• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

*Official* Third Test at the WACA

hendrix

Hall of Fame Member
Me neither, only two Aussie spinners have ever impressed me, Warne and McGill, the rest have either been simply average bowlers or total garbage, Mallett was pretty good so was Yardley but you never expected big things from them.
To be honest, Lyon has taken some huge wickets this series.

If Harris, Siddle, Johnson and Watson isn't enough of a pace battery to take 20 wickets then I'm not sure what another seamer instead of Lyon would do.

But they clearly are enough to take 20 wickets as evidenced by these past 3 tests so it's really a non issue.
 

SpofforthLohman

U19 12th Man
Come on England, pull off a miracle! Keep the series alive.

Stokes and Bresnan are capable of a big partnership, imo.
If they pull off a miracle I doubt any Australian would watch the rest of the series, I sure wouldn't. I stopped watching the last ashes series half way through from disgust. Surely no team could ever choke that badly.
 

flibbertyjibber

Request Your Custom Title Now!
What is it with New Zealand and allrounders? Along with South Africa they must've produced most of the decent ones for the last 20 years. Shame the Christhchurch ginga is playing for the Poms though
At least having this lad isn't a case of pinching him as he moved to England aged 12 so the main development was done in our system rather than yours. He has surprised me on tour so far, looks to have a good head for the game.
 

SpofforthLohman

U19 12th Man
To be honest, Lyon has taken some huge wickets this series.

If Harris, Siddle, Johnson and Watson isn't enough of a pace battery to take 20 wickets then I'm not sure what another seamer instead of Lyon would do.

But they clearly are enough to take 20 wickets as evidenced by these past 3 tests so it's really a non issue.
I hold out some hope for Lyon, don't get me wrong but great Australian spinners have been very rare ever since O'Reilly and Grimmett, A great spinner is a bowler who destroys batting line ups on some sort of regular basis. You are right, no point in having five seamers.
 

hendrix

Hall of Fame Member
At least having this lad isn't a case of pinching him as he moved to England aged 12 so the main development was done in our system rather than yours. He has surprised me on tour so far, looks to have a good head for the game.
He's absolutely, unequivacally a product of the English cricket system so I have no problem with him playing for England.

I hold out some hope for Lyon, don't get me wrong but great Australian spinners have been very rare ever since O'Reilly and Grimmett, A great spinner is a bowler who destroys batting line ups on some sort of regular basis. You are right, no point in having five seamers.
The reason great spinners are great is because they're rare. Australia is not going to consistently produce spinners of the same calibre as the SC teams. I don't mind a bit of settling, to be honest.
 

wiff

First Class Debutant
Australian bowlers are getting long in the face. I can see this match going down to the wire. Waiting on some unpredictable fielding or bowling from Smith to turn things. Well played Stokes, first test he's played at the Wacca.
 

Top