• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

**Official** 3rd Test @Brisbane (Ewwwww), 14th-18th December

social

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
Uzi turns 38 on Wednesday, Rohit is only a couple of months younger and Virat is 36

You could make a case for the first 2 being retired from tests already and Virat has been in decline for years
 

King Kane

International Regular
It looks like only one team can win this now, India's best hope is to get a draw and looking at the weather forecast the rain might help them get one.
 

Justo

U19 Debutant
Outside of the last ashes in Australia Khawaja has been poor in Australia since his return (SA, WI x 2 and PAK). All of his runs have been overseas (Pakistan, Sri Lanka, India and England) with the one overseas series failure in New Zealand. While he shouldn't get an unlimited run I wouldn't be so keen on writing him off based on that, the conditions and general lack of decent alternatives to open.

He's not been great but I wouldn't be surprised if he did well in Sri Lanka (assuming he sticks around and gets selected). Ultimately I think he's generally done a decent enough job to soak up the new ball. With the current conditions and Kookaburra it's really a matter of just trying to survive 30 overs and then cash in afterwards.

If he's keen I wouldn't be against keeping him around and maybe binning him next Ashes given his struggles in Australia.
 

Aritro

International Regular
I have just found out there has been a huge controversy because Isa Guha used a word that could easily be misinterpreted as a racial slur. It sounds like it has created a furore and Isa has been criticised in very strong terms by the media and online commentators.

Something like that has the scope to cause tremendous hurt and distress. IMO the only decent thing to do in this scenario would be for all of you to apologise to Isa Guha.
 

Gnske

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
I have just found out there has been a huge controversy because Isa Guha used a word that could easily be misinterpreted as a racial slur. It sounds like it has created a furore and Isa has been criticised in very strong terms by the media and online commentators. Something like that has the scope to cause tremendous hurt and distress and IMO the only decent thing to do in this scenario would be for all of you to apologise to Isa Guha.
Literally the only people complaining about it are pussies and virgins
 

Nintendo

Cricketer Of The Year
Outside of the last ashes in Australia Khawaja has been poor in Australia since his return (SA, WI x 2 and PAK). All of his runs have been overseas (Pakistan, Sri Lanka, India and England) with the one overseas series failure in New Zealand. While he shouldn't get an unlimited run I wouldn't be so keen on writing him off based on that, the conditions and general lack of decent alternatives to open.

He's not been great but I wouldn't be surprised if he did well in Sri Lanka (assuming he sticks around and gets selected). Ultimately I think he's generally done a decent enough job to soak up the new ball. With the current conditions and Kookaburra it's really a matter of just trying to survive 30 overs and then cash in afterwards.

If he's keen I wouldn't be against keeping him around and maybe binning him next Ashes given his struggles in Australia.
Huh? Top run scorer last time WI toured @46.3, 178 runs @44.5 in the windies tour before that. 209 runs @70 vs SA (196* was most of those runs, tbf). Pakistan he was the third leading run scorer, 220 runs @37. If you think an opener averaging 37 in his worst series is poor you need to check in to a mental health clinic.
 

vicleggie

State Vice-Captain
I have just found out there has been a huge controversy because Isa Guha used a word that could easily be misinterpreted as a racial slur. It sounds like it has created a furore and Isa has been criticised in very strong terms by the media and online commentators.

Something like that has the scope to cause tremendous hurt and distress. IMO the only decent thing to do in this scenario would be for all of you to apologise to Isa Guha.
Yeah I could see something bad coming from this, in terms of her mental health. She should take a break IMO

Perhaps back to ****ty old England for the winter may be the best medicine.
 

vicleggie

State Vice-Captain
Yeah it's a non-event manufactured to be controversial by clickbait reporting. Can't believe the attention it's getting.
If a white male commentator called Bumrah a 'primate', he'd never be seen in commentary again. Let's be honest.

Similar to tennis commentator Doug Adler calling Venus Williams' tactics "Guerilla mode", and was hounded out of tennis till he had a stroke.
 

Window

U19 Debutant
If a white male commentator called Bumrah a 'primate', he'd never be seen in commentary again. Let's be honest.

Similar to tennis commentator Doug Adler calling Venus Williams' tactics "Guerilla mode", and was hounded out of tennis till he had a stroke.
Yeah I know that's exacy the reason this is getting any air time and it's a false equivalence. Context matters and the fact of the matter is Guha is not a white male commentator, and it does not carry the same meaning coming from her as there's no colonial or racist history attached to it.
 

Justo

U19 Debutant
Huh? Top run scorer last time WI toured @46.3, 178 runs @44.5 in the windies tour before that. 209 runs @70 vs SA (196* was most of those runs, tbf). Pakistan he was the third leading run scorer, 220 runs @37. If you think an opener averaging 37 in his worst series is poor you need to check in to a mental health clinic.
Was only going from memory and definitely better than I had remembered. Overall though he's been better away from Aus (leading run scorer in Pakistan, India, England and potentially even Sri Lanka from memory) so given that no reason to dump him so quickly if he's still keen to play given we have SL and a potential WTC to come next.

Overall I think he's done well enough this series given the ball, conditions and Bumrah. Anytime Head comes in after 30 overs means the top order have done their job IMO.
 

Starfighter

Cricket Web: All-Time Legend
I'm the furthest thing from a declaration hawk and even I'm surprised that Aus played the innings to a finish, considering the stoppages.
 

cnerd123

likes this
Pant gets out defending a lot. Really has just one gear- maniac mode. Rohit should have come out ahead of him in this situation.
 

Top