• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

***Official*** Sri Lanka in South Africa 2016/2017

91Jmay

International Coach
Reckon they know Morris is a good T20 player so will be back for the important tournaments. Worth looking at a few other players.
 

Dendarii

International Debutant
Just odd a fringe ODI player like Dwaine Pretorius isn't there.
I would say that his exclusion is the most puzzling one, especially since he played in the against Australia when they were here and then went over there after Steyn got injured, so he clearly has recently been in the selectors' minds. If the T20 squad was just made up of players unlikely to feature in the ODIs then him not being there might make more sense, but you would have thought that Behardien, Tahir, Miller, Parnell, Phangiso, and Phehlukwayo would also make the ODI squad, so it doesn't look like an either/or selection.
 

TT Boy

Hall of Fame Member
Kuhn and JJ Smuts have been around the traps so I don't think they will represent another country but I see what you trying to say.

In that squad I wouldn't say there is the next QdK or Rabada besides maybe de Bruyn/Ngidi. Obviously Phehluwkayo also has a bit about him too.

Just odd a fringe ODI player like Dwaine Pretorius isn't there. Chris Morris needs to get overs under his belt as well.

But percentages definitely looks like the plan while they testing where some players are quite clearly.
Looks like the squad was selected on the basis of rewarding the guys who did well in this seasons domestic 20/20, and guys who may have a future in other formats. That’s presumably why Hendricks and Paterson were selected as they didn’t have a great domestic 20/20 and if you are selecting on the basis of form, Kruger should have got the nod over Hendricks and there were a number of bowlers who performed better than Paterson as well. Surprised Shamsi wasn’t selected. Tahir is the number 1 bowler in international 20/20s but Shamsi is the future and is made for 20/20. Keep Tahir for the ODIs / Champions Trophy. Would have gone with Klaasen over Kuhn as well but Kuhn could still have a test career, and may tour to New Zealand as backup to de Kock.
 

TT Boy

Hall of Fame Member
I would say that his exclusion is the most puzzling one, especially since he played in the against Australia when they were here and then went over there after Steyn got injured, so he clearly has recently been in the selectors' minds. If the T20 squad was just made up of players unlikely to feature in the ODIs then him not being there might make more sense, but you would have thought that Behardien, Tahir, Miller, Parnell, Phangiso, and Phehlukwayo would also make the ODI squad, so it doesn't look like an either/or selection.
Bit like David Wiese before he debuted, statistically phenomenal but didn't look too hot with bat or ball. Could have a test career but I wouldn't back him to get through 10 overs in many ODIs, or be a banker for 4 overs in 20/20.
 

TT Boy

Hall of Fame Member
He does deserve it. Just suits limited overs cricket with his all-round ability. Those slow left-armers of his have been tough to get away for years.
Think it’s the bowling which helped get him selected. Batting he is more Richard Levi lite but both he and Ackermann were great with the ball for the Warriors. Interested to see if what he bowls (flat darts) will work on the international stage.
 

StephenZA

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend

SeamUp

International Coach
Looks like the squad was selected on the basis of rewarding the guys who did well in this seasons domestic 20/20, and guys who may have a future in other formats. That’s presumably why Hendricks and Paterson were selected as they didn’t have a great domestic 20/20 and if you are selecting on the basis of form, Kruger should have got the nod over Hendricks and there were a number of bowlers who performed better than Paterson as well. Surprised Shamsi wasn’t selected. Tahir is the number 1 bowler in international 20/20s but Shamsi is the future and is made for 20/20. Keep Tahir for the ODIs / Champions Trophy. Would have gone with Klaasen over Kuhn as well but Kuhn could still have a test career, and may tour to New Zealand as backup to de Kock.
It is a bit of a mixture. Rewarding T20 form, percentages, looking how players deal with international environment.

I think Reeza Hendricks is a good player but he hasn't scored runs for 2 years now so I still think it is an odd decision.

Also with Pretorius - he probably needs more international exposure. He doesn't look special but at least he hits good areas and hits the seam unlike Wiese. Wiese would run and bowl 5 cutters and get hit for 6 and then his fifth seam-up ball would still get hit for 6. I am not a massive Pretorius fan but he should have been in the squad but he probably is in ODI squad. I would probably agree about Shamsi as well. He should be playing this format.

Rewarding some form - I suppose Van der Dussen (Levi like hits to the leg), Kruger and definitely Jonker must have come close. Birch and Siboto too.
 

SeamUp

International Coach
I would say that his exclusion is the most puzzling one, especially since he played in the against Australia when they were here and then went over there after Steyn got injured, so he clearly has recently been in the selectors' minds. If the T20 squad was just made up of players unlikely to feature in the ODIs then him not being there might make more sense, but you would have thought that Behardien, Tahir, Miller, Parnell, Phangiso, and Phehlukwayo would also make the ODI squad, so it doesn't look like an either/or selection.
ODI squad ?

Amla
De Kock
Faf
AB
JP
Miller
Behardien

Pretorius
Phehlukwayo

Tahir
Phangiso/Shamsi

Rabada
Morkel
Parnell


* Morris probably play 4-day crkcet for Titans to prove fitness.
 

SeamUp

International Coach
Theunis De Bruyn and Duanne Olivier confirmed in the Knights squad.

Parnell and Maharaj playing.
 

Marius

International Debutant
Was surprised for a moment that Moonda came up with something that funny. Happy to know she didn't.
Yeah, I had the same thought when I was readingit, Fernando is about ten thousand times better than Moonda, glad he wrote the preview.
 

vcs

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Fernando is really funny.

Moonda's magnum opus was the one with all those forced metaphors about fairy tales. God that was painful.
 

OverratedSanity

Request Your Custom Title Now!
Fernando has always been pretty awesome. His end of day reports are always entertaining when he tears into SL.

eg:

Sri Lanka is three-and-a-half hours ahead of Cape Town. Perhaps you watched the morning session, left for dinner, played a sport, spent time with family, read a book, watched a movie, and thought to check back with the cricket, to cap off the day.South Africa were batting when you had last watched. Now, already, they are batting again.

This is not the highlights they are playing. It is not a rain break. This is just what it's like to watch Sri Lanka overseas.
 

vcs

Request Your Custom Title Now!
He secretly loves the doom and gloom. He'd be lost if SL suddenly became awesome and started winning overseas.
 

Marius

International Debutant
Fernando is really funny.

Moonda's magnum opus was the one with all those forced metaphors about fairy tales. God that was painful.
That was the vodka and coathangers of cricket journalism. It was staggeringly awful.
 

SeamUp

International Coach
Think it’s the bowling which helped get him selected. Batting he is more Richard Levi lite but both he and Ackermann were great with the ball for the Warriors. Interested to see if what he bowls (flat darts) will work on the international stage.
I will never forget when Brett Lee was bowling him out-swingers and he couldn't lay bat-on-ball. Sure he was young then but it was about that strong right-hand technique and strength on leg-side. Taking nothing away from him though. This is his format and he can score runs and like you say, lets see how his dartish bowling goes.

It's amazing how the careers have gone with that u19 batch. Who has actually lived up to their potential ?

Pieter Malan
Jon-Jon Smuts
Reeza Hendricks
Rilee Rossouw
Jonathan Vandiar
Yaseen Vallie
Obus Pienaar
Wayne Parnell
 
Last edited:

Top