Line and Length
Cricketer Of The Year
Could you please delete your earlier post so I don't count twice. If you make an error, it is better if you just edit your incorrect original. Thanks.Ashwin
Pollock
Davidson
Could you please delete your earlier post so I don't count twice. If you make an error, it is better if you just edit your incorrect original. Thanks.Ashwin
Pollock
Davidson
Ashwin
Pollock
Davidson
Those who rate Ashwin tend to rate spinners as better than pacers, and also: the spinner vote is quite constrained by the pacer vote (and vice versa). Hence the spinner vote here sort of condenses down into Ashwin v not Ashwin (a position for which there are a lot of candidates), when that wouldn't necessarily be the case on a spinner poll (as long as that poll wasn't just counting first choices, a process by which Ash wins pretty easily).Laker, Grimmett and Verity are all getting a lot of votes too in the current poll, probably more than Ashwin. An example being yours above.
But how is that connected to putting pacers and spinners in same poll?
Yeah but that's not necessarily inaccurate. Surely part of the point of this poll is to see how people rate spinners as compared to pacers.Those who rate Ashwin tend to rate spinners as better than pacers, and also: the spinner vote is quite constrained by the pacer vote (and vice versa). Hence the spinner vote here sort of condenses down into Ashwin v not Ashwin (a position for which there are a lot of candidates), when that wouldn't necessarily be the case on a spinner poll (as long as that poll wasn't just counting first choices, a process by which Ash wins pretty easily).
Waqar and Holding already in.Waqar
Davidson
Holding
Oh sorry, misunderstood. Edited.Waqar and Holding already in.
All of these have already been voted into the Top 18 (see post 274). Too late to change.Younis
Steyn
Marshall
Just need to clarify are we listing the best at their peak or their career as a whole . I listed them at their peak for a Callander year .if this is for their entire career my list will change .
Apologies .All of these have already been voted into the Top 18 (see post 274). Too late to change.
We are currently voting to fill positions 19-21.
Voting is generally done over a carrer but each voter is entitled to their own interpretation.
S. Pollock
Ashwin
Philander
Ashwin
Pollock
Davidson