Harry brook vs kamindu mendis

[govinda indian fan]

Who is better test batsman

 

[Johan]

too early

 

[govinda indian fan]

too early

Iam saying who looks likely to be future atg

 

[sayon basak]

Iam saying who looks likely to be future atg

What if I say both? (or none?)

 

[govinda indian fan]

What if I say both? (or none?)

Ok. As you wish

 

[Thala_0710]

The one who knows how to play spin

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Jaiswal

 

[Johan]

The one who knows how to play spin

Brook's weakness with spin is there but is overstated, he can output as long as the pitch isn't a landmine.

 

[Thala_0710]

Brook's weakness with spin is there but is overstated, he can output as long as the pitch isn't a landmine.

Although it is T20 cricket, but the way he has played spin in the current, and it is apparent that he doesn't read it at all from the hand, is a big issue

 

[Johan]

Although it is T20 cricket, but the way he has played spin in the current, and it is apparent that he doesn't read it at all from the hand, is a big issue

he is definitely very limited against it, he seems to want to play backfoot against spin in test so he plays as late as possible and milk spin for singles, which is a viable strategy in test cricket but would obviously not work in Limited overs

 

[PlayerComparisons]

The ashes is Brooks main test. He needs to average like 45+ with 3+ hundreds in Aus. It will be tough though against an ATG like Cummins but Brook has the game to do well.

 

[Thala_0710]

The ashes is Brooks main test. He needs to average like 45+ with 3+ hundreds in Aus. It will be tough though against an ATG like Cummins but Brook has the game to do well.

I feel he will do well in the Ashes. It is obviously the most important series for any ENG Batsman. But IND would be his biggest test imo

 

[govinda indian fan]

I feel he will do well in the Ashes. It is obviously the most important series for any ENG Batsman. But IND would be his biggest test imo

There is no india tour till 2028 so we have to wait till then but he would do well in ashes

 

[PlayerComparisons]

Tbf even ATGs have a hole or two in their records so it’s not a big deal if he struggles in Ind imo. Just needs to make sure to succeed in Aus.