Are you sure Rawat is even half as good as Kaarthick behind the stumps?Dravid said:Rawat seems like a good prospect for the Indian team in the test matches. He hasn't done much in OD Cricket but his FC isn't bad. Already has 2 100s in his name and will hopefully get his third tomorrow. Has a strike rate of a test player, but wouldn't consider him an option for ODI. If he can get runs in the Ranji Trophy, he could give Karthik a run for his money.
BTW I'm most likely going to be back in time for the 3rd day of the first Delhi match, so I'm most likely gonna end up there.
Highly unlikely. Karthik was good when he was India's test keeper, but he's been absolutely brilliant in what I've seen of him since then (ie A tours, domestic cricket). I dare to say he's looked world-class behind the stumps, but of course the real test comes when you have to keep to Kumble and Bhajji.honestbharani said:Are you sure Rawat is even half as good as Kaarthick behind the stumps?
yeah, but even when he was with the national side, he looked like the only keeper since Mongia to be picking Kumble. And Bhajji is not as tough to keep to as Jumbo, IMHO.adharcric said:Highly unlikely. Karthik was good when he was India's test keeper, but he's been absolutely brilliant in what I've seen of him since then (ie A tours, domestic cricket). I dare to say he's looked world-class behind the stumps, but of course the real test comes when you have to keep to Kumble and Bhajji.
Yeah, I wasn't implying that Karthik struggled against Kumble and Bhajji. Just saying that his exceptional glovework in domestic cricket doesn't mean too much.honestbharani said:yeah, but even when he was with the national side, he looked like the only keeper since Mongia to be picking Kumble. And Bhajji is not as tough to keep to as Jumbo, IMHO.
The point is that I think for tests, the better keeper has to get in. For ODIs, the better batter.
AB de Villers...adharcric said:Yeah, I wasn't implying that Karthik struggled against Kumble and Bhajji. Just saying that his exceptional glovework in domestic cricket doesn't mean too much.
He is a very good keeper and I for one won't be devastated if Dhoni doesn't succeed in the test series in SA.
I want Dhoni to succeed, but in Karthik we have the best backup keeper-batsman in the world (well, Haddin is there).
Right, but he's already in the team as a batsman so he's not exactly a backup.chaminda_00 said:AB de Villers...
Yeah but if Boucher got injuried then De Villiers would probably take over the gloves, therefore back up keeper.adharcric said:Right, but he's already in the team as a batsman so he's not exactly a backup.
Yeah. Basically, my point is that India has one of three international-class backup keepers. Karthik is a good backup to have.chaminda_00 said:Yeah but if Boucher got injuried then De Villiers would probably take over the gloves, therefore back up keeper.
If this Pawat guy is international class then most sides would have atleast three.adharcric said:Yeah. Basically, my point is that India has one of three international-class backup keepers. Karthik is a good backup to have.
India do have three....Dravid.chaminda_00 said:If this Pawat guy is international class then most sides would have atleast three.
wtf ... when did I mention Rawat (Pawat?) at all? I said Karthik is one of three backup keepers who are very good (along with Haddin and ABDV)chaminda_00 said:If this Pawat guy is international class then most sides would have atleast three.
You said you will be coming to Mumbai on Thursday. Can you email me when you get there? I'm not too sure if I can give an email here; although someone already wants it.Dravid said:BTW I'm most likely going to be back in time for the 3rd day of the first Delhi match, so I'm most likely gonna end up there.
Send it to <arjun UNDERSCORE mohan 2000 AT yahoo DOT com>.predator_05 said:Arjun, do you have an email ? i got something to ask you.
You must have mistaken me with someone else. I never used the username Dravid on any other forums.Arjun said:Send it to <arjun UNDERSCORE mohan 2000 AT yahoo DOT com>.
Do you still post on the Sportnetwork forums? I've seen a few of your posts there. It doesn't seem a nice place...