nzfan
International Vice-Captain
I have no problem with Edgar, he has done some good things surely.Nzfan will be happy. I think he’s done a great job, restoring the Wellington side to a competitive team.
Pocknall was coach during the Ford Trophy win though, so seems like a good replacement.
Wish Edgar could return as NZ selector!
The good things first:
1. Excellent signings of Hamish Bennett, Logan Van Beek, Jimmy Neesham and Devon Conway.
2. 4 years at the helm, two trophies isn't bad. Also Firebirds are now considered a team that is hard to beat so kudos to him.
3. Got few newbies into the team, the likes of Rachin Ravindra, Troy Johnson, Andrew Fetcher, Lauchie Johns, Alex Ridley. All home grown talent.
The bad things:
1. How did Rachin Ravindra not debut much earlier? Clearly Ravindra was good enough 2 years ago and he's got game 2 years late. Everyone in the NZ Cricket circuit including past players tell you this. How did he not get a t20 game ahead of the likes of Nofal, Woodcock, Johnson etc? That clearly shows he's slowed down the lad. Lads like Nathan Smith, Zac Gibson etc have been in the domestic circuit for over 2 years now. Clearly Ravindra was probably the best player since 2016 U19 World cup. Every tom, dick and harry knew this but for Edgar.
2. Jeetan Patel bowls like 70 overs for 2 wickets and not letting any other spinners a chance. Ravindra was as good if not better than Patel in the super smash and it was nearly at the end of the campaign he got a go. Clearly shows not having guts to tell your most experienced bowler you are no more the only thing and there is a youth cricketer probably as good as you or better. Point in case, in the last game Ravindra bowled about 8 overs to Patel's 40+ overs for probably 1 wicket.
3. How does it sound when your local team has no captain from the local side? Michael Bracewell is the captain in the 4 day format and Hamish Bennett in the white ball. How did they go ahead of other Wellington players such as Luke Woodcock, Steve Murdoch, Tom Blundell etc? That is very average from the coach. Clearly not showing enough respect to the local lads knowledge of cricket and experience. Don't tell me there hasn't been a single Wellington player not good enough to captain the team during Edgar's tenure.
4. What was the point in signing up 40 year old Marshall? He just slowed down the likes of Ravindra and others. He played for a year and half or more, earned some bucks and left mid way through. Last year he was elevated to captaincy if I'm correct for 4 day games as well for 1 game or something like that?
The likes of Ravindra, Jacob Bhula were all NZ Cricket picks. Had nothing to do with Edgar or the coaching staff or even Wellington cricket. I'm not happy to give credit to Wellington for their growth.