• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official*** West Indies in New Zealand

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
Yep. That last over showed us why Marshall for Taylor at ODI level is a straight swap.

Edwards - legend

Marshall - have a kit kat
 

Mr Mxyzptlk

Request Your Custom Title Now!
sirjeremy11 said:
No doubting the guys talent, but he has been a bit Brett Lee-ish in his economy rate.
For the type of bowler that he is you don't expect economy though. Or you shouldn't at least. He's a charge in and deliver type of bowler with a slingy action. Brett Lee has a more orthodox action, and therefore you'd expect to bowl with control more often than Edwards.
 

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
Mr Mxyzptlk said:
For the type of bowler that he is you don't expect economy though. Or you shouldn't at least. He's a charge in and deliver type of bowler with a slingy action. Brett Lee has a more orthodox action, and therefore you'd expect to bowl with control more often than Edwards.
Don't know, that last over was fairly well directed and controlled. I'm telling you, he looked very good today. Very accurate.
 

James

Cricket Web Owner
and what about the WIndies fielding guys, can it get much worse! New Zealand must have got an extra 20-30 runs in mid-fields and general rubbish fielding. On the positive, at least they can catch!
 

Mr Mxyzptlk

Request Your Custom Title Now!
sirjeremy11 said:
Don't know, that last over was fairly well directed and controlled. I'm telling you, he looked very good today. Very accurate.
He must've been, because the New Zealand batsmen didn't appear to be in a charitable mood. That's why I'm so surprised and suddenly very excited for the Test matches. Accuracy is the thing that has hindered Edwards in Tests and he's been bowling well (bar his last over in the 3rd match) ever since that final spell in the first match.
 

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
I too am looking forward to the test matches. Mainly to see Lara, and who we pick! I am also keen to see Lara vs Bond and Vettori. Could be a good battle...
 

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
James said:
and what about the WIndies fielding guys, can it get much worse! New Zealand must have got an extra 20-30 runs in mid-fields and general rubbish fielding. On the positive, at least they can catch!
It can get worse. I try to imagine what they would have been like had we collared Edwards today as well. They would have had nothing to cheer about.
 

Mr Mxyzptlk

Request Your Custom Title Now!
sirjeremy11 said:
It can get worse. I try to imagine what they would have been like had we collared Edwards today as well. They would have had nothing to cheer about.
*cough* Gayle *cough*
 

James

Cricket Web Owner
I don't see how the WIndies are going to take 20 wickets against us in the tests to be perfectly honest. The only bowler who's impressed me in this tour has been Edwards, while the other seamers have been woeful, and with Bravo carrying an injury, he's unlikely to be at his best.

The only way the WIndies are going to beat us IMO is to bat first and score 600+ on the back of a Lara double ton and then rely on some silly shots from the Kiwi batsmen.

2-0 is my pick.
 

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
Mr Mxyzptlk said:
*cough* Gayle *cough*
Yeah... maybe. Still went for 5's... got three wickets in the rest of the torment though.

They really need someone to back these two up. Surprised at the way they got to Butler and Bradshaw.
 

Mr Mxyzptlk

Request Your Custom Title Now!
sirjeremy11 said:
Yeah... maybe. Still went for 5's... got three wickets in the rest of the torment though.

They really need someone to back these two up. Surprised at the way they got to Butler and Bradshaw.
He was under 4.5 for a large part though (I think).

Butler and Bradshaw have built career on being economical, so it was rather shocking. It's bound to happen occasionally though. Just a pity it happened for both on the same day.
 

Mr Mxyzptlk

Request Your Custom Title Now!
James said:
I don't see how the WIndies are going to take 20 wickets against us in the tests to be perfectly honest. The only bowler who's impressed me in this tour has been Edwards, while the other seamers have been woeful, and with Bravo carrying an injury, he's unlikely to be at his best.

The only way the WIndies are going to beat us IMO is to bat first and score 600+ on the back of a Lara double ton and then rely on some silly shots from the Kiwi batsmen.

2-0 is my pick.
Given the chance to attack and rip a few, I can see Lewis taking a wicket or two.

If the ball swings early on, Bradshaw can be a handful, though not quite in the Pedro Collins mold. Daren Powell tends to start tours well and then fall away as his fitness is tested, so I think he could have an early impact before he fades.

Wavell Hinds may be sorely missed in the Tests as far as batting is concerned.
 

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
Mr Mxyzptlk said:
He was under 4.5 for a large part though (I think).

Butler and Bradshaw have built career on being economical, so it was rather shocking. It's bound to happen occasionally though. Just a pity it happened for both on the same day.
Got to say, just when I saw the end of the game the other night, and the Windies were shaking hands with NZ as they came off the field, I felt sorta sorry for them. That was the first time I had such a feeling when watching us beat someone.
 
Last edited:

sirjeremy11

State Vice-Captain
Mr Mxyzptlk said:
Given the chance to attack and rip a few, I can see Lewis taking a wicket or two.
In the whole series? :dry:

Mr Mxyzptlk said:
Wavell Hinds may be sorely missed in the Tests as far as batting is concerned.
Agreed. They could use him. Still have a good line up though with Lara, Gayle, Chanderpaul, Sarwan, Bravo, Ramdin, Ganga. Maybe could have swapped him for Morton.
 

roseboy64

Cricket Web Content Updater
sirjeremy11 said:
In the whole series? :dry:



Agreed. They could use him. Still have a good line up though with Lara, Gayle, Chanderpaul, Sarwan, Bravo, Ramdin, Ganga. Maybe could have swapped him for Morton.
Morton looks more like a Test batsman than OD.
 

Top