• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** 1st Test @ Perth, 22nd-26th November

K

kevinw

State Captain
Qlder said:
Renshaw just hit a hundred in a shield match and is playing India in the PM XI on 30th Nov. If he does well there it's time to get a real opener back for Australia (rather than a fabricated opener)
Click to expand...
Not convinced Bancroft or Harris will score if they get a Test return but Renshaw is still young enough to invest in. McSweeney should get the series though unless he is woefully out of his depth in the second test.
 
TimAngas

TimAngas

State Vice-Captain
TimAngas said:
Well will be interesting to see if there's a reaction to this from selectors or they double down. I don't think Australia have been as bad as the scorecard suggests (it was certainly easier to bat today) but there's definitely some warning signs in the batting effort and speeds from the quicks quite down. If they'd come out with the same intensity as they had after tea they might been able to make a match of it, but by then both openers looked in.
Click to expand...
Well I'm leaning towards wanting wholesale changes.

Bumrah is clearly terrorising our batting line up right now. To succeed for a long time at the top level I am inclined to think you need to come to some sort of inner peace at the summit. Marnus and Smith right now look like they're together blowing a bubble of ever more frantic neurotic energy and it is preventing them from making clear decisions under duress of the potential in-ducker. Marnus should probably be dropped for the next test, even though he made 90-odd in the last one; he looks too far gone.

Do we even have any proper front foot players in the Shield right now? The most consistent player in the Shield is Handscomb and his technique looks designed to be exploited by Bumrah. Maybe bring in someone like Ollie Davies to at least provide the energy and innocence of youth and a more enterprising style.
 
L

LangleyburyCCPlayer

State 12th Man
Qlder said:
Sack Cummins as captain as obviously his tinkering with the batting order is the problem.

Promoted himself to #8 and then Starc demoted to #9 out-batted him, so he made himself nightwatchman at #3 over Nathan Lyon who has done it forever...

Another case of someone batting well in a recent ODI game getting undeserved test skill credit 😉
Click to expand...
Starc should be the #8, but does it really matter who gets picked 8 and who gets picked 9? The nightwatchman call obviously went very wrong!
 
L

LangleyburyCCPlayer

State 12th Man
TimAngas said:
Well will be interesting to see if there's a reaction to this from selectors or they double down. I don't think Australia have been as bad as the scorecard suggests (it was certainly easier to bat today) but there's definitely some warning signs in the batting effort and speeds from the quicks quite down. If they'd come out with the same intensity as they had after tea they might been able to make a match of it, but by then both openers looked in.
Click to expand...
Ironically if India had got a middling score in the first innings they may well be in a worse position in the match, they got out early enough to get Australia in while the conditions were bowler-friendly. Still, while scoreboard pressure is a thing, and while India’s bowling is majestic, 107 ao and 12/3 is not good in anyone’s book, Labuschagne looking like a flat track bully these days, Khawaja and Smith look like they’re nearing the retirement home and McSweeney doesn’t look up to it
 
TimAngas

TimAngas

State Vice-Captain
LangleyburyCCPlayer said:
Ironically if India had got a middling score in the first innings they may well be in a worse position in the match, they got out early enough to get Australia in while the conditions were bowler-friendly. Still, while scoreboard pressure is a thing, and while India’s bowling is majestic, 107 ao and 12/3 is not good in anyone’s book, Labuschagne looking like a flat track bully these days, Khawaja and Smith look like they’re nearing the retirement home and McSweeney doesn’t look up to it
Click to expand...
I would give McSweeney more time but Cowan definitely looking exonerated about complaining he was an open-faced-slapper. Didn't really look like he wanted to meet the ball at all.
 
Son Of Coco

Son Of Coco

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Skyliner said:
According to the SMH -


STUMPS: Australia 3-12 chasing 534
‘That couldn’t possibly have gone worse for Australia.
To say they’re on the ropes is underselling it. They’ve already been knocked out. Barring some unprecedented form of cricketing miracle, India will rock up tomorrow and probably have the win officially in the bag before lunch.’
Click to expand...
Tomorrow is going.to be an hour or two watching us bound to the ropes whilst India punches the **** out of us.

Our bowlers.must be pretty shitty after the first innings. They did their job, and then the bats came out and ****ed it completely. Looks like only one half of the team got the memo to actually train in the lead up to this.
 
G

govinda indian fan

State Vice-Captain
kevinw said:
Not convinced Bancroft or Harris will score if they get a Test return but Renshaw is still young enough to invest in. McSweeney should get the series though unless he is woefully out of his depth in the second test.
Click to expand...
I would give macsweeny three tests before deciding. He played in seaming conditions in first dig and got worst conditions in second
 
Gob

Gob

International Coach
Well I was expecting India to win the series but this is coming as a bit of a surprise tbh. I expected both teams bowling to be very good and batting to suck equally making it a closer contest but this is a massacre its almost like Ashes 10/11 on steroids

It would be interesting how rest of the series would pan out. I felt they were a bit lethargic in their attitude coming in with India's home defeat to NZ and thought India can be pushed over. This will be one of the great wins if they turn it around as unlikely as it looks now
 
social

social

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Gob said:
Well I was expecting India to win the series but this is coming as a bit of a surprise tbh. I expected both teams bowling to be very good and batting to suck equally making it a closer contest but this is a massacre its almost like Ashes 10/11 on steroids

It would be interesting how rest of the series would pan out. I felt they were a bit lethargic in their attitude coming in with India's home defeat to NZ and thought India can be pushed over. This will be one of the great wins if they turn it around as unlikely as it looks now
Click to expand...
It’s only one test

I predicted 2-2 because both batting lineups are fragile and there will be plenty of collapses
 
Molehill

Molehill

Cricketer Of The Year
social said:
It’s only one test

I predicted 2-2 because both batting lineups are fragile and there will be plenty of collapses
Click to expand...
A number of series recently have seen the away side win the First Test but not the series. England in Pakistan with a similar hiding to kick things off.

Having said that, the future of this Aussie team when certain bowlers retire looks pretty average.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top