollock
5) Pollock

Overall: Asif

 

[silentstriker]

Yeah they look good on me. I can also teleport through time, and speak Japanese.

And have a multi millionaire for a father (who was the captain of a starship previously).

 

[rodzilla1010]

I think you missed out on Akhtar ..when fit he is by faaar the best in the world...conditions dont matter to him....Look he only bowled 12 overs and swung the series in Pak's direction against the SAffers.

 

[silentstriker]

I think you missed out on Akhtar ..when fit he is by faaar the best in the world...conditions dont matter to him....Look he only bowled 12 overs and swung the series in Pak's direction against the SAffers.

The problem is that he only bowls 12 overs.... Bond shouldn't be here for the same reason.

 

[PhoenixFire]

Why no more votes for Ntini?

 

[silentstriker]

Why no more votes for Ntini?

Well under condition #2, he doesn't have a great record. And because I am biased towards Asif.

 

[Tom Halsey]

The problem is that he only bowls 12 overs.... Bond shouldn't be here for the same reason.

Haven't been paying too much attention to Bond since his return from the long lay-off, but he didn't impress me in the recent Commonwealth series really, seemed to profit ecessively from death wickets to me.

 

[Pup Clarke]

1)Pollock
2)Asif
3)Ntini
4)Bond
5)Asif

 

[Armadillo]

Pollock
Pollock
Pollock
Pollock
aaaaaand...Pollock

 

[Richard]

I guess it is the modern times version of 'Mcgrath vs Wasim vs Waqar vs Walsh' discussion . Who would you like to bowl for your team ,given there are following types of pitches and conditions available i.e.
1. Grassy (under clouds and slight wind)
2. Indian pitch with a package of 300+ per day runs in a test
3. Typical South African Durban Pitch
4. ODI on NZ pitches
5. ODI in kolkatta
Offcourse different bowlers can be chosen for the above conditions but overall who would you prefer ?

1, Asif
2, Asif
3, Asif
4, Pollock
5, Pollock

 

[oz_fan]

1. Pollock
2. Pollock
3. Ntini
4. Bond
5. Pollock

 

[shortpitched713]

I'm assuming you're talking more about ODIs, in which case its Pollock by miles.