• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

4th Test at the Gabba, Brisbane, 15 - 19 Jan 2021

Spark

Global Moderator
people know that "black sportsmen are Powerful and Athletic rather than Skillful and Intelligent" has been a trope in professional sports since black people started playing (western) professional sports and has been pretty thoroughly debunked, right
 

Red

The normal awards that everyone else has
What was the argument?

It shouldn't be controversial or considered racist) to note that people of West African origin are self-evidently way better than everyone else at some specific things.

But what did Hodge say?
Correct. A white man hasn’t won the Olympic 100 in 40 years, and basically all the guys who excel in it are west African in origin
 

cnerd123

likes this
He won't take a wicket in a hundred overs bowling that short of a length ****e, but at least he'll give someone else a rest.
he nearly had Saini with a pretty decent ball tbf. Hasn't been that bad today. Has the right pace and attributes for this surface and hasn't bowled a lot of bad balls.
 

Spark

Global Moderator
it's usually the case that when a bowling attack is disciplined their bad balls tend to not go for as many runs, because the batters are not in the right frame of mind to put them away.

But yea despite that Aus have lacked any real gameplan on getting the scorecard ticking. At least for India each player seems to have worked out a way to survive and score runs that suits them.
Well yeah but that's kind of the art of Test batting, making sure you do actually take advantage of bad balls when they come. Otherwise the whole "disciplined batting, wait for them to come to you" doesn't really work.
 

Aritro

International Regular
people know that "black sportsmen are Powerful and Athletic rather than Skillful and Intelligent" has been a trope in professional sports since black people started playing (western) professional sports and has been pretty thoroughly debunked, right
Was he making the rather than skillful and intelligent point?
 

honestbharani

Whatever it takes!!!
people know that "black sportsmen are Powerful and Athletic rather than Skillful and Intelligent" has been a trope in professional sports since black people started playing (western) professional sports and has been pretty thoroughly debunked, right
BC Lara the best big brain batsman I have seen.
 

Prince EWS

Global Moderator
What was the argument?

It shouldn't be controversial or considered racist) to note that people of West African origin are self-evidently way better than everyone else at some specific things.

But what did Hodge say?
It was more just that he kept bringing it up at weird moments.

If it was...

Co-comm: Hey Brad why you do think so many West Indians are fast bowlers and big hitters?
Hodge: Hmm I think possibly genetic factors are at play.

... then sure, but it was more like:

West Indian cricketer: *does a thing*
Hodge: omg those genetics ???

It was seriously cringe, and it went on for like three games before someone presumably told him to can it.
 

Aritro

International Regular
It was more just that he kept bringing it up at weird moments.

If it was...

Co-comm: Hey Brad why you do think so many West Indians are fast bowlers and big hitters?
Hodge: Hmm I think possibly genetic factors are at play.

... then sure, but it was more like:

West Indian cricketer: *does a thing*
Hodge: omg those genetics ???

It was seriously cringe, and it went on for like three games before someone presumably told him to can in.
Hahaha
 

Red

The normal awards that everyone else has
people know that "black sportsmen are Powerful and Athletic rather than Skillful and Intelligent" has been a trope in professional sports since black people started playing (western) professional sports and has been pretty thoroughly debunked, right
Fair jump to get where you are. Who said they aren’t “skilful and intelligent”?
 

Spark

Global Moderator
Was he making the rather than skillful and intelligent point?
by implication, imo. he was saying that T20 suited them more because of genetics, and it doesn't take incredible knowledge of the game to realise what skills are favoured in T20s over tests.

and also him constantly mentioning genetics was really, really strange.
 

Shri

Mr. Glass
It was more just that he kept bringing it up at weird moments.

If it was...

Co-comm: Hey Brad why you do think so many West Indians are fast bowlers and big hitters?
Hodge: Hmm I think possibly genetic factors are at play.

... then sure, but it was more like:

West Indian cricketer: *does a thing*
Hodge: omg those genetics ???

It was seriously cringe, and it went on for like three games before someone presumably told him to can it.
there was a bill burr bit where **** like this in the usa led to immediate firing lmao
 

Top