• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

Jasprit Bumrah vs Malcolm Marshall

Bumrah vs Marshall at their peak

  • Bumrah

    Votes: 6 20.0%
  • Marshall

    Votes: 24 80.0%

  • Total voters
    30

DrWolverine

First Class Debutant
Bumrah’s average
In WI : 9 in 2 Tests
In Ind : 17 in 12 Tests
In Aus : 18 in 10 Tests
In SA : 21 in 8 Tests
In Eng : 26 in 9 Tests
In NZ : 31 in 2 Tests

In 2025 India will tour England for 5 Tests.
In 2026 India will tour NZ for 2 Tests.

If those two series turn out to be great for him and he can finish 300+ wickets at the same rate, he will be a strong contender for GOAT fast bowler
 

HouHsiaoHsien

International Debutant
Bumrah’s average
In WI : 9 in 2 Tests
In Ind : 17 in 12 Tests
In Aus : 18 in 10 Tests
In SA : 21 in 8 Tests
In Eng : 26 in 9 Tests
In NZ : 31 in 2 Tests

In 2025 India will tour England for 5 Tests.
In 2026 India will tour NZ for 2 Tests.

If those two series turn out to be great for him and he can finish 300+ wickets at the same rate, he will be a strong contender for GOAT fast bowler
In England also it’s above 25 cause of the WTc final against NZ. So there also his record is very good. It’s the performance in and vs NZ that is the only hole
 

subshakerz

Hall of Fame Member
Bumrah could also easily be asked to continue if his pace is gone, he becomes a third bowler and he averages 27/28 in the attack for a few latter years if there aren't better options.

So he could average 20 reaching 300 wickets and 22/23 by the end of his career.
 

Sliferxxxx

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
Bumrah would probably average around 11 if he had guys like Ambrose/Garner/Holding/Walsh/Bishop/Roberts bowling with him

Marshall was very lucky to have such a great pace attack around him
Umm no. Bumrah funny enough, however is bowling under very similar circumstances to Marshall imo. He's bowling as part of a strong attack, he's played most of his game overseas, he's bowling in an era where no team really has an atg batting lineup but a few are challenging. On his current trajectory and assuming he doesn't get injured, he may very well end up being the goat fast bowler......
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
Umm no. Bumrah funny enough, however is bowling under very similar circumstances to Marshall imo. He's bowling as part of a strong attack, he's played most of his game overseas, he's bowling in an era where no team really has an atg batting lineup but a few are challenging. On his current trajectory and assuming he doesn't get injured, he may very well end up being the goat fast bowler......
On a serious note, I just can't see Bumrah maintaining this form and playing long enough (atleast 6 more years) to really be an equal of Marshall-Hadlee-McGrath
 

subshakerz

Hall of Fame Member
No way. It would be crazy if that happens. Jasprit Bumrah taking 300+ wickets and ending with an average less than 20 would be crazy.

Walsh’s first half : 60 Tests. Avg of 25.
Walsh’s second half : 72 Tests. Avg of 23.
Just for reference, Pollock I believe reached 300 with a 20 average.

Marshall was 19/20, I think.
 

Sliferxxxx

School Boy/Girl Cricketer
No way. It would be crazy if that happens. Jasprit Bumrah taking 300+ wickets and ending with an average less than 20 would be crazy.

Walsh’s first half : 60 Tests. Avg of 25.
Walsh’s second half : 72 Tests. Avg of 23.
Barring injury and Indian board completely messing up, I don't see who stops him honestly. Away to England, i think he'll have a field day. He's currently cleaning up arguably the best batting lineup in world cricket in their own backyard. South Africa and WI have minnowesque batting at the moment so he'll feast against them. I can see him setting the record straight vs NZ who again don't have a particularly amazing batting line up. Ditto SL. So again assuming he remains in relatively good shape, I don't see why he can't remain sub 20 for the foreseeable future and end up as the goat. The caveat as always before people come out with their pitchforks is if he's FIT....
 

Top