All-Time India XIs - A re-run

[Line and Length]

Phadkar
Nadkarni
Kuldeep

Ditto

 

[capt_Luffy]

Dattu Phadkar - 5
Sandeep Patil - 4

Kuldeep Yadav - 8
Axar Patel - 4
Bapu Nadkarni - 4
Karsan Ghavri - 2

 

[capt_Luffy]

India XI	India A	India B	India C
1. SM Gavaskar	1. VSM Merchant	1. RG Sharma	1. G Gambhir
2. V Sehwag	2. MH Mankad	2. FM Engineer+	2 NS Sidhu
3. RS Dravid	3. CA Pujara	3. MB Amarnath	3. PR Umrigar
4. SR Tendulkar	4. VS Hazare	4. DB Vengsarkar	4. MAK Pataudi*
5. V Kohli	5. GR Viswanath	5. M Azharuddin	5. AM Rahane
6. RR Pant+	6. VVS Laxman	6. SC Ganguly*	6. RJ Shastri
7. RR Jadeja	7. MS Dhoni+*	7. NB Amarnath	7. SMH Kirmani+
8. NK Dev*	8. A Kumble	8. LNA Singh	8. H Singh
9. R Ashwin	9. J Srinath	9. BS Bedi	9. UT Yadav
10. MA Shami	10. Z Khan	10. I Sharma	10. EAS Prasanna
11. JJ Bumrah	11. BS Chandrashekhar	11. S Gupte	11. M Nissar
India D	India E
1. M Vijay	1.
2. YBK Jaiswal	2.
3. DN Sardesai	3.
4. CG Borde	4.
5. VL Manjrekar	5.
6. DG Phadkar	6.
7. WP Saha+	7.
8.	8.
9. BS Kumar	9.
10. K Yadav	10.
11. M Siraj	11.

 

[capt_Luffy]

Now please vote for:
A) Those who haven't voted for any of them, either for Bapu Nadkarni or Axar Patel. @Teuton should also vote for his preferred option, as he voted for both.
B) The captain of India D
C) Two middle order batsmen
D) Two opening bowlers for India

 

[capt_Luffy]

Chandu Borde

CK Nayudu
Rusi Modi

Karsan Ghavri
Venkatesh Prasad

 

[Thala_0710]

Borde

Kambli
Gill

Ghavri
Pathan

 

[Bitmap]

Borde
Kambli
Nayudu
Ghavri
Prasad

 

[CricAddict]

Borde

Kambli
Nayudu

Ghavri
Irfan Pathan

 

[Teuton]

Axar

Borde

Kambli
Rusi Modi

V. Prasad
Ghavri

 

[ma1978]

Axar

Borde

Yuvraj Singh
Sandeep Patil

Pathan
Ramakant Desai

 

[ma1978]

On a side note not sure I see the case for V Prasad over I Pathan

 

[Thala_0710]

On a side note not sure I see the case for V Prasad over I Pathan

Yeah I agree actually, changing my vote to Pathan too

 

[Xix2565]

Chandu Borde

CK Nayudu
Vinod Kambli

Karsan Ghavri
Irfan Pathan

 

[capt_Luffy]

On a side note not sure I see the case for V Prasad over I Pathan

Among his 100 wickets in 29, he took 39 against BangZim in 4 @11. He costed 45 for each of his other wickets. I think Irfan should be in as an all-rounder.

 

[ma1978]

Among his 100 wickets in 29, he took 39 against BangZim in 4 @11. He costed 45 for each of his other wickets. I think Irfan should be in as an all-rounder.

fair argument. One of those cricketers who looked better than his results but he’s the AR.

 

[CricAddict]

Among his 100 wickets in 29, he took 39 against BangZim in 4 @11. He costed 45 for each of his other wickets. I think Irfan should be in as an all-rounder.

I have seen both of their careers completely. Prasad was such a limited and average bowler while Irfan was so good for a short period of time before he fell off.

 

[capt_Luffy]

I have seen both of their careers completely. Prasad was such a limited and average bowler while Irfan was so good for a short period of time before he fell off.

Can understand that sentiment. But really, his numbers against any strong team is outrageously bad. It might be that his form coincided with those 4 BangZim games, but overall, I will keep Prasad as a bowler higher. Strangely, his numbers as a batsman holds up pretty well, which I didn't honestly expect. Infact, they suffer due to Bangladesh!

 

[Fuller Pilch]

A) Axar

B) The captain of India D - not sure = pass

C) Yuvraj & Sandeep Patil
D) Prabbhakar & Irfan Pathan

 

[capt_Luffy]

Axar Patel - 3

Chandu Borde - 7

Vinod Kambli - 5
C K Nayudu - 4
Rusi Modi - 2
Sandeep Patil - 2
Yuvraj Singh - 2
Shubhman Gill - 1

Karsan Ghavri - 6
Irfan Pathan - 5
Venkatesh Prasad - 3
Manoj Prabhakar - 1
Ramakant Desai - 1

 

[capt_Luffy]

India XI	India A	India B	India C
1. SM Gavaskar	1. VSM Merchant	1. RG Sharma	1. G Gambhir
2. V Sehwag	2. MH Mankad	2. FM Engineer+	2 NS Sidhu
3. RS Dravid	3. CA Pujara	3. MB Amarnath	3. PR Umrigar
4. SR Tendulkar	4. VS Hazare	4. DB Vengsarkar	4. MAK Pataudi*
5. V Kohli	5. GR Viswanath	5. M Azharuddin	5. AM Rahane
6. RR Pant+	6. VVS Laxman	6. SC Ganguly*	6. RJ Shastri
7. RR Jadeja	7. MS Dhoni+*	7. NB Amarnath	7. SMH Kirmani+
8. NK Dev*	8. A Kumble	8. LNA Singh	8. H Singh
9. R Ashwin	9. J Srinath	9. BS Bedi	9. UT Yadav
10. MA Shami	10. Z Khan	10. I Sharma	10. EAS Prasanna
11. JJ Bumrah	11. BS Chandrashekhar	11. S Gupte	11. M Nissar
India D	India E
1. M Vijay	1.
2. YBK Jaiswal	2.
3. DN Sardesai	3. CK Nayudu
4. CG Borde*	4. VG Kambli
5. VL Manjrekar	5.
6. DG Phadkar	6.
7. WP Saha+	7.
8. AR Patel	8. IK Pathan
9. BS Kumar	9. KD Ghavri
10. K Yadav	10.
11. M Siraj	11.