capt_Luffy
Cricketer Of The Year
I will cut the ****ing rapist Sandeep Lamichhane first; the others I will add later.
Aiming to start the draft next Friday, unless I get busy in which case early the following week. So deadline is end Thursday (at the earliest)Super busy now and need more time to check and finalize. Will do the cutting later. What is the deadline for delisting?
Interesting selection. He hasn't played for Australia for years but I guess Ben could be an option for the World T20.cutting
FWIW I think that could cause more issues than it solves. At the moment everyone knows the category of vast majority of cricketers unless they are a youth prodigy - eg I picked Jaiswal as an OP last year when he wasn't in the DB - seeking clarification that was an okay pick at the time. But having clear player categories for players in the DB prevents disputes over interpretations and ensures the goalposts aren't changed - a drafter could argue they may have picked a player earlier in the initial draft if they could have picked them as a spinner rather than all-rounder or vice-versa.@Teuton
I've noticed a lot of the players roles are open to interpretation on your list ..
For example Mehidy Hasan Miraz is classified as SP (Spinner) and Santner is classified as AR (All Rounder) , but I think both are all rounders..
Mehidy even opened the batting at the odi wc and has more hundreds and 50's at international level than Santner, another example is Sikandar Raza is considered a MOB (Middle Order Bat) on the list but I feel he is more than that...
If for example a player like Raza becomes available, would you allow a contestant to consider him an all rounder even if you have him listed as an MOB ? Of course the contestants claim to change the playing role should be reasonable (You can't argue Bumrah is an OP for instance).
This response is pretty spot on. Of course many players could legitimately be viewed as one of 2 or even 3 categories. But after running this for years (and similar comps outside of CW) I have found it is best to keep it equal for all of the players and manageable for the admin by picking a category at the start of the year and sticking with it.FWIW I think that could cause more issues than it solves. At the moment everyone knows the category of vast majority of cricketers unless they are a youth prodigy - eg I picked Jaiswal as an OP last year when he wasn't in the DB - seeking clarification that was an okay pick at the time. But having clear player categories for players in the DB prevents disputes over interpretations and ensures the goalposts aren't changed - a drafter could argue they may have picked a player earlier in the initial draft if they could have picked them as a spinner rather than all-rounder or vice-versa.
Not a deal breaker either way for me but just my two-cents worth.
This has been considered in the past but adds a level of complexity that impacts the overall running of the comp.@Teuton
I've noticed a lot of the players roles are open to interpretation on your list ..
For example Mehidy Hasan Miraz is classified as SP (Spinner) and Santner is classified as AR (All Rounder) , but I think both are all rounders..
Mehidy even opened the batting at the odi wc and has more hundreds and 50's at international level than Santner, another example is Sikandar Raza is considered a MOB (Middle Order Bat) on the list but I feel he is more than that...
If for example a player like Raza becomes available, would you allow a contestant to consider him an all rounder even if you have him listed as an MOB ? Of course the contestants claim to change the playing role should be reasonable (You can't argue Bumrah is an OP for instance).
OuchI will cut :
Ibrahim Zadran
Fazalhaq Farooqi
Dilshan Madushanka
Axar Patel
Ravi Bishnoi
Marnus Labuschagne
Akeal Hosein
Saim Ayub