• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** Pakistan v New Zealand in the UAE 2014

ohnoitsyou

International Regular
Southee would swing the ball more than Rahat in New Zealand conditions. Its one of the beautiful things about swing bowling, how comfortable you feel in the conditions effects your ability to swing the ball. I expect both the quicks to find more movement in the next match.
 

Hurricane

Hall of Fame Member
Yeah, though Hadlee was probably naturally quicker than Southee - capable of bowling in that 137-142 zone with less effort. But then, didn't even Hadlee struggle pretty badly on his one trip to Pakistan?
We will never know. There is the speed gun test on youtube but it only had Thomson at 146 iirc and he would have been 155kms in the test so I think it was a slow gun. Hadlee was 129 on the test but tellingly he finished 2nd to last out of ten people in the contest. That tells me that he would have been 135 tops by mid career. Though obviously when he had his 22 step run up he would have been 140-145
 

ohnoitsyou

International Regular
They have Waqar Younis as their coach. And no doubt Akram gets involved. I am not surprised they reversed it more than us. From reading about Pakastani cricket you have to learn how to be a master of reverse on their pitches.

as for the new ball swing - sometimes it goes for us and sometimes it doesn't - this will offend my fellow kiwi posters - but usually we cheat or push the rules to their limits - by having a whinge about the slightest imperfection in the ball until we get one that does move. Sometimes we can't find a reason to complain though. That may sound ridiculous but that is how we operate.
Bottle caps certainty help too
 

Hurricane

Hall of Fame Member
Seriously. Are you really trying to say a county should want to take Sodhi on? This is the type of brainlessness which perpetuates me thinking you actually rate the guy and think he's going to be a good bowler.
You hit the nail on the head earlier when you said that some of us go back on this message board and that we all have each others backs. If you want to reach that status one day where we have your back then you need to leave out the passionate punctuating comments like I have highlighted. Play nice.
 

Blocky

Banned
You hit the nail on the head earlier when you said that some of us go back on this message board and that we all have each others backs. If you want to reach that status one day where we have your back then you need to leave out the passionate punctuating comments like I have highlighted. Play nice.
Stop being so sensitive, stop feeling like if I insult a point you make about a player that it's a personal insult and stop getting yourself into a situation where you feel personally attached to players or points you make about players.

In my view, it's the absolute pinnacle of brainlessness to suggest that a player who can't average less than 50 with the ball in NZ domestic cricket where most batsmen cannot face spin for the life of them would be considered in the English county scene. I really don't want you to have my back, because unlike you, I'm here to discuss and debate cricket, not be politically correct or be in a situation where I feel I can't call someone out for making a stupid post.

If I had half the style of sensitive reaction you guys have towards things said in my direction, I'd dare say I'd probably have slit my wrists by now.

ps - we're all happily discussing cricket, that post is what, two hours old? We've moved on to other subjects and you bring it back up with some personal commentary, no doubt you'll then claim I started the whole **** fight that is no doubt about to ensue because I've called you out on feeling like someone has been personally attacked when their opinion was the thing being attacked - with various points of view made as a counter point to why their opinion was brainless.
 
Last edited:

Hurricane

Hall of Fame Member
Stop being so sensitive, stop feeling like if I insult a point you make about a player that it's a personal insult and stop getting yourself into a situation where you feel personally attached to players or points you make about players.

In my view, it's the absolute pinnacle of brainlessness to suggest that a player who can't average less than 50 with the ball in NZ domestic cricket where most batsmen cannot face spin for the life of them would be considered in the English county scene. I really don't want you to have my back, because unlike you, I'm here to discuss and debate cricket, not be politically correct or be in a situation where I feel I can't call someone out for making a stupid post.

If I had half the style of sensitive reaction you guys have towards things said in my direction, I'd dare say I'd probably have slit my wrists by now.
WE WILL SEND YOU TO COVENTRY SOON UNLESS YOU CHANGE. Is that clear enough. Was that passive aggressive.
 

Blocky

Banned
Look, the point is leg spinners do not improve without overs under their belts in match situations. Sodhi shouldn't be doing it in international cricket, but he isn't getting it in the NZ first class scene. County cricket isn't ideal either to be perfectly honest, but the alternative isn't giving up on Sodhi as an international player, it's giving up on him entirely in all likelihood. A one off tour match or limited short tours kinda supports the point I was making and a series of one day games is an irrelevance. Even if he can't get a county deal, plenty of Kiwis before him have played in the top English club leagues and have been the better for the experience.
Heres a tip - if Sodhi was actually taking wickets or being threatening, he'd get more overs. When are you going to stop pointing the finger at "Sodhi doesn't get enough overs" into "Sodhi isn't good enough to get the overs"
 

Daemon

Request Your Custom Title Now!
It really should be no surprise that tons of domestic Pakistani and Indian bowlers (albeit to a lesser extent) exploit reverse better than most. It's absolutely vital to be able to do it on some of the pitches they play on. That coupled with the experience Pakistan's coaches have means I'd back every quick who makes it to Test level to be able to extract some reverse to a reasonable degree. I don't think Irfan gets any which is probably a product of him having less coaching, which kinda reinforces my point.

While being **** in general in all other departments I do think a lot of Indian domestic bowlers from certain states are really talented at swinging the ball around as well, because of the random greentops we see in the Ranji.

It's not Southee's fault he couldn't get it going as much (I think, didn't watch him much) because he, along with the team have got very little experience trying to get a ball ready for reverse even compared to a newcomer like Rahat. He'd do well to learn though obviously.

It's either that or bottletops, I'm just choosing to believe it's a skill developed out of necessity and honed over the years.
 
Last edited:

Blocky

Banned
It's either that or bottletops, I'm just choosing to believe it's a skill developed out of necessity and honed over the years.
These days with the amount of cameras on the cricket and the fact that most players have a camera on them ready to be cut to should an event occur, I really don't think you can easily tamper with the ball and not be caught on it. It's not like the Chris Pringle days where you might have one or two cameras at the ground - so I'm of the same mindset you are, it's a skill developed out of neccessity and they've gotten amazing at being able to extract it.

You'll also see them use the yorker a lot more than most other nations too.
 

Blocky

Banned
WE WILL SEND YOU TO COVENTRY SOON UNLESS YOU CHANGE. Is that clear enough. Was that passive aggressive.
Actually, considering you first had an issue with my post, only for me to bark back at you about being A: Late to the party, B: Trying to revive an already dead argument and C: Being sensitive, your resulting attempt at a satirical response isn't passive aggressive, it's to the point of a blatant troll, something you were complaing about WW doing.
 

Blocky

Banned
It also helps if your spin bowlers aren't being battered around the park getting the ball out of shape, etcetera... and helps even more if your spin bowlers are consistent in getting the seam position right when they spin the ball - If you look at the seam position of the Pakistani spin bowlers, invariably it's spinning in a nice circular motion. If you look at the NZ'ers, it's generally a bit more scrambled and wonky meaning you're not as likely as Pakistan to be able to select a side to scuff and have the spinners play into that.
 

Blocky

Banned
Can I report Blocky for calling people brainless?
Is this where I report you for taking conversation away from cricket and trying to perpetuate an argument that didn't involve you?

If you're going to report someone, do it, don't squark about it and make it a public spectacle.
 

Hurricane

Hall of Fame Member
Actually, considering you first had an issue with my post, only for me to bark back at you about being A: Late to the party, B: Trying to revive an already dead argument and C: Being sensitive, your resulting attempt at a satirical response isn't passive aggressive, it's to the point of a blatant troll, something you were complaing about WW doing.
I responded 30 minutes after you made the post. That is not late to the party. You made your post at 10:33pm.

I didn't complain about WW.

I don't think there is any giving you any advice Blocky. My first post was worded nicely or as nice as I could possibly make it. My second post was direct as I could possibly make it.

I hope you get a forum atmosphere ban because quite frankly you are not prepared to accept any well intentioned hints from anyone else.
 

Blocky

Banned
By the time Sodhi gets the ball hafeez has already slapped it out of shape.
Boult and Southee combined went for less than 2.5 an over in the first innings, how again was the ball slapped out of shape?

Seriously, review the way in which our spin bowlers (and Lyon previously) spin the ball, very wonky and scrambled in the seam, often the ball is turning over itself rather than turning around the seam meaning we're scuffing both sides whenever we've got a spin bowler in operation. The times we've managed to get reverse swing working generally coinside with when we don't have that many overs bowled by spin.
 

Blocky

Banned
I responded 30 minutes after you made the post. That is not late to the party. You made your post at 10:33pm.

I didn't complain about WW.

I don't think there is any giving you any advice Blocky. My first post was worded nicely or as nice as I could possibly make it. My second post was direct as I could possibly make it.

I hope you get a forum atmosphere ban because quite frankly you are not prepared to accept any well intentioned hints from anyone else.
Where as you perpetuate arguments and then attempt to tell me that you're the bastion of forum behavior and not just a bandwagon poster who decided to jump on an already dead discussion because you took umbrage with me playing the ball... meanwhile your focus is now to play the man.

You do realise the moderators see through that horse **** right? - Last post I bother with in this vain, from now on I'm just going to report any of you who start **** or perpetuate finished **** over nothing more than a misguided belief that you know how to post on forums better than others.
 

ohnoitsyou

International Regular
Boult and Southee combined went for less than 2.5 an over in the first innings, how again was the ball slapped out of shape?

Seriously, review the way in which our spin bowlers (and Lyon previously) spin the ball, very wonky and scrambled in the seam, often the ball is turning over itself rather than turning around the seam meaning we're scuffing both sides whenever we've got a spin bowler in operation. The times we've managed to get reverse swing working generally coinside with when we don't have that many overs bowled by spin.
14 over the first few overs. It slowed down afterwards, but most of the swing was gone by then.
 

cnerd123

likes this
It really should be no surprise that tons of domestic Pakistani and Indian bowlers (albeit to a lesser extent) exploit reverse better than most. It's absolutely vital to be able to do it on some of the pitches they play on. That coupled with the experience Pakistan's coaches have means I'd back every quick who makes it to Test level to be able to extract some reverse to a reasonable degree. I don't think Irfan gets any which is probably a product of him having less coaching, which kinda reinforces my point.

While being **** in general in all other departments I do think a lot of Indian domestic bowlers from certain states are really talented at swinging the ball around as well, because of the random greentops we see in the Ranji.

It's not Southee's fault he couldn't get it going as much (I think, didn't watch him much) because he, along with the team have got very little experience trying to get a ball ready for reverse even compared to a newcomer like Rahat. He'd do well to learn though obviously.

It's either that or bottletops, I'm just choosing to believe it's a skill developed out of necessity and honed over the years.
All valid points - but it's more than just a skill. You need to be able to bowl at a certain speed with a certain type of release from the hand to get the ball to reverse. And that's more natural than taught.

As cricketers progress through club, age-group, and domestic cricket in these countries, the ones who naturally bowl in the right pace range with the right grip and release are noticed and promoted up the ranks, as opposed to those who are just quick and accurate but without the inherent ability to reverse the ball.
 

Blocky

Banned
14 over the first few overs. It slowed down afterwards, but most of the swing was gone by then.
Takes more than two to three boundaries to stop the ball swinging though, I think more so the climate there doesn't have conventional swing for longer than a few overs unless you're getting through the air slightly quicker than other bowlers. Also I feel our bowlers didn't pitch the ball up as much as the Pakistani bowlers which again robs you of the chance of late swing through the air. We were trying to use the pitch and there was really nothing there to use. The Pakistani's bowled better variations, changes of pace, used angles more and pitched it up.
 

Top