tooextracool
International Coach
arggh what i meant was that overall imran was better with the better bowling but theres no doubt that botham was the best batsman out of the 4.Swervy said:i will disagree..Bothams batting was better than Imrans on the whole,especially in those first 5 years of his test career.Imran for say all but his last 6 years or so was considered a decent lower order batsman,his technique developed into something a bit more solid and later on he was a good middle order batsman....dont just look at the averages of over 50 in the last few years...look at how many hundreds he got compared to Botham,that might be a more telling indication.
I will still go with Botham on this one over Imran
imran would get 9/10 with the ball and 7/10 with the bat
botham would get 7/10 with the ball and 8/10 with the bat.
imran=16
botham=15
and dont forget imran was the better captain of the 2 as well