• Welcome to the Cricket Web forums, one of the biggest forums in the world dedicated to cricket.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join the Cricket Web community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

All-Time India XIs - A re-run

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
CK Nayudu - 4

Pankaj Roy - 4
Nari Contractor - 2

KL Rahul - 1
Mayank Agarwal - 1

Venkatesh Prasad - 4
S Sreesanth - 2

Chetan Sharma - 1
Shardul Thakur - 1
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
India XIIndia AIndia BIndia C
1. SM Gavaskar1. VSM Merchant1. RG Sharma ⬆⬆⬆1. G Gambhir ⬇
2. V Sehwag2. MH Mankad ⬇2. FM Engineer+2 NS Sidhu ⬇⬇
3. RS Dravid3. CA Pujara ⬆ ⬆3. MB Amarnath ⬇3. PR Umrigar⬇⬇
4. SR Tendulkar4. VS Hazare4. DB Vengsarkar4. MAK Pataudi*
5. V Kohli5. GR Viswanath⬆5. M Azharuddin5. AM Rahane
6. RR Pant+ ✴6. VVS Laxman6. SC Ganguly*6. RJ Shastri
7. RR Jadeja ⬆⬆⬆7. MS Dhoni+* ⬇7. NB Amarnath⬆⬆7. SMH Kirmani+ ⬇⬇
8. N Kapil Dev*8. A Kumble ⬇8. LNA Singh ⬇8. H Singh
9. R Ashwin ⬆9. J Srinath ⬇9. I Sharma ⬆9. UT Yadav ⬆
10. MA Shami ⬆⬆⬆10. Z Khan ⬆10. BS Bedi ⬇10. EAS Prasanna ⬇
11. JJ Bumrah ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆11. BS Chandrashekhar ⬆11. S Gupte⬇⬇11. M Nissar ⬇⬇
India DIndia EIndia F
1. M Vijay ⬇⬇1. S Dhawan ⬇⬇1. P Roy ⬇⬇
2. YBK Jaiswal ✴2. BK Kunderan+ ⬇2. NJ Contractor ⬇⬇
3. DN Sardesai3. RS Modi ⬆3.
4. CG Borde*4. CK Nayudu*4.
5. VL Manjrekar⬇5. VG Kambli ⬇5.
6. DG Phadkar ⬆6. SM Patil ⬆⬆6.
7. WP Saha+ ⬇7. M Prabhakar ⬆7.
8. AR Patel ✴8. IK Pathan ⬇8.
9. BS Kumar ⬇⬇9. RG Nadkarni9. BKV Prasad ⬇
10. K Yadav ✴10. KD Ghavri ⬇10. SN Sreesanth ⬆⬆
11. M Siraj ✴11. S Venkataraghavan ⬆11.
 
Last edited:

Majestic

U19 Captain
I have not followed this thread so don't know but just wondering could Kumble have been a captain instead of MSD in Tests? MSD's captaincy is not rated highly in Tests.
 

Thala_0710

State 12th Man
He could have been but I'd prefer Dhoni. His captaincy in tests is overly criticized imo. He was a good and proactive captain tactically with field settings, bowling changes etc. Ofc, the transition period post 2011 was tough and Dhoni could have done better himself at certain points but I'd take him over most others. People forget that we actually became the test no 1 side under Dhoni for the first time in our history and beat NZ in NZ and drew against prime SA in SA. Also whitewashed Aus 4-0 at home
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
India XIIndia AIndia BIndia C
1. SM Gavaskar1. VSM Merchant1. RG Sharma ⬆⬆⬆1. G Gambhir ⬇
2. V Sehwag2. MH Mankad ⬇2. FM Engineer+2 NS Sidhu ⬇⬇
3. RS Dravid3. CA Pujara ⬆ ⬆3. MB Amarnath ⬇3. PR Umrigar⬇⬇
4. SR Tendulkar4. VS Hazare4. DB Vengsarkar4. MAK Pataudi*
5. V Kohli5. GR Viswanath⬆5. M Azharuddin5. AM Rahane
6. RR Pant+ ✴6. VVS Laxman6. SC Ganguly*6. RJ Shastri
7. RR Jadeja ⬆⬆⬆7. MS Dhoni+* ⬇7. NB Amarnath⬆⬆7. SMH Kirmani+ ⬇⬇
8. N Kapil Dev*8. A Kumble ⬇8. LNA Singh ⬇8. H Singh
9. R Ashwin ⬆9. J Srinath ⬇9. I Sharma ⬆9. UT Yadav ⬆
10. MA Shami ⬆⬆⬆10. Z Khan ⬆10. BS Bedi ⬇10. EAS Prasanna ⬇
11. JJ Bumrah ⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆⬆11. BS Chandrashekhar ⬆11. S Gupte⬇⬇11. M Nissar ⬇⬇
India DIndia EIndia F
1. M Vijay ⬇⬇1. S Dhawan ⬇⬇1. P Roy ⬇⬇
2. YBK Jaiswal ✴2. BK Kunderan+ ⬇2. NJ Contractor ⬇⬇
3. DN Sardesai3. RS Modi ⬆3.
4. CG Borde*4. CK Nayudu*4. SV Manjrekar
5. VL Manjrekar⬇5. VG Kambli ⬇5. Y Singh
6. DG Phadkar ⬆6. SM Patil ⬆⬆6.
7. WP Saha+ ⬇7. M Prabhakar ⬆7.
8. AR Patel ✴8. IK Pathan ⬇8.
9. BS Kumar ⬇⬇9. RG Nadkarni9. BKV Prasad ⬇
10. K Yadav ✴10. KD Ghavri ⬇10. SN Sreesanth ⬆⬆
11. M Siraj ✴11. S Venkataraghavan ⬆11. DR Doshi ⬇⬇
 

capt_Luffy

Cricketer Of The Year
Now please vote for:
A) One of Shubhman Gill or Jaisimha. As usual, no need to vote given you already did. Also @ma1978 voted for vote, so please specify your favoured candidate.
B) The no. 6 player
C) The wicketkeeper
D) Another bowler
 

Top