adharcric said:
SJS, I certainly rate Ramesh Powar about as much as I rate Harbhajan Singh. I wouldn't mind him getting a game, but I don't see it happening against the Aussies if we're only playing one spinner. With Tendulkar, Yuvraj and Sehwag in the side, I'm not sure if we need 2 specialist spinners.
I also dont think its going to happen but its worth a try. Powar has played in most of the matches India has played this year and his performance has been consistent.
Bhajji on the other hand is not the destroyer of batting line ups that he used to be.
Bhajjis' advantage is the doosra though his doosra has not been as effective of late. On the other hand his off spin is not causing concern to top batsmen. He is now resorting to flighting less in order to check the runs. This shows a decline for an off spinner.
His flight and trajectory that makes the ball appear to be a tempting half volley that dips at the last minute has ceased to exist. The moment he does decide to flight batsmen are taking him on because the flight is not deceptive and without flight he is not the bowler he was.
The problem with Bhajji is not impossible to rectify but Bhajji is unlikely to go to the masters like Prasanna and take advise (prasanna is on record saying how can I help him unless he asks me) and this is not something Greg Chappell is going to be able to teach him.
When an off spinner loses his 'loop', hed becomes a regular off spinner and murali, Harbhajan (in his earlier daysd) and Saqlain are not just regular spinners.
Lose the loop and a Prasanna becomes a Venktraghvan and thats a HUGE difference.
Harbhajan's droppping can actually do him good if it makes him think he has a problem. But he seems to think that its just that his luck is not favouring him. Thats a tragedy.
Powar has a natural loop. Its what makes him so easy to look at but still so rarely is he collared.
One more thing, Harbhajan is having lots of problems bowling to left handers which is a bad sign not only because off spinners should 'feed' on left handers but also because there is an unusually large number of left handers amongst the top order batsmen in the world today.